By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 43 - WipEout

spurgeonryan said:
Well I guess it all does not matter now that he has claimed Tracker it seems. Although it seems strange that he would not know the difference between a tracker and a watcher.

Sadly too many people get the two roles mixed up. I can somewhat understand people thinking a Watcher would see what a person does, but that's pretty clearly what a Tracker does. Which means a Watcher just watches what happens to a person.



Around the Network

In case anyone is interested, here is the wiki info about NoCtiS_NoX's EG-R team. http://wipeout.wikia.com/wiki/EG-R



pezus said:
Linkz, when you said the mafia were likely amateurs, what exactly did you mean (or rather, why?). Who would have been a better choice than FF in your opinion?

Now that I'm chronologically here, I mean FF wasn't a high priority target. Wonk would obviously be the top choice, because if the lack of a reveal at lynch wasn't enough he would be confirmed come day. But that would also make Wonk a top choice for protection. If prof is town he'd be an excellent choice as always. But even amateurs could have a sense of honor and wouldn't kill him night one AGAIN. I'd have been an excellent choice, especially given how active I was. There's no reason not to kill me other than thinking I can be mislynched. Sure I can be killed any other night, but the same could have been said for FF.

The bigger names know that's not going to be easy. It's going to take a faked incriminating scan and I'll still go down swinging, which is going to expose one or more of them. Amateurs would think the bit of mumblings day one could snowball into the votes needed.



spurgeonryan said:
Such as you killing Final Fan last night Linkz? Is that what a watcher would do?

Sense. You're still not making a lick of it.



WiiBox3 said:
pezus said:
I feel like we are torn and have no idea what we should do. Ideas?

Wonk should not investigate FF. Why the hell? Investigate the lynchee.

I'm getting a vibe from prof, linkz, notstan.

Linkz, when you said the mafia were likely amateurs, what exactly did you mean (or rather, why?). Who would have been a better choice than FF in your opinion?


That's a good question, if you were scum what would you have done on your first night? Also why is FF an amatuer choice?

Though, I think his comment that the mafia were likely amateurs sounds like a screen to throw people off his scent.

At the underlined, I'm glad you're admitting I'm not scum, Mr. Mafiaso!

Your question is quite different from the one pezus asked. To answer it I'd have to be of a different alignment, so it would depend on my teammates and our available powers. If we had neither a strongman or a roleblocker to take care of Wonk, I'd likely push for pezus or j0 to be the kill, assuming at least one isn't on my team. If it were the three of us then yeah I guess FF would be my choice there. Then he becomes the best kill, unlikely to be protected and allowing prof to enjoy the game some more.



Around the Network
Linkzmax said:
NotStan said:

Linkzmax said:

 What claim of radish's? And why are you counting dead players, one of which isn't confirmed town, in your total?

As for your third paragraph. Why so dramatic about the upcoming nightkill?

 

Didn't he effectively claim a pro town impulsive janitor? Or have I read something wrong? FF was a night kill. In a game of 13 people, 3 people are likely to be scum, we already had one vanilla lynched, and I am another vanilla, hence why I think that FF actually had a power role rather than just plain vanilla, although it probably wouldn't make much difference now, I am interested to see what role he held, just a personal interest thing really.

I like your suspicion of me linkz, keep it going. Would love to see what argument you're going to bring forward.

radish did no such thing. You're thinking of Mario. If we go by radish's claim then FF was probably also a vanilla.

Why are you so quick to claim vanilla? What would it matter if FF had a power role? I know plenty of reasons why, I'm just personally interested in why you wanted to know.

I claim vanilla, because I am vanilla. Earlier in the last day there was speculation in regards to this being a power game or not, at which I scoffed. You're right, got the two confused. I am just wondering as to what role FF had that's all, to gauge the power that Town holds, so far there are two vanilla townies that I am aware of, in a game of 13, with 3 possible scum that's quite a reasonable amount that would likely leave FF as a power role. Also what I am not aware of is the extent to which janitors "clean up"? Do they also get to know the role of person that they've "cleaned up"? That could help us pinpoint whether there are roleclaims that have gone awry - ie radish being scum and claiming the role of watcher/tracker knowing that we won't likely unveil the role of FF. Again that's dependent upon how much janitor can actually do. I am not entirely sold on Mario being a pro town compulsive janitor, don't think I've ever seen a role such as that, as in most cases it's an anti town role.



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.

Linkzmax said:
WiiBox3 said:
pezus said:
I feel like we are torn and have no idea what we should do. Ideas?

Wonk should not investigate FF. Why the hell? Investigate the lynchee.

I'm getting a vibe from prof, linkz, notstan.

Linkz, when you said the mafia were likely amateurs, what exactly did you mean (or rather, why?). Who would have been a better choice than FF in your opinion?


That's a good question, if you were scum what would you have done on your first night? Also why is FF an amatuer choice?

Though, I think his comment that the mafia were likely amateurs sounds like a screen to throw people off his scent.

At the underlined, I'm glad you're admitting I'm not scum, Mr. Mafiaso!

Your question is quite different from the one pezus asked. To answer it I'd have to be of a different alignment, so it would depend on my teammates and our available powers. If we had neither a strongman or a roleblocker to take care of Wonk, I'd likely push for pezus or j0 to be the kill, assuming at least one isn't on my team. If it were the three of us then yeah I guess FF would be my choice there. Then he becomes the best kill, unlikely to be protected and allowing prof to enjoy the game some more.

Why would you have chose one of them over FF?



Sorry I'm not here! Posting from my phone right now, whilst not at home.

Erm I have little time to write a well thought out post, but for everything I've read so far:

unvote - Pezuz

vote - Linkz

I'm willing to test this out, even if spurge is being messy with the roleclaim.

Also,

Vote - Time Extension



 Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."                               

spurgeonryan said:
I have no idea how it is supposed to be. This is my first.


Well if you've only seen him visit the now dead FF then that would mean that's he's the scum goon. I am guessing you're now claiming the role of watcher?



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.

Fuck sake, why is shit bolded -_-



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.