By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - 3DS vs. Vita

 

Which handheld do you think will be better?

Vita 190 44.60%
 
3DS 207 48.59%
 
Both will be the same 8 1.88%
 
I don't care 21 4.93%
 
Total:426
brendude13 on 25 September 2011
thetonestarr said:
Yes, but you can't really use the original material as a model. Different system = different coding, and being updated can also mean cleaner coding.

True, Resident Evil 4 was only 3.3gb's on XBL / PSN.

...But then again, it was one disc on the Gamecube.

I still think the MGS HD Collection would be over 10gb though, and I still think Konami wouldn't put it on the 3DS.



Around the Network
Linkasf on 25 September 2011

3DS here... I mean at least it's a handheld device, unlike the Vita, which felt like an Ipad... Leave it at home, it gets the job done there.



sepoer on 25 September 2011

I remember about month ago, some people still mocking 3DS battery life. But, I really don't care about battery. Because If my 3ds battery already empty I'm gonna charge it, and then playing psv :D.
This mean, I'm gonna buy both system but I play 3DS first and then Vita.



thetonestarr on 25 September 2011
brendude13 said:
thetonestarr said:
Yes, but you can't really use the original material as a model. Different system = different coding, and being updated can also mean cleaner coding.

True, Resident Evil 4 was only 3.3gb's on XBL / PSN.

...But then again, it was one disc on the Gamecube.

I still think the MGS HD Collection would be over 10gb though, and I still think Konami wouldn't put it on the 3DS.

The XBL/PSN version included the PS2 version's extra content, didn't it? That would explain why it'd be bigger than the GC version.

Personally, I agree with you on the unlikelihood of being on 3DS, but I don't think size will be a deciding factor.



 SW-5120-1900-6153

MasterVG71782 on 25 September 2011
thetonestarr said:
brendude13 said:
thetonestarr said:
Yes, but you can't really use the original material as a model. Different system = different coding, and being updated can also mean cleaner coding.

True, Resident Evil 4 was only 3.3gb's on XBL / PSN.

...But then again, it was one disc on the Gamecube.

I still think the MGS HD Collection would be over 10gb though, and I still think Konami wouldn't put it on the 3DS.

The XBL/PSN version included the PS2 version's extra content, didn't it? That would explain why it'd be bigger than the GC version.

Personally, I agree with you on the unlikelihood of being on 3DS, but I don't think size will be a deciding factor.

The size of the games will only be a problem if you do a direct download from the store (for Vita), especially if you buy a lot of them.



Around the Network
Kyuubi Ricky SSJ2 on 25 September 2011
brendude13 said:
thetonestarr said:
Yes, but you can't really use the original material as a model. Different system = different coding, and being updated can also mean cleaner coding.

True, Resident Evil 4 was only 3.3gb's on XBL / PSN.

...But then again, it was one disc on the Gamecube.

I still think the MGS HD Collection would be over 10gb though, and I still think Konami wouldn't put it on the 3DS.


Resident Evil 4 on the Gamecube was on 2 discs.



brendude13 on 25 September 2011
Kyuubi Ricky SSJ2 said:
brendude13 said:
thetonestarr said:
Yes, but you can't really use the original material as a model. Different system = different coding, and being updated can also mean cleaner coding.

True, Resident Evil 4 was only 3.3gb's on XBL / PSN.

...But then again, it was one disc on the Gamecube.

I still think the MGS HD Collection would be over 10gb though, and I still think Konami wouldn't put it on the 3DS.


Resident Evil 4 on the Gamecube was on 2 discs.

I thought so, I looked into it on google and some people were saying it was one disc.

I only just found out a minute ago it was 2 when I looked up a walkthrough and saw the part where he had to change discs.

My bad.



Deadlikeme on 25 September 2011
MasterVG71782 said:

I've been seeing a lot of topics where people have been comparing the two, so I thought maybe we could keep it all in one thread. I figured this part of the forum would be ideal, although there might be some sales discussions between the two. Maybe I'll start off by listing some PROs and CONs of the two systems (my knowledge of the 3DS is a bit rusty, so feel free to add more to that; feel free to add PROs and CONs to both).

Feel free to offer any more PROs and CONs for the two systems, if you feel I have any missing.

3DS PROs
- First party lineup
- Some big third party franchises (Monster Hunter, for example)
- Casual appeal
- Glasses-free 3D
- Virtual Console (access to old Game Boy titles and the like are a plus)
- Head start over competition
- Unanswered holiday period in 2011 in US and EMEAA regions
- Recent price cut puts it at an edge
- StreetPass allows for interactivity with other systems easily (even while in sleep mode)

3DS CONs
- Identity crisis (i.e. some people don't view it as much of an upgrade over DS)
- The less powerful of the two
- Region locked
- Started off with barely any games (will be remedied this holiday season)
- 3D effect has been said to make some people feel ill

Vita PROs
- Clearly the more powerful of the two
- Cross platform ability with PS3 (remote play, playing a title on both PS3/Vita with same save)
- Access to large library of games on PSN
- Not region locked
- Strong launch line-up
- Built-in second analog stick (some people consider it a plus over 3DS)
- Good amount of apps for the system (Social networking, for example)
- Near system allows interaction with other nearby players

Vita CONs
- No clear system selling games (like Nintendo's first party/Monster Hunter)
- 3G plan might be expensive (it seems so in Japan, but no announcements for outside of Japan yet)
- Memory cards are considered expensive
- No 2011 holiday release in US and EMEAA
- Debuting at a higher price ($250/300 for Vita vs. $170 for 3DS)
- No UMD option (people with a PSP and a lot of UMD games are left in the dust until Sony decides to announce a program to exchange UMD to digital)

Some things I didn't list include the battery life (about the same for both systems, so no advantage to either), the external battery for the Vita (don't think much is known about it, except that it will extend the battery life, but price and some other stuff is unknown, so can't place it).

