By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Why try to disprove/disagree with religion?

ps3-sales! said:

My thoughts on premarital sex: I do think you should save it for marriage, but I don't think it's that big of a deal. I lost it at 19 (still 19) and didn't think twice about it. I don't think they (mainstream Christian media) promote abstinence as a meanings of just following what the bible says. I think that is a small part next to reducing prenancies and STD's, which is good in theory but they go about it wrong sometimes.

In my opinion, being that religions all around the world tend to have similar rules, the rules that organized religion are based on are generally related to the "evolution" of societies and are necessary building blocks for survival ...

There have been many studies by a variety of different organizations (some very conservative and some very progressive) and having more sexual partners prior to being married is linked to a higher rate of divorce; with a smaller number of partners the increase in the divorce rate was fairly minimal, but as the number of sexual partners increases the rate of divorce grows exponentially.

Beyond that there is the problems associated with children being raised without their father around, STDs, and (I suspect) the dangers brought about by having a large population of "Sexual Losers" due to a large portion of women sleeping with a small portion of highly desirable men there are a lot of negatives of a culture of promiscuous sex.

 

Ultimately, I wouldn't say that sex outside of marriage is wrong/bad but I do think we're seeing a lot of the consequences from it; especially in communities where it has been taken too far.



Around the Network
Runa216 said:

true, but religion gives people one more (pathetic) reason to kill one another.  And let's be honest, a LOT of people have died over which god has the bigger dick. 

I never said people didn't. But I doubt many "normal" Religious people want war over their beliefs. I sure don't, that's ridiculous.



ps3-sales! said:

My thoughts on gays as a Christian: I don't think you are born gay, but you might pick up very early in life who you are physically attracted to. Who are we to say you can just stop being attracted to the same sex? It doesn't work that way. Let them be and treat them with kindess, as they are normal people like everyone else. All this gay hate from Christians is not doing them any good. It just makes the gays stronger and work together more in order to get the rights they want. 

Oh my God, people still believe homosexuality is a choice? Did you choose to be straight? This is beyond stupid at this point.

DNA

" In the summer of 1993, Dean H. Hamer and his research team at the National Cancer Institute announced their discovered evidence of a connection between genetics and some male homosexuality. By constructing family trees in instances where two or more brothers are gay, and performing actual laboratory testing of the supposed homosexual DNA, Hamer located a region near the end of the long arm of the X chromosome that likely contains a gene influencing sexual orientation."

Source: Here

Psychology

"Many [scientists] think that nature and nurture both play complex roles; most people experience little or no sense of choice about their sexual orientation."

Source: Here

Mormon Church

"The Mormon Church has launched a new website, Mormonsandgays.org, to establish its official stance on homosexuality, saying that gay people were born this way, as it were."

Source: Here

 



Why should we follow anything? Everything Humanity does is fundamentally flawed, all I'm saying is your logic of questioning any particular religion isn't going to change (on average) someone's mind about said religion your pretty much talking to a brick wall so why waste your breath? (If I come off sounding as if I don't believe in God I'm sorry I do very much)



Runa216 said:
ps3-sales! said:

Loved this response, mainly because it's almost taking the words out of my mouth. I think we can all agree that the ignorance and stupidity on either side leads to distance and anger from each other. It's people like you that make me enjoy having a friendly debate on somewhat as fragile as someone's religion. Unfortunatley when the ignorant don't agree with you, it turns into idiotic namecalling and pure hate towards the other, which in turn gets thrown right back at them. No matter how religous you are, if you insult somebody, they will most likely insult you back. This spirials into years of religous hate and tumoil that evolves into events that can elevate to mass ethnic cleansing and other muderous acts. 

My thoughts on gays as a Christian: I don't think you are born gay, but you might pick up very early in life who you are physically attracted to. Who are we to say you can just stop being attracted to the same sex? It doesn't work that way. Let them be and treat them with kindess, as they are normal people like everyone else. All this gay hate from Christians is not doing them any good. It just makes the gays stronger and work together more in order to get the rights they want. 

My thoughts on premarital sex: I do think you should save it for marriage, but I don't think it's that big of a deal. I lost it at 19 (still 19) and didn't think twice about it. I don't think they (mainstream Christian media) promote abstinence as a meanings of just following what the bible says. I think that is a small part next to reducing prenancies and STD's, which is good in theory but they go about it wrong sometimes.

My thoughts on pushing religion on others: COULDN'T AGREE MORE. One of my biggest pet peeves as a Christian is how bad it other people make our beliefs sound by forcing them upon others, specifically parents on kids. Everyone needs to do their own research and journey in life to find their own way. 

