While I can understand why you don't agree with Moreno's methods of openly trying to snuff out the other sibling, linkz, I really don't see any added harm that Dolphin didn't already damn us with. That is if Doofus really is a sibling town.

If he was scum, he would discuss the matter with his scummates during the night (or day), not openly with us. I don't like your case against moreno. Especially since, on a personal level, I considered doing something similar as morn, so it doesn't come of as scummy to me. Matter of fact, I got a town read from it.

If he just wanted to find the other sibling or lack therof that would be one thing. But he pretended to not want the sibling to come forward.

As it is, HD can be protected by the doctor, or at least the idea of a doctor protecting HD can keep scum from killing him at night. Out the sibling and their chances of survival drop significantly.

I would expect you to do that, because it is always in your nature to out everyone else, town be damned if it's actually for the best.

By the very slim chance he was not lying about the sibling, we can agree it'd been better if the sibling didn't show himself. Think of that post as a failed way to prove he doesn't have a sibling.

Geez, finally someone giving beef to moreno. Screw you Rol.

He limit them into a list a newb player could figure out if they actually thought about it.

And while I'm at it, let me throw this out there. Why do we assume that the mafia players are so dumb that they can't read between the lines like any other player can? Whether it's a riddle, hint, or a pun that is blown up into something it wasn't never meant to be originally, the mafia will see it as clear as we do.

Back to Linkz. So no, the second sibling will not out themselves... they will be a moron if they did. However, making a list that narrows down the sibling isn't something that each of us already partially did in the back of our heads. So I find it hard to hold that list against morn.

Also, you fail to realize the possibility of Doofus lied about the sibling thing, which could explain the non existent support from his brother during his fiasco, or possibly the reason the brother didn't even role claim - they don't exist.

What did you mean by "Users"?

You're right, I can't say for certain that mafia are humans. I would be confident in saying all town are pokemon and vice-versa though, and thus mafia and any other non-town are not pokemon.

But if Noctis is any good as a host, he gave any non-town a safelist of pokemon they can claim. So the whole thing is moot.

False false false! Mafia can be lynched day 1, but odds are against it. That doesn't make day 1 lynches bad though. Good(smart) players can learn a ton from a mislynch. Good(smart) players will push a lynch even on the chance that is a mislynch, because votes and lynches are town's strongest weapon.

We are going to have a lynch today and as long as I continue to play, there will be lynches day 1 in every future game as well.

Bah, more "rolefishing" talk when it's not such. This is blatantly asking for a claim, but it's obviously not serious either.

Why so defensive when you weren't even named?

Not true. Town wouldn't want attention focused on them for too long either. It could lead to a mislynch rather than lead finding scum.

I'll probably annoy some people, but I'm going to try real hard not to be insulting this round.

Let's see.. it can't be prof, Trucks and I again since I already said prof is on the other team... Okay, I'll stick with Trucks and pick Wonk. prof can have hat and radish, because they'd work well together.

Let me guess, Linkz is trustworthy and 100% town for you.

You could easily be mafia, but you're right that far too many votes have been thrown down without any reasoning. No lynch(good or bad) is as meaningful if it's all just bandwagoning.

Sure! In my first game here, which was also my first game of forum mafia, I was very experienced with terms and such.(Because I read several full games and went through the entire flash tutorial before joining up) IRL Mafia games are somewhat similar and don't always go by the same name. Usually they go more like this day has been so far, with random finger pointing and lynchtrains pulling out to a good lead quickly, instead of our usual slower pace of finding candidates.

Being the one to start the trend,(which I pulled from elsewhere) I wholeheartedly disagree. Allowing mafia to strategize during the small window of night and fend for themselves during the longer days takes away a lot of the team aspect. Sure in a "real town" two or more people sneaking off to talk to each other would raise pitchforks, but that doesn't translate well to forum Mafia.

I can't remember how you seemed to know the game too well in your first game. Point being, it's easy to skate by for a while as a clueless rookie. If mafia can talk during the day, any good "coach" would just tell HD to act inexperienced.

This was a modkill trap.

I see your point, but I still think town so far. But he's either going to die or be forced to claim at some point, and his refusal to answer your question should be remembered if that happens.

This. In http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4525920 moreno gives two possible explanations for HD's vote, both of which point to HD being mafia.