EBWOP -
on second thought, it's still a stupid claim is he's mafia and there's no Janitor, because Coroner implies there will be no reveals to role if someone dies. If stefl starts telling us who is who then Wonk's claim goes down the toilet.
Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."
| supermario128 said: My general thoughts about everybody so far. Since the game is still very young and some people have yet to post that much this might be a little pre-mature, but here it is anyway, Noctis: Apparently made a joke vote, but didn't really explain if it was a joke vote or not. (I see how this can be annoying) Besides that, he is playing the same way he was last game. He pops in every now and then, but generally lurks. His posts are short and make it hard to get any sort of read on him. He was mafia last game and I guessed every other member except for him. Either play more serious, or we can never get an actual "read" on you. Vote: Noctis Linkz: Seems to be VERY eager so far. More so than I have ever seen him. It could be that he has more free time, or that he was excited to play again after hosting, or it could be a false cover to appear town (Did he really read his PM like he said?), OR something else entirely. His general thoughts seem to be similar to my own though. Suspicious of Prof, suspicious of Spurge, and his reasoning behind things. Normally I would conclude someone to be pro town for scum hinting the way he is, but it seemed like he is going after anyone that slips up to try and get an easy lynch. I'm leaning towards scum for him, but I could be wrong. HoS: Linkz co3: His posts make a lot of sense and I agree with his reasoning. The only thing that seemed a bit odd is that he almost seemed to try and steer Spurge away from the mess he was in. Here he says he wants to give him more time and doesn't even FoS him, but he did give one to Linkz who was originally arguing with Spurge. Here he summarizes he summarizes a bit of what happened and then tells Spurge to make more sense (play better). I'm leaning towards pro town for him. Radish: He is actually making a lot of sense this game, which usually means he is mafia. However, I will wait a bit longer to see how things play out with him. He voted for someone pretty quickly after Final Fan wanted everyone to do so. Just noting that; doesn't necessarily mean anything. Spurge: I first thought his initial post was a joke, but apparently it wasn't. Everyone already posted how he contradicted himself, but Spurge has done similar things in the past. He could be a scum trying to look crazy/ confused on purpose or he could be a townie who made a simple mistake. Linkz, Wonk, and c03 seem to be the ones who went after him the most and through their conversations with him I am slightly leaning towards town for him, but I could be wrong. It is always hard for me to get a good read on Spurge, but I'll take back my FoS. WiiBox: I've never played with him before, and nothing he has posted so far stands out as suspicious so far. He has asked a lot of newbie questions and I am leaning toward pro town for him, but it is a bit too early to be sure. Pezus: His first 3 posts were talking about the theme, laughing at Spurge, and then talking about past games. I wonder why he didn't mention Prof at all. Maybe he didn't read the whole thread or the rules at that point in time, but the game had already started and it seemed like he was talking about "other" stuff just to get a few posts in. Also, he doesn't really do or say anything to benefit the game until he votes for a time extension. He seems more concerned about the past game and other random posts. HoS: Pezus Prof: Like I have said before, what Prof did was (for lack of a better word) stupid no matter which team he is on. If Stefl went ahead with the punishment, and didn't stop the whole thing when he did, a lot of others could have voted no lynch as well. After reading through his long explanation I am starting to understand his thinking a bit more, but he was assuming a mafia team would get punished as a whole when the town wouldn't? Like others have said, third party could be likely but this isn't enough for me to conclude anything just yet or to vote for him at the moment. Prof has done crazy stuff in the past, so I will believe him for the time being. I'm still keeping my eyes on you though, Prof. I'll change my Hos on him to a FoS. Soleron: I don't really have a read on him yet. Probably because he only has three posts. He needs to start posting more. NotStan: Never played with him before, but I agree with most of what he is saying. He votes for Noctis and then Noctis comes on to FoS NotStan simply because he voted for him? Final Fan: The only thing that struck me as odd about him is wanting everyone to vote right away. In theory this is an easy way to see who everyone is MOST suspicious of, but it is also a great way to end the day prematurely. As far as I'm concerned the longer the day the better so people should vote for someone when they are good and ready, not just because. I always think he is mafia when he isn't, so I will wait a bit longer before making my final conclusions on him. :P Wonk: He has also been very active this round compared to others. His posts and reasoning make a lot of sense and he is asking a lot of questions in an attempt to scum hunt. I get a pro town vibe from him so far. |
he is very spot on and yes I am mafia so Now vote me people. 
supermario128 said:
You shouldn't jump to conclusions. It is very likely that we may have a passive janitor amongst ourselves. Think back to Hatz game with Pac Man. As far as your role claim goes, I am inclined to believe it and as far as I'm concerned this 99% confirms you as town. There is no way scum would lie about being a corener or for that role to be anything other than pro town. |
What conclusion did I jump to?
