By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 45: Friendship is Mafia

Linkzmax on 28 August 2012
zero129 said:
spurgeonryan said:
His reason is because I called NoCtis a lurker Zero. Just a few posts back.

Well that doesnt seem like a very good reason as i think its clear for all to see that Noctis has been lurking and he even said so himself.

This has just made me highly suspect of Stefl after that post.

Ill see what his reply is to me before i post my suspicions later

Why are you going by the votee's reason for the vote instead of reading the voter's reason yourself? Heck even a third-party's explanation should carry more weight.



VGC Mafia Archives

Around the Network
mantlepiecek on 28 August 2012
pezus said:
Linkzmax said:

Why did you name me there when I'm not listed in your Notes? Did you mean to include me as "hiding in the shadows"?

wth! Yes, you should have been in the "hiding in the shadows" list. Nothing to fear there, that comes later, for this was just a list of people who hadn't posted much in a while. Prof came up with an excuse, so it was really only mantle who was "lurking". But now he comes in after being called out and talks about a long forgotten post from Soleron. As a townie, that makes it seem to me like he's trying to set me up for a lynch. We'll see what he comes up with later on.

Not posting for a while shouldn't be such a surprise when I specifically said that I will be resting on this thread for a while.



Linkzmax on 28 August 2012
theprof00 said:
In response to linkz a little while back, no, I did mean noctis about who to watch

I would be mortified if a watcher existed and thought Noctis to be a good target because of a single "Dr." Evil post. But that's not really a discussion that will serve well to get into.



VGC Mafia Archives

mantlepiecek on 28 August 2012
pezus said:
mantlepiecek said:

Not posting for a while shouldn't be such a surprise when I specifically said that I will be resting on this thread for a while.

Yes, but the question is...why would you want to "rest on this thread"? That is an easy cover if you want to lurk. Not to mention that after your "rest" you point out Soleron's post who targeted me for the sole reason of not having anything significant to say. You could say I was "resting" at the time. Resting on the thread does not give you a free pass.

I would want to rest on this thread because of a lot of reasons. Which is why I now have to re-read.

The reason why I bought up Soleron's post now is simple: when he posted it I was behind Radish. At that time I saw that he had a good argument but didn't mention it since I wanted to concentrate on radish myself.



Linkzmax on 28 August 2012
pezus said:
Linkzmax said:

pezus said:

Notes: Hatmoza, prof, stefl, noctis, moreno (obviously), mantle, mario and yoshi to an extent have all been hiding in the shadows for a while now.

Out of those hatmoza, linkz, mario haven't logged in recently. Mantle and especially prof have recently though but no comments. Noctis and stefl have entered but not with many things to say.

Why did you name me there when I'm not listed in your Notes? Did you mean to include me as "hiding in the shadows"?

wth! Yes, you should have been in the "hiding in the shadows" list. Nothing to fear there, that comes later, for this was just a list of people who hadn't posted much in a while. Prof came up with an excuse, so it was really only mantle who was "lurking". But now he comes in after being called out and talks about a long forgotten post from Soleron. As a townie, that makes it seem to me like he's trying to set me up for a lynch. We'll see what he comes up with later on.

If by "in a while" you mean the last ~15 hours of your post then I question why you think I would be posting during a period in which I very seldom am online, due to sleep and work. If you mean I just haven't been as active as in past games, then I would disagree. But more importantly, I would ask what of it?

I have zero fear, but what do you mean by "that comes later"?



VGC Mafia Archives

Around the Network
Yoshiya on 28 August 2012
Linkzmax said:
Yoshiya said:

You don't seem like a first-timer. Do you have experience in Mafia?

Never played a mafia game in my life. Heard Radish talk about them in the past but that is about it and he only talked about them in very lose terms.



Linkzmax on 28 August 2012

Well I'm glad you signed up. I hope you have fun and continue to play.



VGC Mafia Archives

hatmoza on 28 August 2012
zero129 said:
hatmoza said:
zero129 said:
Linkzmax said:
So you're keeping the FoS or removing it?

i wasnt joking about the FoS at the time cos i really didnt understand what he meant by that comment. But once Yoshi i think? explained what he meant i didnt suspect him of anything at that point so yeah im going to remove it

Spurge: FoS Removed


I'm glad I said I was at least sure of Yoshiya being town and not you coz my opinion about you is quickly changing as the game progresses.

I cringe when people unFoS.

to the underlined, What was your opinion of me if you dont mind me asking?

and to the bolded, Sorry rotfl


??? My opinion was very vocal and caused quite the reactions... Where the hell where you when I posted these? Need I also remind you were THE center of discussion when I posted these?

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4745055

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4745086

Before I even responded to this you were already on my list of scum. Which I should share anyways now that I feel comfortable with giving my opinions (as soon as I get home in a few hours anyways) but here's the overview. So far I got you [zero], J0 and Linkz pegged as scum.

I got Prof, Soleron, and Yoshiya as town.



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

hatmoza on 28 August 2012
theprof00 said:
Hey, just wanted to let people know that I am reading comments.
I've just been working on building a website and it's taking a lot of time. Having to teach myself a lot of new coding.

In response to linkz a little while back, no, I did mean noctis about who to watch and I am also fosing that whole unvote vote train from moreno to noc, even though I think a couple of them might simply be newbs. I'm curious as to what moreno's alignment is just because I think it would be a helpful read on that train.
I also changed my viewpoint on radish because some of his posts genuinely seemed to be town. It was specifically the 4 or 5 directly previous to me saying I was leaning town on him.

Pezus I don't seem to mind too much. He's a bit shadier than usual, but I'm sure with time, I'll be able to peg him as I do every game. I'm still leaning town though even though the shadiness.

I think mantle might be town, and I think radish also. Mantle, because I don't believe scum would have gone after Radish for meta-gaming so quickly even if radish is scum. Radish because of a gut feeling on the sincerity of his posts.

For newbs, I think yoshi is town, leaning scum on zero. I base this off of polite, quick, accurate responses from yoshi, and for zero, a seeming 'pretend ignorance'. I further do not like his "agreement" when I questioned him, and his interaction with linkz.

The pros seem to be biding their time, which I feel is a good idea. Linkz and Hat don't really need to do a whole lot on day 1, so it's not bothering me. For day1 play, I'd say it's a fairly town thing to do, as a mafia really has no reason to hide, especially a pro who is unlikely to be lynched. Furthermore, pros are usually too good to allow themselves to say anything that could later be contradictory, so it's not like they're covering for anything.
(Regarding Linkz, I don't mean he's actually hiding out, but that he's posting a bit less than usual.)

Take this compliment as you will, but I've been doing a lot of sitting back... a lot... and reading posts this game and this is the first time I've got a clean town feel from you.

I want to share my opinions and meta a little bit when I get home. 



I am the black sheep     "of course I'm crazy, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong."-Robert Anton Wilson

Linkzmax on 28 August 2012
zero129 said:
Linkzmax said:
zero129 said:

Why are you going by the votee's reason for the vote instead of reading the voter's reason yourself? Heck even a third-party's explanation should carry more weight.

I said i was waiting to get an asnwer from the voter as i think that would of gave me a much better understanding of why he voted the way he did.

But why not just read the posts that already exist?

zero129 said:

Mantle seems to be defending Yoshi in some posts (He might even be the one thats explaining things to him behind the scenes)

How could that be possible?



VGC Mafia Archives