i think it depends on if you like onrail games more than if you like Fable or not

everyone knew it was going to be on rails, it looked terrible and hope MS finally realizes kinect is a failure and at best it should supplement the 360 controller.

actual no, when it was first annoucened. Peter M, swore up and down the game wasnt going to be on rails then it vanished for awhile, then from the demo people deduced that it would be in fact on rails. IMHO its a good decision at the very least this game is now playable. Cant imagine how Pete planned to make the game not on rails

how about we only post review threads for games that score 80 and above on metacritic?? That way soft people dont get there feeling hurt and fans of the game could feel there taste and life has meaning