Why would a townie want to play like he is a 3rd party, and why would a townie give up on the town?

You clearly misread. 

Anyways, your "dirt flinging" has involved your tone and the way you constantly pair Mario and I. 

Look at your bolded, factually wrong sentence .The "I like that" (which has been going on for a while now) always hints at being demeaning. It simply sounds like you are saying that you are above whatever point you are pointing out at a time because it is something said by a scum.

You can claim that that is not what you mean, but that's definitely the tone of those sentences. 

And as for Mario and I, it's definitely a trope in your posts. You are always pairing us together in the hopes of whatever action I do is associated with Mario so it makes me look like mafia too. 

I call this dirt-flinging. If it appeases you I'll call it subtle dirt-flinging, byu mud-flinging nontheless. 

(1) - No, I think both you and Mario can be aggressive. It's against each other after all. Prof also hasn't been aggressive. So if you want to go by what you just said then you are the aggressive mafia and he is the lying-low mafia. 

You just paired Mario and I up here too, which just backs up my point. See? Flinging dirt. Not to mention that Mario has been quite aggressive against you, so the point is mute anyways. 

Yes, I thought maybe you'd bring up that you were asking me about myself since I quoted you. I only meant to quote the "powerful" portion.

I really have nothing to prove myself. I think my suspicions are reliable despite the argumentation against them.

Yes, it is natural for a mafia to vote for other mafia. "Mafia FoS townies, and vote other mafia". He's not seriously pushing for Mantle, he's pushing for him "as an option". I think in his latest vote though he's straight up looking to bus. Again, this is entirely based on Mario being mafia. It could be wrong, but there's a good chance. It could also be that mario is simply offering up two townies, though in my experience it's always better to offer up one and one and gently guide the decisions.  He could also be bluffing with his mantle vote, so I'll say now that if he removes his vote after a second one whenever that may occur down the line, well, we can talk about that if it happens.

Also both you and pezus being online at the same time and not voting for mantle implies that either you are both town not voting a mafia, or one mafia and one town not voting for a town/mafia. I know it doesn't sound like evidence, but it proves one thing, both you and pez cannot be mafia. At the most it's one. And I'd say it wasn't you. So I think you're confirmed at this point. Unless you're being a complete asshole and letting us fudge around for trolling.

Yes quite interesting that you're voting for someone who won't be lynched.

I really want to lynch Mantle first

Vote: Mantle

Mario has been at two votes for a while now, with neither Pezuz or I dropping the hammer.

So, if Pezuz was mafia and Mario town then Pezuz would have voted already.

Likewise for myself.

So... let's scratch that out of the possibilities.

Nope, because Mantle is :D

unvote
vote: mantle

ANd you're next mario.

Oh crap!

Hammer vote.

Now explain to me how I would have been lynched pezus. You said "You won't".

Simple analysis would tell you that I won't because neither myself, nor Mantle, nor j0 are going to vote for me. Are you simply not paying attention and actively lurking? I've noticed that in all the days you've been asking where I've been, you've not really analyzed a whole lot.

Even if he's town, game isn't over.