Mafia Round 45: Friendship is Mafia

[hatmoza]

c03n3nj0 said:

hatmoza said:
Let me remind people that this is Zero's a Yoshiya's first game (at least to my knowledge) don't let their warped view on the game and how it's played sidetrack you too much. We've all been rookies at one point and eventually learned to eliminate all misconceptions that come with the rookie experience.

It wouldn't stop either of them from being mafia, though. 

And it's not useless sidetracking if we correct misconceptions, 'cause that'll just be helpful. 

If I sensed newb scum behavior, I would have pointed it out already. All I get from both Zero and Yoshiya are newb town vibes that consist of determination and confusion. My track record for pointing out newb scum speaks for itself in previous games and I'm not getting a hint of it this game. I will not get into past games of course but I'll state right now with utmost confidence that at least Yoshiya is town.

The confusion I mention stems from lack of guidance- meaning they have no coach and are acting on their own... That much is evident to me at least.

That said, I don't want to get in the "but we don't know if scum can talk during the day" argument. My position on the matter is purely instinctive. And although my warning to not dwell on the newbs stands, I didn't say we should COMPLETELY eliminate all discussion about them as well. see bolded.