Finally back home. It's good to be back at my computer.
OK where was I?
Reads latest posts again.

errr....

*shrugs*

Did Stefl ever post what time the day ends?

All this discussion hasn't changed my mind at all, in fact, I am more confident that Mantle and Prof are mafia. I just can't see Jo and Pezus as anything but town the way they have played this game. Prof blames his lack of participation on work. Mantle blames his lack of understanding the game from joining late and now he is saying Jo is neutral and I am opportunistic... It couldn't be any more obvious to me that they are scum.

Also, I just thought of something. Unless I vote today then it will be two votes for mafia and two votes for town, assuming everyone casts a vote before the day ends. With 3 votes needed to lynch (unless we wait for time to run out) I will probably have to vote. At this point I don't think it will really matter not knowing who was lynched though. Either we lynch mafia today or we lose. If we make it to another day we will know we lynched mafia.

I plan to end the day on thursday 00:00 CEST (Wednesday 22:00 UTC, 18:00 EDT)

@bolded.

Why is prof an obvious scum to you? Explain this without a) Involving me b) Talking about his life/death.

Since it is so obvious and all.

Bumping on my VGChartz Buddy.

Even if you say that, it is a simple process of elimination. I already said I couldn't see Jo or Pezus as scum. With only 4 people left to chose from that leaves you and Prof. Pretty simple, actually.

Oops, my bad, I got home and procrastinated with beers, chinese, and game of thrones episodes.

Anyway, I don't really have a read on j0. He has been saying some intriguing things all game, but there have been times where he's done complete 180's on scummy thought processes. Like, I have been thinking at times that he was clearly scum, but then he'd completely change his mind and start making sense. A mafia follows through with illogical thought processes.

For example, with wiibox, j0 was defending him and was making an argument but then right after that post, admitted that he'd actually convinced himself that wiibox was scum! Like, I just don't see that coming from a mafia, not one bit, because it's easily explainable if he was. He could just say, "how was I supposed to know? I made a decision and it was the wrong one" etc etc. So yeah, I don't think j0 is scum, but I do recognize that it's not GREAT evidence. That's just what I'm seeing.

Mantle: his reaction to my "cop hint", which in all reality was never a cop claim felt like a genuine town. He seemed excited for the cop to come forward. While I never claimed to be the cop, I said "even though I hinted at cop". He didn't start in with accusations or suspicion, he instantly accepted it. If he was mafia and took the "obvitown" as a way out, wouldn't he have thought that maybe I was trying to trick him and steer clear... or maybe just not talk so much and reveal his thoughts like he did? Furthermore, he voted to extend time, which nobody else did, when I said that I was time constrained.

You (pezus) I've already gone over. You say I'm wrong, I disagree, but I'm here to discuss, not push my agenda.

Mario just doesn't come across as a townie. I haven't had any of the town reads that I've had with j0 or mantle with him.

This is why my decision is you and mario.

prof, I can see why you think that about pezus, and thanks for sharing that info right now since it will help.

But since we agree on mario both of us, I think we should go forward with him. Pezus and conj are what I will probably have to face during day 6. I will go through their posts once again, however I think Pezus is town for showing greater enthusiasm for scumhunting.

Defense of a fellow townie is not something that can be considered scummy. I can guarantee you that tonight prof will be dead, you can see for yourself. The scum isn't going to go into day 6 with him alive even if he can go wrong simply because he has an amazing reputation for not getting lynched.

This is why if you think prof is scum, go for his scummate. Do not go for him. The night itself will prove whether he is scum or not. In case he is alive then either me or one other person will die among Conj and you, and that will clear you as well, after lynching mario we can see the alignment and roles as well.