By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 40. Pokemon! Gotta Catch them all!

TruckOSaurus on 20 April 2012
theprof00 said:
I also felt good about pezus.
So, after the re-read, I'm thinking pezus, wonk, HD are town, adding on to my previous feeling that manuel is also, and spurge, slight town reads on rol, moreno, and trucks.
Which leaves me about 10 suspects.

Also, I don't like how Hat flipped on his feeling about HD so quickly. He soon abandoned his thoughts when HD said he was padib. I didn't like that.

I agree about most of your "feels" except for moreno. To me he acted like scum who's found a lynchable townie and it felt like he wasn't interested in what Happy had to say and he was just looking for ways to bring him down.



Signature goes here!

Around the Network
happydolphin on 20 April 2012
RolStoppable said:
theprof00 said:
OK, here's my theory, because scum are likely going to figure it out anyway, so I think it should be put out there.

I think HD is the cop. His pm might've said something like "investigate someone, and you will see if they are pokemon or human".
This explains the arrogance (usually a sign that someone is making a BIG mistake voting them), it explains him constantly saying "you'll be sorry when you see my 'alignment'" (what he really means is "role"), it explains his non-accusations and no-votes, it explains his "I assume the best", and his response to me of "all in good time", and it explains his understanding of human and pokemon as mafia and town.

So your theory boils down to "our cop is an idiot".

And I have to admit that I am willing to believe this.

In defense of my honor, I will say, I am not the cop. Maybe I am an idiot, but I'm not the cop. The cop is out there and we don't know who he is, but he's not me.



happydolphin on 20 April 2012
TruckOSaurus said:
theprof00 said:
I also felt good about pezus.
So, after the re-read, I'm thinking pezus, wonk, HD are town, adding on to my previous feeling that manuel is also, and spurge, slight town reads on rol, moreno, and trucks.
Which leaves me about 10 suspects.

Also, I don't like how Hat flipped on his feeling about HD so quickly. He soon abandoned his thoughts when HD said he was padib. I didn't like that.

I agree about most of your "feels" except for moreno. To me he acted like scum who's found a lynchable townie and it felt like he wasn't interested in what Happy had to say and he was just looking for ways to bring him down.

I wouldn't go that far trucks. I think I gave a really bad mafia smell and he wasn't gonna let me go. I don't judge him because I was the one to make the lapsus.



happydolphin on 20 April 2012

At this point guys it should be pretty clear that I'm alone and have 0 coaching I have made enough mistakes to prove you that.



theprof00 on 20 April 2012
happydolphin said:
RolStoppable said:
theprof00 said:
OK, here's my theory, because scum are likely going to figure it out anyway, so I think it should be put out there.

I think HD is the cop. His pm might've said something like "investigate someone, and you will see if they are pokemon or human".
This explains the arrogance (usually a sign that someone is making a BIG mistake voting them), it explains him constantly saying "you'll be sorry when you see my 'alignment'" (what he really means is "role"), it explains his non-accusations and no-votes, it explains his "I assume the best", and his response to me of "all in good time", and it explains his understanding of human and pokemon as mafia and town.

So your theory boils down to "our cop is an idiot".

And I have to admit that I am willing to believe this.

In defense of my honor, I will say, I am not the cop. Maybe I am an idiot, but I'm not the cop. The cop is out there and we don't know who he is, but he's not me.

Well, I can't imagine what role you could have that could possibly bring it all together then.

I can still see a possibility for a pm worded in that way...though it's back to the drawing board.



Around the Network
happydolphin on 20 April 2012
theprof00 said:
happydolphin said:

In defense of my honor, I will say, I am not the cop. Maybe I am an idiot, but I'm not the cop. The cop is out there and we don't know who he is, but he's not me.

Well, I can't imagine what role you could have that could possibly bring it all together then.

I can still see a possibility for a pm worded in that way...though it's back to the drawing board.

You don't need to go back to the drawing board. The only place where your theory fails is in you thinking I'm a cop. I'm not. I'm something else but please don't pinch it out of me unless you want to compromise townie knowledge.



theprof00 on 20 April 2012

Basil
There is often a role called lie detector who can use his ability on a post to see if a person is lying.
Given that role, I would like you to answer this question in less than two minutes.

Answer this question in your own words:
Are you a townie?

You can answer:
I am a townie
-or-
I am not a townie



theprof00 on 20 April 2012

You have about 30 seconds to respond or I will start pushing for your lynch.



TruckOSaurus on 20 April 2012
happydolphin said:
TruckOSaurus said:
theprof00 said:
I also felt good about pezus.
So, after the re-read, I'm thinking pezus, wonk, HD are town, adding on to my previous feeling that manuel is also, and spurge, slight town reads on rol, moreno, and trucks.
Which leaves me about 10 suspects.

Also, I don't like how Hat flipped on his feeling about HD so quickly. He soon abandoned his thoughts when HD said he was padib. I didn't like that.

I agree about most of your "feels" except for moreno. To me he acted like scum who's found a lynchable townie and it felt like he wasn't interested in what Happy had to say and he was just looking for ways to bring him down.

I wouldn't go that far trucks. I think I gave a really bad mafia smell and he wasn't gonna let me go. I don't judge him because I was the one to make the lapsus.

That reminds me, another alternative I also thought about was that he could be throwing you under the bus and he wanted to be a part of that lynch to earn some "town credit"



Signature goes here!

theprof00 on 20 April 2012

Goddamnit vgc, he went offline 8 minutes ago. Fix your shit. Stop noting that people are online when they aren't!!!