Sounds like you should go with the PS3 if you don't like paying for online and are most interested in the exclusives each console has to offer. I would suggest the Wii but it sounds like most Nintendo IPs aren't to your liking. To put it simple.... Go buy a PS3.. Now, I must go vomit for recommending Sony.

never say never,

why not pick one up they are much cheaper now and have some great deals,whichever one you choose

i only know psn and i enjoy that too,i'm sure xboxlive and wiware(or whatever nintendo have) are the same

i have a PC too but its not a mega super one or anything

True enough 

Dont waste your $$ just stick with your PC a while longer then go next gen

The problem with going next gen right out of the gate is that most of the problems that occur in consoles usually show up in the first wave of the systems, which means that in 2-3 years time, he would most likely need to buy another system to replace his old one.

true classic example is the YOLD and RROD

No, it´s not too late...we´re probably 2 years away, at least, from all next generation consoles being released...still plenty of time for you.

Nintendo's always have been associated with quality in their hardware (apart from the NES), although I think any disc-based system might eventually wear down to the point of breaking if it's used a lot.

PS3

I would say at this stage to get a ps3. I think the nextbox will release before the ps4. Also if you dont like to pay for online its good. I haven't played their exclusives but they do look good.