I don't understand why Radish gets all this attention every game. He does the same thing EVERY game, whether he is mafia or not, yet people continue to abuse him on it game after game after game.

I believe it was 2 (maybe 3).  But I have played about 10 rounds (almost all with radish I believe), and he does something like this just about every single game.  Rather than act so intelligent, you should go back and read through some rounds.  His current actions are in no way a scum vibe.

I was in games with cultists, but I can't remember if they had cult leaders.

Its an impossible question to answer. Surely you know that as town, you don't know the alignment of any other player.

I have no clue if he is on my team.

Well my first game, let's see how it rolls.

Sure.

Okay, but as everyone is saying, Radish plays it safe and is always a problem for town later on.

They gave me a hard time for playing badly, and that's probably what Radish needs.

Vote: No Lynch

I've never played a Mafia game where we lynch someone first round. Don't the villagers have to get mad at something before we lynch someone?

(I didn't even realize we could do a no lynch vote... it seems I have a lot to learn...)

Now if you 'scuze me, I've got a butchery to run. *sharpens cleaver*

It wasn't until after Mr. Kitten  filled his pot with water, lit the stove, brought the water to a boiling, inserted the pasta into the pot, boiled the pasta to perfection with the right amount of salt and pepper, smothered a frying pan with butter, tossed the pasta into the frying pan, fried the pasta to excellence, relocated the pasta to a dining dish, sprinkled the pasta with Parmesan cheese, sat in front of the computer screen with his accomplished meal, THAT he realized ... he was supposed to count the votes.

With 20 players, 11 votes is the majority.

No lynch(3): Radish, Outlaw, Smeags
Radish(3):Rol, F-F, Theprof

Cold Pasta Stamp