Who said anything about friendly debate?  I'm not sure if you've noticed, but I'm pretty aggressive when it comes to wiping out the mess that is religious right. I mean, don't misunderstand, I don't think "All who disagree with me need to be eradicated." I've never thought that and it's the worst kind of mentality you can have, especially as one who considers himself to be an intellectual.  No, people misunderstand.  My hatred for religion isn't about having a different opinion and needing to censor it, it's about science.  It's always been about science and rationality and logic and progression.  I don't beleve that, as an encompassing theory, Religion should be respected unless it can quantify and justify its claims.  Until the religious can find even a shred of evidence supporting the existence of a god and that the events in the bible (or any holy text) happened as stated, it needs to be treated as the mythology it is. 

I don't mind people reading the bible, but I just don't understand the mentality of "This is how it happened becuase a book written thousands of years ago told me so, and the book also informed me it's infallible, therefore it is truth, end of discussion. No, I can't prove it, but I have faith and a billion friends who agree with me, so I must be right."  I know that sounds like a strawman argument, but that's basically what religious arguments boil down to.  The very idea that this stance needs to be respected not for its contributions to science and philosophy, but becuase many of us were raised in a nation where 'freedom of religion' is a thing, and mocking someone for thinking something so absurd is not acceptable.  

As for gays, I don't care if it is a choice, or if it is genetic, or if it can be cured or if it needs to be fixed, I see no issue with it.  If my neighbours are gay, it doesn't impact me in any way whatsoever, so I have no right to push my morals on them regardless.  That should be in effect on a global scale.  My 'morality' comes down to something very simple:  "if your actions are harming someone else, then it is not cool.  Otherwise, have fun, do what makes you happy and don't be ashamed of who you are."  This goes for pretty much everything in life, from what entertainment you enjoy right down to your body.  Your body is really your last bastion of freedom, you should be able to do what you want with it, it's your decision and your choice to balance the risk/reward.   Even if being gay DOES lead to HIV (it doesn't, but for the sake of argument let's say it does), then you need to decide if being with the one you love is worth that risk, and nobody has any right to judge you for it unless you're spraying HIV blood in the ketchup containers at the work cafeteria.  

As for premarital sex, as a man who doesn't believe in religion, I fail to see why you should save sex for some arbitrary signing of a paper.  I just don't see the correlation.  Hell, even when I did think sex was some holy thing that needed to be on a pedestal as some special intimate bond, I didn't see why you'd need to not do something you enjoy (as long as you're doing it safely and responsibly) just so you can wait so OTHERS deem you acceptable to have intercourse.  I just don't see the need for the correlation at all, and it seems so silly.  I won't even get into my thoughts on sex, intimacy, and love in this thread.  

The funny thing, I'm kind of amazed nobody's gone "oh, but you're pushing your beliefs on us" yet.  It's kind of an 'equal and opposite reaction' thing.  I only push back against religion when it pushes on me, my friends, or my ideals.  I maintain that if I could go without hearing about some religiously motivated terrorist attack or battle over teaching intelligent design over evolution or some instance where some woman was stoned to death for not marrying her rapist or some parents who starved their kid to cure him of the devil becuase he didn't want to read his bible, I honestly wouldn't even give two shits.  Let crazy people think crazy things, just keep it far away from me and I'll simply chose not to associate myself with them, but as soon as I see an instance of someone using religion to influence politics or education or violently protest things they have no right to protest based on some outdated unsubstantiated nonsense, I feel the need to fight back.  

I actually grew up in a religious household surrounded by religious people, so I grew up a pretty active christian.  it wasnt till I was 16 that I realized that science and religion could not really mix and I decided to go the path of the intellectual and abandon religion...which was met with scorn and hatred, or plain old judgement.  One person tried to tell me "God has put doubt in your heart so you could come back with greater faith" without realizing how crazy he sounded.  

Anyway, I rant too much.  

You shouldn't do religion, becuase religion is bad.  And if you don, just...stick to other religious people, don't try to get into an argument with people who reject your religion, becuase you will lose.  even if you're arguing with another religion, you always lose because there is no way to 'win' a religious debate, since there is no way to justify one religion over another.  

The teachings and life of Jesus are the exact opposite of the religious 'straw man' you've presented. People naturally want to feel superior even without religion, some wrongfully use Christianity (though they would have to completely ignore the words of Jesus to be the way you describe), others, like you, use science, logic, and their own perceived intelligence to build their brand of self-importance and superiority. Your crusade against Religion certainly has some elements of truth about certain vocal ones who misuse religion, but it has turned you into the exact thing you claim to hate. You are the atheist version of the fundamentalist Christian straw man you describe.

EDIT: Also, you ask for undeniable natural proof of the supernatural, which is by definition impossible. This would be akin to asking a being who lives in a two dimensional world to prove or disprove the existance of a 3rd dimension. It would be impossible due to the natural limiatations on how that being is able to observe their surroundings. If the Spiritual world is by definition another dimension, outside of the time and space we are constrained to, we have no direct way of observing it or testing it. You have created a set of constraints for your thinking that make it impossible for you to think outside your own logical box.

