By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 38 - Portal Theme

Anyway, having too much humans in this game I somehow would like moreno to nameclaim... to ensure that there is a bit of pressure on him:

Vote moreno



Around the Network
spurgeonryan said:
NoCtiS_NoX said:
I don't want to vote just yet. Don't want to rush things.

Anyways, I noticed spurge is awfully quiet this round. Hmm...



It is always about me isn't it NoCtis? Each game I play we seem to cross pathways. I say you are town though. I would have to look back on other games and see what you have said to me to see how this may be the same.

It was only an observation TBH. Last few rounds you were always everwhere with your post but since you are getting over defensively. I am thinking you could be a mafia because you don't want to post anything stupid that will make you look like a scummy. That's what running through my head right now.

Bold:

Anyway, what made you say that? I haven't posted enough words to make you say that. What made you so sure about that I am a townie unless you are mafia because scums knows there buddies. 

 

@wonk

Just like I said I don't want to rush things. Last round when we rush things it didn't us any good. 



I agree with Prof. Moreno is very reluctant to say what is he until the last second and when he was the only 1 that haven't claim yet. He claimed right away. It seems fishy.

An observation. There were 2 guys that didn't want to tell what they are and these 2 guys are Moreno and
Linkz (although he was one of the first guy to claim).

FoS:
Moreno for now.



I figured not claming could be an issue later on, and claming what I am would be useful.
@Prof: The Portal games are my favorite PC games ever, and I know there are few human characters.
Also, I can't look for or quote the post, but someone pointed out it's more of a test subject thing.

HOWEVER, Prof was very quick to point out there are only 4 human characters in Portal, and I'm sure any non-scum human will find that very odd considering their roles.
You see, if you're Mafia, you shouldn't know the test subtjects are random.

Vote: Prof



I'm feeling so refreshed after a loooong sleep. There's a fair amount of things to comment on since my last post, but instead of my usual n-tuple quote posts I'll just address the minor things in one post.

The radish situation:
radish is as obvtown as he can get. I've lost the little bit of trust I had for prof after voting radish for continuing to do what he does as town and then pinning him into one of two possible roles or saying he'll be lynched. I'm wary of FF as well, showing up finally and voting an easy target fairly quickly.
As long as I'm alive, we are not lynching radish, period. So @Final-Fan: please unvote.

Noctis/spurge:
I know I've quickly leaned town with a few people this round, but spurge called Noctis town after this and this. I know they have not played enough rounds together for either to recognize town-on-town interaction, and those two posts aren't telling either. What I see is spurge trying to imitate my behavior with Wonk, but as Noctis points out, scum(especially newb scum) have a habit of calling others town before they should know that.
As a side note, until he had caved, I did like spurge's reasoning for refusing to "type"claim.

moreno:
I saw nothing wrong with his refusal to claim, but finally claiming when he was last does seem shady. I'm not making anything of the 5 human claims to 4 humans Portal characters though. He seems familiar with the theme and knew there were very few characters in Portal. I don't think he would make a mistake like that if scum. I'm not sure if that means we should look into one of the other human claims or if there is another explanation though.



Around the Network

Looks like I was "ninja"d while typing that up. I think you were remembering Stefl's post. "I think that glados is just trying use human test subjects pited against each other" It doesn't mean that humans can't be mafia or that you're both telling the truth, but it does give some credibility to your story.

Gotta rethink things now. I was ready to vote Stefl for starting the setup meta,(especially for mentioning third party, which Mafia is more worried about than town on day 1)  rolefishing , and something else that slips my mind at the moment.(though I never planned on mentioning it either, wanted to leave something for someone else to pick up on so I could get a read on them too)



To further add something into my theory.

Prof claimed to be town, so:
You're lying.
You're Cave or Caroline, most likely scum.
You're Chell or Doug, most likely power role.

There's no way you are non-conventional human like me. So tell me, who are you?



Note*

In the post above, I meant:
"Prof claimed to be human, so:"
My bad



Waaaiit. Why would you want to analyze Portal's characters and then warn against a relatively safe way of helping narrow who could be what?

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4437181

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=4438189



Well, I wanted to analyze possible Mafia characters, but I didn't want townies or power roles to accidentally reveal themselves with a dangerous claim.