albionus said: Strife said: IMHO, The Wii is several steps backwards in gaming. I don't want a cheap system with hundreds of boring second/third party games (with a handful of great first party games), I want a powerhouse system with a wide variety of killer-aps. ------------------------------ Actually, as of right now my current system of choice is a PS2. |
Logical fallacy alert, logical fallacy alert, danger, danger, Will Robinson, that does not compute... I could go on with computer based error messages but I think you get the point. |
OT ALERT! actually, this isn't a logical fallacy (unless you're talking about the false dichtomy of the second sentence, but I assume by the ---'s you're talking about how he likes the PS2)
While saying "I want a powerhouse system" "I like the PS2" is a contradictory statement, it's not actually a logical fallacy.
I agree with you, I just don't like hearing "logical fallacy" being thrown around when it's not true.
Anyway, back on topic:
Kwaad: The simple matter is that games will be made to the market. The basics of Capitalism which we all live with is that while there is a valid market, companies will rise to fill that market, because they can make money. As such, all our needs are met.
What does this have to do with your point? Quite simple. The addition of more "casual" games does not mean that the hard-core gamers are going away. The people who like long, complex RPGs will not suddenly become casual gamers playing warioware, nor will they simply disappear, but they will still be there. So long as there are people who want these things, then they will be made. If companies think they can make more money on cheap casual games they will start making cheap casual games until the market is flooded and it's no longer financially viable to make them. However, the size of the hardcore user base will not shrink by any action of Nintendo (More likely to be the cause of Sony releasing a system at a price no-one wants to pay. Yes, even people who like long RPG's may decide not to spend $1000 on a games console).
If the hardcore market is the same size, then the same number of companies will work there. They may be overshadowed by the much larger new market that Nintendo may create, but that doesn't mean it's smaller, it just looks smaller due to a much larger similar market. What this means, is either the current developer studios get larger, or more studios are created to tap the new market.
So in the end, we have a much larger market, with a niche market of hardcore gamers. Niche markets are still just as profitable, and the shrinking and growing of that niche market will be done by the games companies that make games for that market. If it shrinks, it will not be the fault of Nintendo, or any company that makes small casual games, but the fault of those companies that exploit the market that is falling.
So don't worry about the Wii. So long as there are hardcore gamers there will be hardcore games. Capitalism demands it, and it (mostly) works.