By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Twas the Night Before Christmas-Mafia Round 35

Votals:

Player/Remaining Votes L-4 L-5
Final-Fan - -
Hatmoza - -
Stefl1504 TruckOSaurus -

With 8 remaining players, a lynch occurs on 5 votes.

 

Voting history:

Final-Fan (L-): Hatmoza, theprof

Hatmoza (L-): theprof

Stefl (L-): TruckO



updated: 14.01.2012

playing right now: Xenoblade Chronicles

Hype-o-meter, from least to most hyped:  the Last Story, Twisted Metal, Mass Effect 3, Final Fantasy XIII-2, Final Fantasy Versus XIII, Playstation ViTA

bet with Mordred11 that Rage will look better on Xbox 360.

Around the Network
Stefl1504 said:

Sorry to disappoint you... but it looks like you are wrong the first time this game - sadly I would've hoped that you would be right again, anyway since I am going to get lynched either way since my morale is quite at a low point now and the game, while starting slowly but somehow entertaining has grown boring to me isn't tempting me to fight since either way towns going to win this one (unless epic fail occurs day 4,5...) anyway do not mind voting for me since I am here inside by cookie-jar and happy about it... well I have made all my points I wanted to make today and hopefully it will help you after everyone is going to follow you, MVP so far, blindly... also please do not ignore my ignoring of some posts, it might come in handy sometime later in the game... cheers to a town win anyway^^ 

Man I feel depressed today...

If that's some strategy on your part, let me say that I hate it.

Luckily for you, rereading your first day posts have inserted a doubt in my mind since you've mentionned very early on that your character was unknown to you and that you didn't know its role in the movie. [post][post]

Now there's still things that bug me like your first post mentionning that "you like your role and that it's nice to be something else sometimes". What did you mean by that?



Signature goes here!

Stefl1504 said:
Vetteman94 said:
Stefl1504 said:

I am going to ask the question - what has changed your opinion on me... well I think I get it why (well its not too hard to find out) your opinion has changed - just wanted to hear you speak it out.

I don't really get why you are trusting Vette that much but I don't think I will get any better explanation from you than ToS did...

Maybe I am wrong... but I have got the feeling that I saw a post where Hat claimed Vanilla earlier this game... (before day 3)...

Looking at the question if there really is a vig - what other roles could there be than a vig that isn't interested in killing every day (lets rule out a SK that got blocked night one) - okay then - So either we have a one-shot-vig, a vig, or SK + Doc... what does look like the likeliest... in my opinion the one shot vig...

Also Vette hasn't really paid attention to the thread because when he posted this hat has already said this - to note: hat responded to Vettes question with "shits and giggles"  - I know Vette hasn't really asked about the vote in general but looking at Hatmozas earlier post the question was quite useless...

One shot vig isnt likely at all,  given that they have already used their ability, why not come forward now?  It would make the day easier as it would be one less suspect.  But its quite obvious that they have multiple shots or are even unlimited in ability and using it wisely.  Hence why we havent seen them come out yet.

As for your poor attempt at discrediting my question,  he mentions it a couple times he believes he is the Vigilante.  Why would you want to force a roleclaim on someone in that position?  

Maybe because SKs are often forced to kill and by forcing the SK to claim vig and there is still a kill occuring you could know that the claimed vig is in fact a SK (unless he has the luck to hit the same person as scum or the doced person) - further the Vig could get Doced and hopefully the mafia kill would fail - well there is in fact the posibility that he loses his powers permanently, even that could turn out positive... (considering a vig still could kill a townie)

So what you would want to do is have a vigilante claim, where he would probably lose his power, all so you could confirm he is a vigilante and not a SK. Cause not every instance of a serial killer is forced to kill every night,  hell we had one game where the SK didnt kill anyone over the course of 3 or 4 days because he was afraid of getting tracked.    

With the Vigilante claiming he will probably lose his power,  why would the mafia kill someone that they know has no power? 



TruckOSaurus said:
Stefl1504 said:

Sorry to disappoint you... but it looks like you are wrong the first time this game - sadly I would've hoped that you would be right again, anyway since I am going to get lynched either way since my morale is quite at a low point now and the game, while starting slowly but somehow entertaining has grown boring to me isn't tempting me to fight since either way towns going to win this one (unless epic fail occurs day 4,5...) anyway do not mind voting for me since I am here inside by cookie-jar and happy about it... well I have made all my points I wanted to make today and hopefully it will help you after everyone is going to follow you, MVP so far, blindly... also please do not ignore my ignoring of some posts, it might come in handy sometime later in the game... cheers to a town win anyway^^ 

Man I feel depressed today...

If that's some strategy on your part, let me say that I hate it.

Luckily for you, rereading your first day posts have inserted a doubt in my mind since you've mentionned very early on that your character was unknown to you and that you didn't know its role in the movie. [post][post]

Now there's still things that bug me like your first post mentionning that "you like your role and that it's nice to be something else sometimes". What did you mean by that?


Honestly? I am just in a real bad mood today so maybe thats why I post such shit...

