By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 43 - WipEout

I want prof to come and say what he concluded from the reactions to his fake claim as soon as he can.

Otherwise, it would be a useless thing to do, if you're not basing anything off of your claim.

I would have personally called bull, by the way. The replacements for cop this game was the Watcher/Tracker combo. I concluded that there was no cop as soon as we established both Radish's and linkz's role - I didn't want to come forward with the idea, though. In the hope that the mafia would still consider there being a cop, or maybe leave it unsaid so someone would fake-claim it (and I would have the ability to say bull, like right now ^_^)



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

Around the Network

My conclusion was that mantle was town. I took a well reasoned guess that mantle was town, implied that i scanned him and his reaction completely fit what i would expect a townie to say.

My secondary conclusions were that pezus and mario were scum.
Right from the getgo pezus tried to throw doubt on my claim and i even think he would have tried fake counterclaiming. Hes throwing a lot of crap reasoning at the wall to see what sticks.
Even moreso, i said i was going to be absent a while and so voted for time extension enough to give me some leeway, and to me, him not voting for an extension looks like he was hoping to get the day over before my input,.

I have been following pezus closely and i believe one of the other reasons for me being alive is that he thinks im lynchable., hence why this question comes up every single day. The answer is so obvious. Power roles have been the target every night. I hadnt claimed. Thats why im alive.
Pretending to be the cop is evidence against me? No, because i could have easily came in and called whoever i wanted scum and mislynched them. You just got freaked out by my claim, period.

My post yesterday about there being no cop was not trying to get someone to claim either. I was damn serious that today was likely going to be a good cop fakeclaiming day and was willing to lay down my life to prevent it from happening. Had i died last night due to the hint, id be janitored and people would have questioned my role and saw the hint. It would have completely prevented any possible fakeclaim.

What else..... oh yeah 3v10 is not balanced. 3v9 is. This is the reasoning behind the survivor.

Yeah so thats my thoughts so far. I believe its either pezus and mario or mario and j0. Im leaning more that its pezus and mario.

Oh yeah i forgot. I said earlier that mario had accepted my cop claim but i didnt consider him town like i did with mantle. The reasoning behind this is that while he was quick to accept it he was also quick to flip his opinion as soon as his partner showed up and help cast suspicion.

Feel free to ask any other questions now.



Well you and mario have just been on the same wacky path. That is my initial thougt process.
i will try to respond in a few hours after my shift is done.



pezus said:

Scum know who is town and who is not, Mantle. You saying he couldn't have done that as scum? I see prof's "hinting" a way back as trying to rolefish for the real cop, if there was one. 

Actually, now I am considering my scumpects. There is no need for scum to rolefish at this point.



mantlepiecek said:
pezus said:

Scum know who is town and who is not, Mantle. You saying he couldn't have done that as scum? I see prof's "hinting" a way back as trying to rolefish for the real cop, if there was one. 

Actually, now I am considering my scumpects. There is no need for scum to rolefish at this point.

Scratch the above. I misunderstood.

Anyway about the hinting, he did it in a way that didn't really prove he is cop, the real cop if any wouldn't have any reason to come forward just at that.



Around the Network
c03n3nj0 said:
mantlepiecek said:
Anyway. My suspects are still Co3j and Mario. If it's not Co3j then it's pezus/prof (highly unlikely).

My preferred lynch today would be mario and I wish he was my preferred lynch on day 4.


Huh, if you're asking me why I changed my mind so easily, why don't you ask yourself that question? 

Mario wasn't your preferred lynch. Why is he now? 

Also, why do you have to say about Mario's claimed role? 

Hey. I was suspicious of mario since a long time. Whereas you weren't. The next in line of your suspicion should have been prof. But instead it's mario.

Also what do you mean by the bolded? I think mario is lying, he is mafia passive janitor. That's what I think, at least. His vote affecting the lynch is the main reason I think that. And his posting style completely fits that of a scum.



c03n3nj0 said:
mantlepiecek said:
c03n3nj0 said:

-snip-

-snip-

4) Prof is alive. I had called it.

HoS : ConjGuy

I had already said that prof would be alive. He isn't some kind of bomb that will kill himself to get killed. You SO OBVIOUSLY said in the beginning that radish should have been doctored, and now are surprised that prof is alive.

Seems like you and mario get surprised all the time that prof is alive.

What?

This doesn't make a lick of sense.

Only one person can get killed during the night, radish gets killed = prof stays alive. I have an analysis on this, it pretty much confirms his existence is possible if he is town.



c03n3nj0 said:
mantlepiecek said:

It's just a secondary theory. I actually don't think Conjguy is 3rd party.

However what makes me think jo specifically is survivor is because a) I am town, b) prof is town, c) two more scum remaining for sure so that has to be two of you three pezus, mario and conjguy. If you are scum and mario is scum then conjguy is survivor, there is no chance mario is survivor with his role and you can't be either. You are either town or scum. I am leaning town.

However I am not certain about it. But at least your posts haven't been neutral about everything like Conjguy's has been, and oppurtunistic like mario's.


Elaborate.

It's been neutral. Like, you don't take sides, don't vote, try and push out possibilities, giving minor opinions, not heavy ones which might create arguments and such.



mantlepiecek said:
c03n3nj0 said:
mantlepiecek said:

It's just a secondary theory. I actually don't think Conjguy is 3rd party.

However what makes me think jo specifically is survivor is because a) I am town, b) prof is town, c) two more scum remaining for sure so that has to be two of you three pezus, mario and conjguy. If you are scum and mario is scum then conjguy is survivor, there is no chance mario is survivor with his role and you can't be either. You are either town or scum. I am leaning town.

However I am not certain about it. But at least your posts haven't been neutral about everything like Conjguy's has been, and oppurtunistic like mario's.


Elaborate.

It's been neutral. Like, you don't take sides, don't vote, try and push out possibilities, giving minor opinions, not heavy ones which might create arguments and such.


Is this based on the day I wasn't freaking online most of the time? Because that's the only place where what you said actually fits. 



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

c03n3nj0 said:
mantlepiecek said:

It's been neutral. Like, you don't take sides, don't vote, try and push out possibilities, giving minor opinions, not heavy ones which might create arguments and such.


Is this based on the day I wasn't freaking online most of the time? Because that's the only place where what you said actually fits. 

It's based on everything I've seen of you.