Secondly im not sure about moreno. Hes a convenient scapegoat though alao possibly scum.
Id rather not lynch him today since it will be the third time weve lynched him on day 1 in a row.

^I personally don't even think he's scum, I just think he's overly on my case to the point where he made a misstep (trying to find my sibling). If he were scum, he would have never made that kind of a mistake, especially after Hat had already mentioned to Stefl how scummy that was...

It was probably just over-zeal, but I'm just a noob, what do I know?

@ manuel
i see what you mean by "seems normal", but then why did you write "used to the game" next to hat?
Are you sure you didnt mean seems like they are playing as usual?

I was not going to dig further in your sibling until you mentioned the "2 noobs".

I've said it a lot, but you cut out the list considerably, and there was no harm pointing at M.U.G.E.N.

Well the other thing is that you cant expect that a mafia wouldnt make a mistake.
Also i do not trust hat OR stefl, so again, its hard to tell.

@moreno . Well, since I'm almost sure you're town, just keep in mind I'm doing my best to keep my sibling safe, whatever it takes. Try to read between the lines.

Just a random thought.

I remember he was a bit annoyed about how many posts there were and he wants day 1 over quickly (if I remember right). All in all he seems like a veretan in the game, but hasn't done anything that looks suspicious to me.

But who am I to judge. It's my first game and I have to constantly look up special words in the mafia wiki like vanilla, fos, hos etc.

I just watched the tutorial again and it says siblings are 1 town and 1 mafia. Is that necessarily so?
If so, wouldn't a lynch of a sibling be good? I mean even if we lynched a townie the sibling mafia guy would die too, right? I know it means sacrificing a townie, but...

Don't forget, we're lots of players in this game. We don't know if there are 3rd parties, if there are two anti-factions, or any thing else really (unless we're scum, then it should be easy by deduction). But since there might be lots of townies, the game probably had to be balanced somehow. I think.

Manuel,
Generally we dont use the siblings like that.
Also when a scum/ town sibling pair is ever included in a game, it is usually necessary that both have good powers, like town cop and mafia blocker.
In that way, mafia want to kill the cop but are reluctant to lose a power mafia. Town similarly dont want to lose the cop.
That pair usually lasts for a while.

Its possible given the metagame, but without knowing the setup we still cant do amything about it.