Just for the sake of argument, since your logical process takes place entirely inside your own mind, and is influenced by your own personal experiences, upbringing, and multiple other factors specific to you, how can you be certain that those logical processes are propor? How can you be certain the logical process of others on who's work you base your own logic is propor? Can our own thinking (which is just electrical impulses taking place inside our mind) be used to verify itself, or is that circular reasoning? Is there any impirical, provable evidence to show that our minds don't have flaws that cause our logical reasoning to be wrong? This would be impossible since we would in theory be judging our own flawed logical processes using that same flawed logical process, naturally leading to a flawed conclusion without our knowledge. I'm not saying logic should not be used, it absolutely should, I'm just saying that holding your own logic up as the absolute truth is just as arrogant as what you rail against. Many, many people with greater intelligence than either of us have used logic to come up with very different opinions on a myriad of subjects.

EDIT2: You say Religion is bad, I counter that "Pure and undefiled religion before our God and Father is this: to look after orphans and widows in their distress and to keep oneself unstained by the world. " Take a look at Mother Teresa's life and tell me that true religion is bad. You're judging something based entirely on how it is misused. I'm going to start a crusade against kitchen kinves because they are used in murders, nevermind that is not their purpose.



Around the Network
dsgrue3 said:
ps3-sales! said:

My thoughts on gays as a Christian: I don't think you are born gay, but you might pick up very early in life who you are physically attracted to. Who are we to say you can just stop being attracted to the same sex? It doesn't work that way. Let them be and treat them with kindess, as they are normal people like everyone else. All this gay hate from Christians is not doing them any good. It just makes the gays stronger and work together more in order to get the rights they want. 

Oh my God, people still believe homosexuality is a choice? Did you choose to be straight? This is beyond stupid at this point.

DNA

" In the summer of 1993, Dean H. Hamer and his research team at the National Cancer Institute announced their discovered evidence of a connection between genetics and some male homosexuality. By constructing family trees in instances where two or more brothers are gay, and performing actual laboratory testing of the supposed homosexual DNA, Hamer located a region near the end of the long arm of the X chromosome that likely contains a gene influencing sexual orientation."

Source: Here

Psychology

"Many [scientists] think that nature and nurture both play complex roles; most people experience little or no sense of choice about their sexual orientation."

Source: Here

Mormon Church

"The Mormon Church has launched a new website, Mormonsandgays.org, to establish its official stance on homosexuality, saying that gay people were born this way, as it were."

Source: Here

 



I'm sorry, but I'm having a difficult time finding where he said being gay was a choice. Maybe you could bold it for me? Perhaps you should turn your rage meter down a notch and you will stop seeing things you want to see.

Atheism is the new religion. That might not make sense to some but it depends on the angle you look at it.
Some atheist hold extreme hate for any religion and those that practice it.

Without even releasing it they themselves are becoming the thing they claim to hate most.
Like the way the catholics of the past persecuted the non-believer, the atheist will do the same to believers in future. Hate doesn't need a god or religion on both sides.

That's my prophecy. Read all about in The Word According to Justinian. Out soon in all good bookshops and e-book retailers. Pick it up.



What I really don't understand is how you can believe in the stories/anecdotes in the bible. You can't prove them, everybody and their mother knows the bible has been modified to fit a specific agenda from many different rulers/priest/etc, and then you get the luxury to pick and choose what you want to follow. You can say Fuck gays, they're a bunch of immoral monsters, but eating shrimps and other crustaceans is cool. The bible (from what I have read/seen/searched) literally tell you to hate them, both gays and crustaceans. It also tells you stone disobedient children TO DEATH but we certainly don't do that. I believe (please correct me if wrong) this is all the old testament so we don't give 2 shit and a rat's ass about but except for the gays.

To add insult to injury, I've seen many people say that the bible is open to interpretation and that people have different ways of interpreting God's words. BULLSHIT. Not only do you not acknowledge the bible's obvious flaws as it pertains to our modern society, but now it's open for you to pick and choose. Come on. How can, and here is the kicker, "the word of GAAAWWWDDD" be open to interpretation?

If I offend anybody, i really don't care quite honestly. I don't affiliate with any religion, not even atheism but my parents had christian catholic upbringings and they believe in a higher power but they did not force us to go to church which i cannot thank them enough not brainwashing me at a young age. Because of that, I get to explore different religions with an open mind and I decided they're all pretty meh.  I wish I had the drive to read through the entire thing because i do feel very hypocritical for bashing it while not having read it. If anything, the bible and religion had a purpose in our world at one point. It helped us give reason to things we could not understand. It gave us peace of mind knowing that some things just happen cause God said so. That isn't the case anymore. We are a still evolving species that is becoming more technologically advanced as the centuries pass and we figure out more and more things as we progress, while all the previous events we attributed to god will become smaller and smaller because they will facts to back up the scientific reason for those events happening.

