By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 40. Pokemon! Gotta Catch them all!

theprof00 on 22 April 2012
happydolphin said:
Prof, nen-suer said it's not a good thing for town that I'm an exposed sibling because now we need to use the doctor on me and it's a waste of a use of a role. But why does that logic work?

Isn't it better to know who to protect day 1 than to just take a blind guess?

All doc needs to know is the good targets to protect.

ANy of the people making discussion, not accusing people (ie myself, linkz, )

You, and youve already hinted at your sibling so it shouldn't be too hard for the dco to figure out.

Mafia doesn't want to lose a kill, so it will be hard for them to decide, as the doc could be protecting anyone of them.



Around the Network
manuel on 22 April 2012
theprof00 said:
manuel said:

Here's my list of who looks suspicious or not:

Probably town: Final-Fan (seems normal), Hatmoza (seems like normal/used to the game), spurgeonryan (seems normal), M.U.G.E.N (doesn't post so often, but isn't suspicious to me), RolStoppable (seems normal), TruckOSaurus (seems normal), Wonktonodi (quite sure about him), nen-suer (seems normal)

Undecided: Linkzmax (didn't notice him too much), stefl1504 (sure likes to vote and unvote a lot),  NintendoPie (not as active as expected), V the p00 (prof) (not sure...),  pezus (tending to think town, but not sure), supermario128 (not sure...), Linkzmax (not sure...), BasilZero (he basically left, so I assume he has no powerful role to say the least)

Probably/maybe scum: happydolphin (argues a lot; sibling story could be true or made up and there's really no way to tell), Radishhead (not really sure, could probably put him to undecided, too), morenoingrato (asks people to reveal pm info, which is forbidden by rules... but I'm very close to put him in my undecided category)

Most of it is gut feeling.

I might have missed some fine nuances (if there are any) of the discussion, because I practically raced through several hundred posts.

I'd like to know why you put linkzmax in undecided twice, once saying didn't notice him too much, and once saying not sure.

Your list of towns are a lot of the people I suspect. Next to some you say "seems normal". What does that mean? 

I copied their names from the opening post and somehow Linkzmax slid in twice. Sorry. (It's been a long day and I'm  a bit sleepy)

"seems normal" means I don't find them suspicious. (Sorry for lack of better words)



Need something off Play-Asia? http://www.play-asia.com/

Moren on 22 April 2012

@Pezus:

1. And I will keep doing it, if I'm still convinced he is Mafia.

2. I fail to see how they wouldn't have figured it out, there are only 5 newbies.

3. That was several pages ago, and you probably said it because someone pointed it out.

4. This attitude that just repeats what everyone is saying is exactly why I suspect you, but just a little bit.



theprof00 on 22 April 2012
NintendoPie said:
theprof00 said:
Happy, your problem is that your high strung. You need to reset yourself.

What you need to do is stop assuming what other players *would* do. You do not have enough experience to know what a player or role would or wouldn't do.

Also, try to be 100% clear in everything you say. If you reference something make sure it's obvious to everyone what you are saying. If someone asks something from you, do not explode. You must play it cool, think calmly what to do.

For instance, when someone says who is your sibling, you can say "I don't know if that is the most appropriate thing for me to do. I don't know if you're asking me as scum or town, but what I do know is that I can't make that decision for town without town's input"

Simple.

What's your reason for trying to help him get back on track? Do you know something we don't?

I'm a vet and I know a townie when I see it.

That being said much of everything revolving around him is garbage. Remove the cause, filter the thread.



happydolphin on 22 April 2012
theprof00 said:

All doc needs to know is the good targets to protect.

ANy of the people making discussion, not accusing people (ie myself, linkz, )

You, and youve already hinted at your sibling so it shouldn't be too hard for the dco to figure out.

Mafia doesn't want to lose a kill, so it will be hard for them to decide, as the doc could be protecting anyone of them.

Thanks.

About moreno, don't you think that he's town or 3rd party? At this point if he were scum, his peers would have told him to stfu, am I right or not on this, idk.



Around the Network
manuel on 22 April 2012

But how would they tell him to shut up? Talking outside the thread is forbidden, right?



Need something off Play-Asia? http://www.play-asia.com/

happydolphin on 22 April 2012

^We've assumed this far that scum can talk during the day, that's what I understood. Mario mentioned it, Linkz mentioned it, hatz approved it, it's been said here and there.



theprof00 on 22 April 2012

2 things also.
First people who are saying doc ahould know are good leads. They arent scum but leads.
the reason being that you are actually pretty valuable to scum and killing you and your buddy will simply be doing town a service. Not because you are bad per se, but because mafia would rather town waste a lynch on someome who os a question mark while they kill people who are unlikely to be lynched.
of course, this is a higher level thought process, so domeone who fits the profile is likely a veteran.



Moren on 22 April 2012

@Pezus:

Not really, but I meant recently. It was a mistake, I even corrected it as soon as I noticed.

Also, please answer #2 unless you agree.



manuel on 22 April 2012
happydolphin said:
^We've assumed this far that scum can talk during the day, that's what I understood. Mario mentioned it, Linkz mentioned it, hatz approved it, it's been said here and there.


Yes, I read that assumption, but we don't know for sure, right? In that swf tutorial it says mafia talk to each other at night. Even if it's just a game, at least the basic rules should be followed in my opinion. If they do talk during day then I guess scum is really unfair scum.



Need something off Play-Asia? http://www.play-asia.com/