@ bold - that was already discussed earlier... (prof (I think... or was it linkz?) and I discussed about it, since he remembered me saying I dislike being vanilla and I said its nice to be something else sometimes, while I responded with that I haven't played in a long time and that I haven't been vanilla in a long time (additionally prolonged by me not playing)



Vetteman94 said:
Stefl1504 said:
Vetteman94 said:
Stefl1504 said:

I am going to ask the question - what has changed your opinion on me... well I think I get it why (well its not too hard to find out) your opinion has changed - just wanted to hear you speak it out.

I don't really get why you are trusting Vette that much but I don't think I will get any better explanation from you than ToS did...

Maybe I am wrong... but I have got the feeling that I saw a post where Hat claimed Vanilla earlier this game... (before day 3)...

Looking at the question if there really is a vig - what other roles could there be than a vig that isn't interested in killing every day (lets rule out a SK that got blocked night one) - okay then - So either we have a one-shot-vig, a vig, or SK + Doc... what does look like the likeliest... in my opinion the one shot vig...

Also Vette hasn't really paid attention to the thread because when he posted this hat has already said this - to note: hat responded to Vettes question with "shits and giggles"  - I know Vette hasn't really asked about the vote in general but looking at Hatmozas earlier post the question was quite useless...

One shot vig isnt likely at all,  given that they have already used their ability, why not come forward now?  It would make the day easier as it would be one less suspect.  But its quite obvious that they have multiple shots or are even unlimited in ability and using it wisely.  Hence why we havent seen them come out yet.

As for your poor attempt at discrediting my question,  he mentions it a couple times he believes he is the Vigilante.  Why would you want to force a roleclaim on someone in that position?  

Maybe because SKs are often forced to kill and by forcing the SK to claim vig and there is still a kill occuring you could know that the claimed vig is in fact a SK (unless he has the luck to hit the same person as scum or the doced person) - further the Vig could get Doced and hopefully the mafia kill would fail - well there is in fact the posibility that he loses his powers permanently, even that could turn out positive... (considering a vig still could kill a townie)

So what you would want to do is have a vigilante claim, where he would probably lose his power, all so you could confirm he is a vigilante and not a SK. Cause not every instance of a serial killer is forced to kill every night,  hell we had one game where the SK didnt kill anyone over the course of 3 or 4 days because he was afraid of getting tracked.    

With the Vigilante claiming he will probably lose his power,  why would the mafia kill someone that they know has no power? 

Honestly I misread your question a little bit - I don't think its necessary to force anyone to roleclaim right now - I was trying to think of a way someone could consider  forcing the vig to roleclaim being necessary.

Mafia often kill people without power if they think there aren't any powers left or if they want to remove a confirmed towny from the game (which a vig without a counterclaim would be right now)



Around the Network

Honestly... there I am getting a little bit excited about this game again and then there is no one here to ask me question... maybe I am going to play skyrim a little bit or to reread some of the old posts... well I think Skyrim is the winner in this round...



Stefl1504 said:
Honestly... there I am getting a little bit excited about this game again and then there is no one here to ask me question... maybe I am going to play skyrim a little bit or to reread some of the old posts... well I think Skyrim is the winner in this round...


who do you think should be lynched today?

who are you most suspicious of?

who do you trust the most?

why did you guys pick MG?



Stefl1504 said:

TruckOSaurus said:
I'll get into details later (this site is testing my patience right now) but barring any major revelations upon rereading his posts. I want Stefl to die today.

Yesterday, I mentionned that his name "Undersea Gal" did nothing to sway me either way on him but today I'm reconsidering this position and I'm willing to bet that "Undersea Gal" is a fakeclaim. It is so obscure that I can't shake the feeling it's a name picked by scum because they figured nobody would have it.

Vote: Stefl

useless rant

@bolded

Well thats the sad thing about my character - honestly though - looking back at the FMA (now Maes Hughes wasn't really a major role from the series (though he was important to the story) game I would never dare to fakeclaim again... after all it got me lynched^^ - well really honestly - I would if scum^^... but to me there is no real reason to fakeclaim this game so I WOULD NEVER dare to do so

Now I never watched that movie and I can't say if "Undersea Gal" is more relevant to it than "Mr. Hyde" or some other minor roles, but I don't think that matters all I know is that there were some minor roles so far and that there where some major characters. Whily I would like to say thats an argument for me, it isn't, though if that IS your major doubt about me I would like you to make others characterroleclaim, well scrap that I am going to do it myself:

Are people so kind to nameclaim a bit so we could get a little insight which characters are still out there (IF your name hints at your role please consider doing so (I remember from KH that there was a mayor and a doctor inside Nightmare before Christmas))



Wonktonodi said:
Stefl1504 said:
Honestly... there I am getting a little bit excited about this game again and then there is no one here to ask me question... maybe I am going to play skyrim a little bit or to reread some of the old posts... well I think Skyrim is the winner in this round...


who do you think should be lynched today?

who are you most suspicious of?

who do you trust the most?

why did you guys pick MG?


1) Don't really know yet

2) Hummm... well Vette is kind of not participating much so far I wish for him to be town^^ but there is not a little reason for me to think he is town.

3) Hatmoza by far... the recent weather told me so. Then ToS...

4) I don't know if your talking about my multiple personae but if you are - we didn't pick MG for anything...



Before I nameclaim, I want to know if other people besides Stef support claims of names that may give a clue to a role.



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~