Ok, done ranting. All in all, you can believe what you want to believe. I think it's silly and childish that this day in age we look up to a book writen by MEN. Flawed men like you and I and all of us here in VGC but that's my biased opinion. I will never understand religious believe. I just can't wrap my head around just hoping that shit will happen. Timmy is fighting cancer? Oh god will save him. Bullshit.

EDIT: I just proof read this wall to be little less aggressive and spelling. Also, some people bring up a good point about religions and their members involving politics to get their own ideas and laws across.



"Trick shot? The trick is NOT to get shot." - Lucian

Jay520 said:

I'm sorry, but I'm having a difficult time finding where he said being gay was a choice. Maybe you could bold it for me? Perhaps you should turn your rage meter down a notch and you will stop seeing things you want to see.

Not directly, but he certainly insinuated it was. He says he does not think you are born gay, which means genetics plays no role despite scientists believing that epigenetics plays a vital role at the very least, and entire control at best.

Source: Here

"Italian researchers have made a new discovery that solidifies the understand that homosexuality — at least in men — has a strong genetic component. Though this study does not identify a specific gay gene, which probably does not exist, it does demonstrate what role genetics play."

Source: Here

ps3-sales! said:

My thoughts on gays as a Christian: I don't think you are born gay, but you might pick up very early in life who you are physically attracted to. Who are we to say you can just stop being attracted to the same sex? It doesn't work that way. Let them be and treat them with kindess, as they are normal people like everyone else. All this gay hate from Christians is not doing them any good. It just makes the gays stronger and work together more in order to get the rights they want. 

Bolded since apparently you can't read if it isn't in bold as per your own admission.



Areym said:

What I really don't understand is how you can believe in the stories/anecdotes in the bible. You can't prove them, everybody and their mother knows the bible has been modified to fit a specific agenda from many different rulers/priest/etc, and then you get the luxury to pick and choose what you want to follow. You can say Fuck gays, they're a bunch of immoral monsters, but eating shrimps and other crustaceans is cool. The bible (from what I have read/seen/searched) literally tell you to hate them, both gays and crustaceans. It also tells you stone disobedient children TO DEATH but we certainly don't do that. I believe (please correct me if wrong) this is all the old testament so we don't give 2 shit and a rat's ass about but except for the gays.

To add insult to injury, I've seen many people say that the bible is open to interpretation and that people have different ways of interpreting God's words. BULLSHIT. Not only do you not acknowledge the bible's obvious flaws as it pertains to our modern society, but now it's open for you to pick and choose. Come on. How can, and here is the kicker, "the word of GAAAWWWDDD" be open to interpretation?

If I offend anybody, i really don't care quite honestly. I don't affiliate with any religion, not even atheism but my parents had christian catholic upbringings and they believe in a higher power but they did not force us to go to church which i cannot thank them enough not brainwashing me at a young age. Because of that, I get to explore different religions with an open mind and I decided they're all pretty meh.  I wish I had the drive to read through the entire thing because i do feel very hypocritical for bashing it while not having read it. If anything, the bible and religion had a purpose in our world at one point. It helped us give reason to things we could not understand. It gave us peace of mind knowing that some things just happen cause God said so. That isn't the case anymore. We are a still evolving species that is becoming more technologically advanced as the centuries pass and we figure out more and more things as we progress, while all the previous events we attributed to god will become smaller and smaller because they will facts to back up the scientific reason for those events happening.

Ok, done ranting. All in all, you can believe what you want to believe. I think it's silly and childish that this day in age we look up to a book writen by MEN. Flawed men like you and I and all of us here in VGC but that's my biased opinion. I will never understand religious believe. I just can't wrap my head around just hoping that shit will happen. Timmy is fighting cancer? Oh god will save him. Bullshit.

EDIT: I just proof read this wall to be little less aggressive and spelling. Also, some people bring up a good point about religions and their members involving politics to get their own ideas and laws across.

Your post just sounds angry. Why do you harbor so much hatred? If there is one thing that I am most thankful for my religion, it's a peace of mind. I'm not telling you what to believe, but maybe you should take some yoga classes and clam yourself down :)

It's alright to look for answers, it's what we are here for. But don't do so with anger and bitterness. It only makes it more difficult for yourself.



Currently own:

 

  • Ps4

 

Currently playing: Witcher 3, Walking Dead S1/2, GTA5, Dying Light, Tomb Raider Remaster, MGS Ground Zeros