That's a good point and a good start. Don't be discouraged when people don't reply as fast as you want if at all. Just keep at it. Find more things. Demand answers.  Put a FoS or HoS on people or even a vote. you are one voice of many, make yourself heard

Okay, we knew about the modkill, but we didn't know basil was town or scum.
He still could have a had a scum role.

And the fact that happydolphin really had a sibling made 2 die instead of one.

After reading the tutorial site I expected 2 players gone after the first night.

Now with the mod kill and 1 sibling, that's 4. To a newbie like me it looks dramatic, I can assure you. (That's possible 1/4 to 1/3 of the whole town.)

Okay then...
*dramatic drumroll*

FoS: spurgeonryan

Funny thing is had basil stuck around and not been modkilled it it very possible it would have only been 2.

Even with it being 4 we can still make more mistakes and recover.

Let's hope so.

The problem with me is, I'm always asleep when the really heated discussions are going on. Stupid time difference. :(
In the morning when I get up there are always several hundred posts and it's really hard to keep up.

MUGEN's accusation of editing and his insane determination to stick to that accusation actually gave me a town impression. He may have been misguided but I find it hard to believe a mafia would just pull something completely unfounded out of his ass like that and put himself on the spot the way MUGEN did.

I'm unable to quote right now
@Manuel many times I have been the only one on so I know your pain to a lesser extent. I am in Pacific Time and often up late while most the players are from further east in the US or Canada or over in Europe
@FF it's the fact after being confronted on it that he decided to just post less, that really had me. That and I wouldn't be surprised at a first time mafia player who is mafia his first game doing something like that.

For my personal list of the top 5:

Radish, Final-Fan, Nen-Suer, Spurge, insert choice of favour(MUGEN, Manuel, NintyPie) - the last three being at the same level, and spurge isn't really hight on my scumspect list but he is fourth place nontheless (since you wanted 5 people) - and to put it all on a general level, hell even Radish isn't that high on the list... and for now I would consider Final-Fan and Nen-Suer on the same level as him, but for the other two I cannot really make a case.

to complete the list: here we continue:

mario, rol, wonk, pezus, hatmoza

the lower 4 might even are just a tiny edge above the (MUGEN, Manuel, NintyPie) triplet... Hatmoza is basically cleared with his role.

@ bolded, yeah, agreed.

I was too sleepy last night.....but did steft just "guess" Radish's pokemon?! Was it that obvious!

I explaind this before, but no one cares. Plus cant usualy post in the morning & have to wait for my lunch break.

Cant belive you got lynched day1 in the last games, your awsome.

I like this ratio and i dont like how he seems to poke at me & spurg at all.