When new player's are too stubborn to compromise or see where their logic may fail them, they are newb town. I have to add that to my newb tells' list. I've seen it too many times now.

That leaves my J0, Zero, Linkz scum trio theory dead in the water. I still think at least J0 is scum though.

I wanna hear it ^_^

Because you touch yourself at night. No, I won't say it, yet. But I will meta like I promised.

OP specifically mentions that Fluttershy and Applejack are not in the game ( as someone mentioned very early. I overlooked it then but now I kinda agree)

This means, in my head at least that there multiple Twilight's, Pinkies, Rainbows, and Rarity's. I know that F-F says nameclaims are non beneficial to either/all factions, but I disagree. The way I see it there are 3 of the 4 mane ponies. And since I think it would be careless and unjustifiable for F-F to not include at least a couple support cast members and antagonists from the show, the remaining three players are 3 of the following : Princess Celestia, Spike, Princess Luna, or Discord.

Since Final Fan was kind enough to mention the elements of harmony are mafia, and since each main pony represents an element, that means one of the 3 copies of each Mane pony is an imposter/mafia. So if we had a mass role claim, we can pincer one  mafia per 3 players, then through reasoning and leads, we flush out the imposter.

A third faction is likely to be within the supporting cast of name claims.

This is all fun meta that you may or may not agree with but I felt like mentioning it anyway.

1-Jesus Christ Zero! You asked me why I thought you were town initially and I liked you to TWO posts where I explained it.

2-Jesus fucking Christ Zero! You don't need me to point this out because you already responded to THAT POST after I linked you. You just brushed it off as, "oh not why you think I was town but why you think I'm scum."  seriously. Go back and read and at least show me that you are capable of referring to posts that are mentioned in this game so I can at least acknowledge that you trying to reason with me.

This is getting ridiculous. YOU are ridiculous! Notice How when Pezus asked me questions earlier how I responded without asking for links. Show common courtesy and show that you are putting the effort in the game by doing your own history. Look at this game and you will see that a lot of people rely on their own tabs, resources and links to respond. Stop being so damn lazy. It wouldn't have been so insulting if you didn't ask me the same questions at least twice already.

There are certain times to kindly ask for links but you are just being silly now.

That's why I think it's lame when I answered  Hatz question. Soleron also fits it my criteria that I really don't like people that votes in the middle. Obviously a lot of thing might change when more info. became available.

Radish is also in there but he hinted a power role. He is on my null read fro now.

What do you mean you think it's lame? And you didn't really answer my question. Unless you mean that if Soleron was one of the first couple voters or say an L-1 vote that it wouldn't have been suspicious?

Not really, but like Hatmoza said... I think we would greatly benefit from a mass name claim. That way, when we do lynch a mafia we KNOW the other two people who are the same pony are in fact town. If there are three of each pony and then 3 other characters then everyone might as well name claim now. It will only hurt town and help mafia if we don't.

I am Twilight Sparkle.

Interesting. You could be right about this, actually. I'm not sure if FF would allow the mafia to talk during the day or not, but Zero seems to think they can when we really shouldn't know either way.

I'll change my FoS on him to a HoS.

No, I am not a verified miller... What are you trying to get at here? Please direct me to any questions I have missed and I would be glad to answer them for you. I don't think I am acting strange at all. As far as being absent, I don't see that either. The last time I was mafia was when Prof, Wiibox, and I won. Two rounds ago. I don't know how you could have forgotten that already. :P

I know I'm late, but I guess the best answer is player development. I learn from past games that certain topics lead to certain discussions. And I'm just sometimes careful to avoid topics I really don't want to get into. Specifically when those topics have been discussed and beaten to death in previous games.