It's been one year since Kinect and Move have been out (a bit over actually) and had a few big releases on each device. On the other hand Wii motion Plus has been out for over 2 years. I think it's fair to judge which one is better since it's been a while the three devices have been released.

What is your opinion?

Rank 1. PS Move/Kinect 9/10

Rank 3. Wii Motion Plus 7.5/10

Wii Motion Plus:

 I'll start off with the WM+ in simple wods its good but not great. The controls are fairly accurate and it has a decent selection of games due to the fact that it came a year and a half before both Kinect and Move. I don't own a Wii but I have played enough of it to judge it. To be honest with you I really hated the original Wii motion controller because the camera/sensor was really off and it took me plenty of time to learn how to properly use it. As mentioned earlier since I don't own a Wii I would play it at my cousin's house mostly and would stay overnight as he lives in a different country then I do. By the time I had to leave I had just got the hang of the Wii motion controlller (original) and I would play the Wii a little while later forgeting everything I learnt which got on my nerves pretty freqeuntly. Wii Motion Plus has improved upon the original Wii controller but the precision and accuracy still needs some improvement. 

PS Move/Kinect:

To start off with both these devices are great and are worth a buy. Kinect has much more innovation but PS Move seems like a much more polished product more so when your comparing to the Wii controllers. Kinect dominates in Dance/ Party and Sports game while PS Move dominates in Shooters, action adventure games etc. Kinect does have some issues and lags but it never seems to irrate the hell out of me but it can get annoying once in a while. And MS just took its number one game type (shooters) and threw it into a garbage disrespectfully. I feel like an idiot when I'm playing shooting games on Kinect. I would like some sort of gun similar to the PS Move Sharpshooter which is great. Other than that Kinect is a great device. PS Move is also great almost perfect for shooting games and the precision, accuarcy is really great and the gameplay feels polished. Although for some reason the sensitivity is way too off for my liking. Either I turn way too fast or way too slow and while moving it does feel a bit too high. But both are great devices and I give it a tie.

1. Move

2. Motion +

3. Kinect

Kinect still doesn't work and move actually has an analogue and is more precise.

The device itself:

1. Move
2. Kinect
3. Motion Plus


The games:

1. Motion Plus
2. Kinect
3. Move


Overall:

1. Kinect
2. Motion Plus
3. Move

Wel I only have a kinect motionplus... But overal I like the kinect better. I know it's not perfect and there are a lot of disastergames. But the good ones are very fun. And it's just so special to move with your whole body instead of with a controller ;)

1. Kinect (playing games such as Fruit ninja is like working out)
2. Move
3. Motion +

By Specific Games:

Motion Plus
Kinect
Move

By Accuracy:
Move
Motion Plus
Kinect

By Hybrid Games:
Move
Motion Plus
Kinect

Best Fantasy Motion Control configuration:
Kinect camera + Move Wand + Wii Nunchuck (if only this was possible)

The device itself:

1. Move (super accurate)
2. Motion Plus
3. kinect

The games: 

1. Move (Sports Champions, Killzone 3, and inFamous really show off how great a device it is, and to a lesser extent: Resistance, MAG, and SOCOM)
2. Motion Plus
3. Kinect


Overall:

1. Move (super accurate, precise, has the core games i like and are really good with it)
2. Motion Plus (really accurate, has some core games, not much suport)
3. Kinect (not very accurate, has no core games, but has fun arcadey games)

Based on games, Wii Motion Plus > PlayStation Move > Kinect

i think he means, games that require the device.

so he thinks Motion plus > kinect > Move in games that require the device

1. Move- as I get to play hardcore games, as well as casual titles. It has fantastic accuracy, and I love using it with the sharpshooter.
2. Motion plus
3. Kinect