I'm surprised a Mod hasn't replied to this thread... yet.

I dont think that argument holds any weight though. All three threads did the same thing. irrespective of who the poster was. One maybe better than the other but still the same thing.

I also find it weird that Rol gets a free pass...where is known to be a massive troll. If a new poster came here and posted the stuff he does they will get permabanned. Instantly.

So yeah, i don't agree with the focus on any single one of them. All of them should be banned or not banned.

I think you have this confused Jaywood. MBP got banned because his post was "lame". Honestly I don't know how you could compare those three threads against eachother. MBP didn't really make a funny thread there, maybe it is a case of a bad sense of humor but he could have made a much much more interesting comedic thread. These types of threads aren't really trolling, or to be taken serious. MBP's thread was short, not thought provoking, very limited target of satire, and even cursed in it. While probably a decent chuckle in spoken word, not something to write a thread about and therefore crossed lines with what can be misconstrued by the users here.

I 100% agree with you.

I did and asked in the report that I want an answer for why this is allowed but not Man Bear pig's.  I know they have read my questions and they are not giving me an answer.  I dont want to ask just one moderator either, I want multiple moderators to answer this. 

One word (Green_Sky said it) - Reputation.

I guess being a long time VGChartz user means you don't have to follow the rules.

Well its pretty clear hypocrisy. They are the exact same threads.

I wouldnt really know how to answer this if i were a mod. Also i dont think they intentionally didnt ban the one etc.

They probably thought "Oh its a rol thread, its fine" Thats even if it was reported. Same thing would apply to galaki as he also has a bit of a following.

Then they saw MBP who is really not liked by most of the community and he probably got reported = ban.

Take from that what you will.

That being said it could also be a case where MPB's thread could be seen as more malicious intended than the other two. The other two atleast attempt to make jokes and be funny. Rol most of taken half hes day to type up that shit. Maybe points for effort of trolling??? But yeah again I dont get who will judge that...someone might find MBP's thread hilarious.

That's also the impression I have. It's unbelievable what kind of shit gets past the mods by some users (not referring to the Galaki, MBP and Rol threads here)

didn't know that.  well that's lame.

is this in website issues? you are to smart for me to answer this one. it seems some mods are unclear on this. i think a mod should be asked before making that kind of thread.