There was no coroner in that round though, just all night kills janitored until the janitor died then they all flipped.
@ spurge,
That's okay. This completely applies to this game. It's more his playstyle, than specific information. :P May I ask what his role was?
@ all
So! Would stefl put a jester/joker (whatever it's called) that will win the game If lynched? Because I want Noctis
lynched right now. Him winning from it would be the only thing stopping me.
God, I want you to be mafia, Noctis. If you're townie I'd have no regrets for lynching you for trolling >_>
Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."
| c03n3nj0 said: EBWOP - on second thought, it's still a stupid claim is he's mafia and there's no Janitor, because Coroner implies there will be no reveals to role if someone dies. If stefl starts telling us who is who then Wonk's claim goes down the toilet. |
If there are no ommitted flips I will laugh at being trolled by the mod.
| c03n3nj0 said: @ spurge, That's okay. This completely applies to this game. It's more his playstyle, than specific information. :P May I ask what his role was? @ all So! Would stefl put a jester/joker (whatever it's called) that will win the game If lynched? Because I want Noctis lynched right now. Him winning from it would be the only thing stopping me. God, I want you to be mafia, Noctis. If you're townie I'd have no regrets for lynching you for trolling >_> |
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=141736&page=1# he was a miller
even if he is and would "win" I am sure stefl would keep the game going for second and I'd be fine seening him go since he's often not the best of help to town anyway (you can't lurk mafia to death nox :P ) and as jester he'll have even less incentive to help.
| c03n3nj0 said: .... what, wonk? I can't decide the level of stupidity here. @ Noctis, acting aloof is not helping your case. |
With the way you asked a question before it gave me the impression that you thought I had a power role. Instead of hoping scum don't also draw that conclution or feel that I shouldn't be killed night 1 two games in a row, I felt safer to claim now.
I figure it would pretty much confirm me as town and also let the town know something they might not have. Had I died night one and not flipped it would't have gone so well for town.
@ wonk.
I was expecting an excuse for your theories, not a roleclaim! I was measuring you up. That's okay, though, what's happened happened.
With what's given there's no logic besides believing you. So hell, I'll ask this:
Why do you think links is mafia?
Tag (Courtesy of Fkusumot) "If I'm posting in this thread then it's probally a spam thread."
| c03n3nj0 said: @ wonk. I was expecting an excuse for your theories, not a roleclaim! I was measuring you up. That's okay, though, what's happened happened. With what's given there's no logic besides believing you. So hell, I'll ask this: Why do you think links is mafia? |
It's based soley on some of his past behavior but this is the post where I first thought he was scum. Nothing he's done since has made me think otherwise.
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4661544
Linkzmax said:
j0 basically said 1 already, the obvious thing being prof's carefree attitude about all of town losing their powers. Power or not, that's clearly not benefitial for town. Taking it another level, prof wouldn't care to be protected night 1.(Yeah I know he died early three games so he's due or whatever) 2 is a generalization. Everyone merely consisted of Wonk, Mario, and I, while others were neutral, said nothing of it, or outright dismissed it. Not a big thing I admit, but certainly not helpful. 3, well he states I knew the rule already. So I'm not going to hurt my team, whatever it may be. Which leaves spurge, who statistically is more likely to be town than mafia. Having a scum-scum feel on the two of us based on last round's interaction between hat and spurge(which wasn't scum-scum) is hardly a good reason to put town at risk. I hate to leave mid-thought, but I'm going to see Spidey. Might be back in a few hours or I might pass out. |
Picking up where I left off.
These were all going by the wording of rule #1: "his whole team will be punished by striping the entire team from every night action they might have." which I logically took to mean all of town would be punished if one member breaks a rule. As unfair a rule as it is, I wouldn't think to interpret them differently or to try and test a possible townie breaking them. I tend to go by mods will not lie to players, and I don't really understand why Stefl would say the "entire team" when "he will be stripped of any night action he might have" could be used instead and wouldn't open the game to exploits such as confirming a player.
Anyway, prof's explanation is the type of crazy stunt I'd expect him to pull as town(or at least not mafia) though. If Rol were in this game, I believe he'd have called prof an idiot by now. Given the above paragraph, it's probably fitting but at least no harm was done.Gotta keep my eye on him of course, but no longer my choice for today's lynch.
About Us |
Terms of Use |
Privacy Policy |
Advertise |
Staff |
Contact
Display As Desktop
Display As Mobile
© 2006-2024 VGChartz Ltd. All rights reserved.
