+ Witcher 2
- Zelda: Skyward Sword

+ Batman: Arkham City
- Rayman

+ Dead Space 2

- Pokemon B&W
- The Old Republic
- Deus Ex:HR

This list and thread is really unfair. So many haters with no life come back every three hours just to vote down a game they haven't played but since its on a different console they just love to hate it. A real game of the year thread would be only to vote once for your favourite game and once for the game you dislike. Because its the same people constantly hating the same game 20 times because they have nothing better to do. I expected better from the VGC community. Either a bunch of 13 year old's have taken over this site or just adults acting like kids when it comes to games. Disappointing...

+ Zelda: SS (if gone, then SM3D Land)
- Saint's Row (if gone, then The Witcher 2)

+ Dark Souls
- Deus Ex

+ Batman: Arkham City
- Mario kart 7

This is a corrupted competition really, I only voted for games that I played (down or up) and some haters are downgrading a lot of the good games this year.

+dead space 2
-zelda SS

+Skyward Sword
-Minecraft