Hmm. I haven't seen him on the last few pages, but looking at his profile, he has been posting.

And your second statement makes no sense.

We have no other sane doctor, which means I am probably a sane doctor.

Which makes it very likely that supermario is scum, but I'm having a hard enough time convincing you that I'm not without throwing another proposal into the mix.

When he does get around to dying and flips scum, do remember that I suspected him when you all had complete faith >_>

I'll give it another shot: Which is a riskier fakeclaim, Rol, Motivator or Doctor? Which strikes you as more likely to be fake, the one which is in every game or the one which is rare?

Why did you protect prof on night 1? I want to know the exact thinking behind that decision.

Mario could have been a strongman, as has been suggested many times.

If I am insane (which can only be proven if Mario is killed and flips townie and which I am seriously starting to doubt) then it's more useful as a sort of vigilante power, I think.

Remember that at this point I had no doubts at all about my sanity. I was told I was a doctor. I figured I was a doctor.

I suspected prof at first, but I unvoted the moment he revealed he was a namecop. That didn't seem to me like a very scummy role. Names may be tied to alignment, but how strictly can they be tied to role? And mafia already know everyone's role.

I figured that he was a very useful townie to have. Nobody else had suggested that they had a power role at all. So, I protected prof. I imagine most of you would have done the same.

What do you mean mafia already know everyone's roles? How can they know everyone's roles?

Oh sorry, I meant to say alignment.

That is, any mafia cop would be a rolecop, because a regular alignment cop is of no use to them.

A namecop doesn't work very well as a rolecop.

So you are saying that because prof roleclaimed namecop he must have been a townie? Is that why you protected him?

So let me get this straight, please do correct me if I missed anything. I simply breezed over the last 300 posts.

So it turns out Rol saw only two people at Prof's last night, one claimed doctor and the other claimed motivator... and we want to lynch the doctor? Sorry if I'm the odd ball here but I'd MUCH rather lynch the so-called motivator than risk losing a doctor. I think Kantor has more to worry 'bout from scum or possible third factions than us hanging him by the neck. Plus, if mario does flip motivator and he was telling the truth we can lynch Kantor tomorrow anyway. I'm sorry but right now I'm more comfortable lynching mario. My vote is still on him. Plus,

I assure everyone that me wanting to lynch mario has nothing to do with proving to myself that my suspicion of him was right all along.

Alright, I need to go to sleep now, so I'm going to speak my piece one final time:

• I am definitely some kind of doctor
• I am leaning about 80% in favour of my being a regular sane doctor, because we haven't seen one of those so far, and insane doctor is a fairly rare role.
• If mario flips town, I am definitely an insane doctor.
• If mario flips scum, we go up to a 99% chance that I am a sane doctor.
• Mario claimed a rarely used role. This is a safe fakeclaim.
• I claimed one of the most common roles in the game. This is not a safe fakeclaim.

If:

• You lynch me and I am scum: Well done. I am not, however, scum, so this won't happen.
• You lynch me and I am town: You've just lynched your doctor.
• You lynch mario and he is scum: Well done. One mafioso down.
• You lynch mario and he is town: We've lost a motivator. We know that I am an insane doctor and can plan accordingly. Not ideal, but I don't believe that he's town, and it's not as bad as scenario 2.

Would you rather lose your doctor, or lose your motivator? Think about that for a moment.