+Valkyria Chronicles

-Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn

+Tales of Vesperia
- Valkyria Chronicles

+ FE
- Disgaea 4
At this point I don't really know what to vote down anymore...

You guys killed off Valkyria Chronicles..... wow. That game deserved to be in the Top 5 at least. Why are two Disgaea games up there? smh

Must have been too mainstream..... Which is why Skyrim got eliminated first.

+ ToV
- Disgaea 4

I thought votes were not being counted until Zero decides what to do with the Top 5.

+ Fire emblem
- Disgaea 4

I am surprised by all this thread. I mean, I know it's a matter of opinion, but The Witcher 2, Deus Ex: Human Revolution and Nier are all deserving to be in the top 5. I have not touched or heard of any of the final five games. Are they cool because nobody heard of them?

We can learn a lot about this kind of threads, as we played this game as we usually play videogames.
- We go first against the biggest threads, why some great games were killed very fast
- We took revenge, why some other good games were killed after our favorite game was eliminated
- We vote based on what we know, so the more unknown games could reach the final stages of the game

The final list is an odd one and is very difficult that someone has played all the games in the list (1 wii exclusive, 3 PS3 exclusives, 1 Xbox 360 exclusive), I have only played one, so no matter what Zero decides it will very hard to choose.