For a cop to wait this long before coming forward with the claim, yes. Yet, you accepted him right away and didn't even consider any other options.

I would feel comfortable lynching either Mantle or Prof, but I am more sure about Mantle.

lol, it's not like he got a guilty investigation. So why should he have come forward with his role if he doesn't have a guilty investigation?

He didn't get any investigation results because he isn't the cop. We don't have a cop or a doctor. It should be obvious by now. No one counter claimed Prof and no one is being protected over night. (Unless we have a terrible doctor) Cops come forward without guilty scans pretty often actually. Saving an innocent townie, for example. If we really did have a cop there is no way they wouldn't have found scum by now, unless they have no idea what they are doing with the role. That is why I wouldn't have accepted Prof's cop claim at all. He is too good to not use the role correctly.

FIrst of all, I am under danger. Prof coming out with his role at this time felt to me like a cop trying to save a townie. So there goes your point of cop coming forward with his role if he is cop and no guilty result thing.

You say I should have questioned prof. I ask WHY I should question him when he is confirming me as town? What should I ask him? "Hey prof I totally think you are scum for coming out with this innocent reading on me kthxbai" or something? I decided there was no point in asking him anything. His result was accurate.

-snip-

4) Prof is alive. I had called it.

HoS : ConjGuy

I had already said that prof would be alive. He isn't some kind of bomb that will kill himself to get killed. You SO OBVIOUSLY said in the beginning that radish should have been doctored, and now are surprised that prof is alive.

Seems like you and mario get surprised all the time that prof is alive.

c03n3nj0 said: Vote - Time Extension The last (in-game) day was bad for me. The whole thing happened while I was very busy, so I actually should re-read the whole thing because I maybe missed more than I would if I actually been paying more attention to the game. In hindsight the general inactivity going on most definitely led to a mislynch - easier sway of bad ideas if no one is paying any particular attention. Or easier sway by the two mafia members, for that matter. Anyways, working on two hours of sleep, so I'm gone for the next half-day with sleep and other shit to do. I'm announcing it even though there's probably going to be like ~15 posts when I get back.

Well. You are wrong. This is no ordinary mafia game. In this game even without a lynch a townie can get killed during the day, as long as nobody votes for anyone that is what's going to happen. And the person with the highest no. of votes at the end of the day gets killed. That is what has happened. Except for me, radish and pezus no one voted for notstan, so he would be alive till the end of the day. And then got lynched.

There were no sway of bad ideas and it's funny because you yourself thought that Notstan was scum. He was in your list of the most suspicious person. Whereas mario was safer person.

So tell me. Why is he now so suspicious? Just because of the janitor thing? What were you doing for the last 3 days? It was me who first found this FACT on day 3 and it is now day 5. You proceed forward to be suspicious of both me and mario because you think that I am not in the same team as Notstan (which is not true, I am in his team) and mario because you feel that janitor thing has to be questioned now, during day 5. SO what were you thinking during day 4 to not be suspicious of this janitor thing, and what made you change your mind during the night phase?

It's just a secondary theory. I actually don't think Conjguy is 3rd party.

However what makes me think jo specifically is survivor is because a) I am town, b) prof is town, c) two more scum remaining for sure so that has to be two of you three pezus, mario and conjguy. If you are scum and mario is scum then conjguy is survivor, there is no chance mario is survivor with his role and you can't be either. You are either town or scum. I am leaning town.

However I am not certain about it. But at least your posts haven't been neutral about everything like Conjguy's has been, and oppurtunistic like mario's.