thanks mario
supermario128 said: Let me reiterate my first point. You are a vanilla townie. Even if you were bussed we are not losing any power roles. The reward of you being mafia is much greater than any risk involved. We are lucky that Spuge was even able to hear Stefl's results. We can't let that go to waste... |
To be fair, this is the best argument that's been brought forth by far, despite it being horribly flawed. As I mentioned this is a small game, every townie counts.
Final-Fan, do you have a night ability?
19:44:34 | Skeezer | METAL GEAR ONLINE |
19:44:36 | Skeezer | FAILURE |
19:44:51 | ABadClown | You're right! |
19:44:55 | ABadClown | Hur hur hur |
19:45:01 | Skeezer | i meant |
19:45:04 | Skeezer | YOU ARE A FAILKURE |
19:45:08 | Skeezer | FAILURE* |
happydolphin said: And whether Spurge got GF Ninja result or happyd is a GF Ninja, it's the same diff as bus-driving causes any action made on target A reflect on target B. So where B would have yielded "B is GF Ninja", it now says "A is GF Ninja". |
Actually, no! If an action is redirected, the result stays the same, but the player changes. If B is a GF Ninja and A is a Townie and the action is redirected onto A, it will say "A is a Townie" or it will give a more ambiguous result of "Townie". Otherwise, the role PM would be lying.
happydolphin said:
To be fair, this is the best argument that's been brought forth by far, despite it being horribly flawed. As I mentioned this is a small game, every townie counts. |
You think that "Final Fan voted no lynch" is a stronger argument than "I have a guilty on you?".
I am ending any idea that happy could be bus-driven town.(Or even an action being redirected) There's no way that scum would swap a townie with a ninja godfather. It does nothing to help them in any way,(save a town rolecop) whereas swapping a townie with any normal(as in scanning guilty) scum could mess up lots of scans.
Coincidentally, rolecop is the action Stefl must have taken in order for the masons to know what happy is.
Spurge, you're certainly a mason since nobody has counterclaimed. But would you be so kind as to confirm that what I said is true. We all know the possible repercussions of faking information, even if it won't mean your mislynch.
***Dark Thanatos ***
Can you please clarify Nacho's point regarding the scan on a bus driving scenario?
Nachomamma8 said:
You think that "Final Fan voted no lynch" is a stronger argument than "I have a guilty on you?". |
It doesn't work that way though. The two views aren't in competition. One was done on day 1, where we have little to no information on each other, the other is done day 2, where night 1 actions are unpredictable and where fakeclaims are still possible.
prof had a roleblocker to counteract stefl's investigation, doctor protect, anything he wanted. i'm guessing stefl's joat also had something like a tracker or a normal cop, which would mean that happy would be immune to the tracker as well as the normal cop. goon would be immune to the rolecop, which seems pretty good balance to me. it's no more ridiculous than a cop in a 3 man mafia setup; cop could hypothetically take out two mafia in two days, but it's just not that likely.
happy, you are calling the reasoning for voting you now "horridly flawed" while i'm assuming your own reason for voting final fan is still pretty solid? so yeah, it matters.