By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 40. Pokemon! Gotta Catch them all!

EBWOP: *almost always*



Around the Network
happydolphin said:

I get it, but why would you be threatened if you're townie. If you're townie, you should know that I'm smart enough not to lynch someone off a whim, so you should trust my judgement.

The fact that you want to lynch me day 1 shows either

1) you're not as good as you pretend to be

or

2) you're scum.

So, let's see if you choose the smart path, or reveal one of two things that wouldn't look too good. The day I'm lynched by vote is the day you'll realize you're one of the two, I hope for you you're not 1, you'd feel dumb if you were

Who said I was threatened? lol

Second of all, I haven't put a vote on you. You're a good lead, so I'm pressuring you. Pressuring leads to conversation. Conversation leads to analysis. If you're analyzed to be guilty and flip town, well then we have a pool of people all commenting and we can analyze their posts as well. If I were able to pick out mafia so easily on day 1, I wouldn't play, because it would be entirely unfair to everyone else lol. So it's really not a big deal if we mislynch a town.

That being said, I'd rather not lynch a townie. I want to lynch mafia, and the risk/reward of lynching a mafia on day one is well worth pressuring someone who seems "off".

Lastly, if I push to mislynch you, I'm well capable of taking responsibility for it, just as I took responsibility for mislynching moreno last game, and no, I didn't feel dumb at all.



BasilZero said:

hmmmMMMMmmmmmMMmmmmmmmmmm


I shall for now:

Vote: happyD

 

 

(DONT Taze me bro ;o, it just seems a bit weird that someone like happyD who's first time playing Mafia would be so energetic and so eager to post on and on even if he did a irl mafia thing D:, even I am nervous on my first time n_n)

Another thing basil. If I were scum, I wouldn't be making as many mistakes, because the veterans would probably help me. That's why I'm slipping so much.

Don't worry, I'll make my way out of it.



spurgeonryan said:
Holy Crap! So this is what a ton of players does to a mafia thread.

Checking in and have my PM.

Basil seems to know way too much about Pokemon.

Here we go again!



happydolphin said:
BasilZero said:

hmmmMMMMmmmmmMMmmmmmmmmmm


I shall for now:

Vote: happyD

(DONT Taze me bro ;o, it just seems a bit weird that someone like happyD who's first time playing Mafia would be so energetic and so eager to post on and on even if he did a irl mafia thing D:, even I am nervous on my first time n_n)

Bazil, think for a second!

You don't need to be scum to be cunning. I'm not doing a super good job at it, but don't do like the noob veterans, be smarter than them!

You know that the noob-veterans are radish and me^^



Around the Network
Stefl1504 said:
Also... prof, I think you are reading too much into it^^ - tough you are appearing uncomforting reasonable this time arround, which makes you appear even scummier... lol - I hate you soo much >:(

unvote

@Rol

Why are you so eager to lynch prof ?

FoS stefl

I don't think Rol is very eager to lynch me at all, but I think you're eager to paint him as such.

Also, I love you stefl, you say the funniest things about me and my playstyle. Loved your pm to me last game haha



theprof00 said:
happydolphin said:

I get it, but why would you be threatened if you're townie. If you're townie, you should know that I'm smart enough not to lynch someone off a whim, so you should trust my judgement.

The fact that you want to lynch me day 1 shows either

1) you're not as good as you pretend to be

or

2) you're scum.

So, let's see if you choose the smart path, or reveal one of two things that wouldn't look too good. The day I'm lynched by vote is the day you'll realize you're one of the two, I hope for you you're not 1, you'd feel dumb if you were

Who said I was threatened? lol

Second of all, I haven't put a vote on you. You're a good lead, so I'm pressuring you. Pressuring leads to conversation. Conversation leads to analysis. If you're analyzed to be guilty and flip town, well then we have a pool of people all commenting and we can analyze their posts as well. If I were able to pick out mafia so easily on day 1, I wouldn't play, because it would be entirely unfair to everyone else lol. So it's really not a big deal if we mislynch a town.

That being said, I'd rather not lynch a townie. I want to lynch mafia, and the risk/reward of lynching a mafia on day one is well worth pressuring someone who seems "off".

Lastly, if I push to mislynch you, I'm well capable of taking responsibility for it, just as I took responsibility for mislynching moreno last game, and no, I didn't feel dumb at all.

Nope, that's a cop-out. If you were a good townie, you wouldn't sacrifice a townie with all the what-ifs. You don't know who is who, and you can't just blame a mis-lynch on a risk/reward scenario.

What if a marksman thought like you?

Nah, you would be option 1) if  you mislynched me in my book. I don't smell off, I don't feel off, and your reasoning was so off it made no sense whatsoever.

Also, for the record, I never said you voted for me, read again.



happydolphin said:
hatmoza said:
Can't quote but:

dolphin said:
"Or will you? Odd thing in this playfield is the idea that you lynch a townie, no biggie! But then why lynch a townie if you don't really think he's scum but are just assuming stuff. Why not wait to actually get a scum read on someone and then cast a stone? Don't be scum and play wise."


This is just ... no way a newb could possibly put such mafia game vocab in a single paragraph without having played mafia before. This reeks of a fellow mafia player telling Dolphin how to diffuse the shit hole he dug himself into.

To be totally honest I've played Mafia in real life once and it was lots of fun.

I also played a warewolf game this one time, so I guess that's twice.

As for townie talk, I learned from the best I watched you guys play.

pervert



Anyway - I think that neither happyD or prof are scum (t!hough one can never be sure with prof - if he uses logic it is a lot harder to judge him)



theprof00 said:
Stefl1504 said:
Also... prof, I think you are reading too much into it^^ - tough you are appearing uncomforting reasonable this time arround, which makes you appear even scummier... lol - I hate you soo much >:(

unvote

@Rol

Why are you so eager to lynch prof ?

FoS stefl

I don't think Rol is very eager to lynch me at all, but I think you're eager to paint him as such.

Also, I love you stefl, you say the funniest things about me and my playstyle. Loved your pm to me last game haha


Indeed I am - how else should I get someone to lynch my fellow countrymen^^