 

EDIT (9/20/11) - Added StreetPass (3DS) and Near (Vita) to the PROs categories of both systems.

I disagree with alot of what you put in pros and cons for starters with 3DS

1."Some big third party franchises (Monster Hunter, for example)" PSV is going to have that franchise as well as most other 3DS franchises I don't think there are any exclusive 3rd party franchises for the 3DS. 

2. "Glasses-free 3D" is this really a pro? All the advantages of 3D get taken away with it being on such a small screen that is likely to move around a bit, also you can't use gyroscope and 3D at the same time. 

3. "- Head start over competition- Unanswered holiday period in 2011 in US and EMEAA regions" Redundant, Just leave it at headstart. 

4. Lack of 3rd party support needs to be in cons

5. Can't use gyroscope and 3D at same time needs to be in cons

Now for psv

1. Didn't mention enhanced BC with digital psp games (psp games will beable to use second analogue)

2. Didn't mention massive third party support (153 devs making games for it as well as Sony)

3. Didn't mention 3G option in pros

4.  "No clear system selling games (like Nintendo's first party/Monster Hunter)" Um Uncharted and does anyone believe there isn't going to be a Monster hunter on psv, really?... This should not be here. 

5. "Debuting at a higher price" It's going to be the same price 3ds was when it debued. 

6. " No UMD option" I would call that a pro, UMDs are bulky and the drives break easy, it's a really bad medium and would just clutter the system, I'd leave this out.



brendude13 on 25 September 2011
Deadlikeme said:
MasterVG71782 said:

I've been seeing a lot of topics where people have been comparing the two, so I thought maybe we could keep it all in one thread. I figured this part of the forum would be ideal, although there might be some sales discussions between the two. Maybe I'll start off by listing some PROs and CONs of the two systems (my knowledge of the 3DS is a bit rusty, so feel free to add more to that; feel free to add PROs and CONs to both).

Feel free to offer any more PROs and CONs for the two systems, if you feel I have any missing.

3DS PROs
- First party lineup
- Some big third party franchises (Monster Hunter, for example)
- Casual appeal
- Glasses-free 3D
- Virtual Console (access to old Game Boy titles and the like are a plus)
- Head start over competition
- Unanswered holiday period in 2011 in US and EMEAA regions
- Recent price cut puts it at an edge
- StreetPass allows for interactivity with other systems easily (even while in sleep mode)

3DS CONs
- Identity crisis (i.e. some people don't view it as much of an upgrade over DS)
- The less powerful of the two
- Region locked
- Started off with barely any games (will be remedied this holiday season)
- 3D effect has been said to make some people feel ill

Vita PROs
- Clearly the more powerful of the two
- Cross platform ability with PS3 (remote play, playing a title on both PS3/Vita with same save)
- Access to large library of games on PSN
- Not region locked
- Strong launch line-up
- Built-in second analog stick (some people consider it a plus over 3DS)
- Good amount of apps for the system (Social networking, for example)
- Near system allows interaction with other nearby players

Vita CONs
- No clear system selling games (like Nintendo's first party/Monster Hunter)
- 3G plan might be expensive (it seems so in Japan, but no announcements for outside of Japan yet)
- Memory cards are considered expensive
- No 2011 holiday release in US and EMEAA
- Debuting at a higher price ($250/300 for Vita vs. $170 for 3DS)
- No UMD option (people with a PSP and a lot of UMD games are left in the dust until Sony decides to announce a program to exchange UMD to digital)

Some things I didn't list include the battery life (about the same for both systems, so no advantage to either), the external battery for the Vita (don't think much is known about it, except that it will extend the battery life, but price and some other stuff is unknown, so can't place it).

 

EDIT (9/20/11) - Added StreetPass (3DS) and Near (Vita) to the PROs categories of both systems.

I disagree with alot of what you put in pros and cons for starters with 3DS

1."Some big third party franchises (Monster Hunter, for example)" PSV is going to have that franchise as well as most other 3DS franchises I don't think there are any exclusive 3rd party franchises for the 3DS. 

2. "Glasses-free 3D" is this really a pro? All the advantages of 3D get taken away with it being on such a small screen that is likely to move around a bit, also you can't use gyroscope and 3D at the same time. 

3. "- Head start over competition- Unanswered holiday period in 2011 in US and EMEAA regions" Redundant, Just leave it at headstart. 

4. Lack of 3rd party support needs to be in cons

5. Can't use gyroscope and 3D at same time needs to be in cons

Now for psv

1. Didn't mention enhanced BC with digital psp games (psp games will beable to use second analogue)

2. Didn't mention massive third party support (153 devs making games for it as well as Sony)

3. Didn't mention 3G option in pros

4.  "No clear system selling games (like Nintendo's first party/Monster Hunter)" Um Uncharted and does anyone believe there isn't going to be a Monster hunter on psv, really?... This should not be here. 

5. "Debuting at a higher price" It's going to be the same price 3ds was when it debued. 

6. " No UMD option" I would call that a pro, UMDs are bulky and the drives break easy, it's a really bad medium and would just clutter the system, I'd leave this out.

It seems like you have an agenda listing 3DS cons and Vita pros.

But you have a point, those things should be added / removed from the list, especially those Vita pros.



Deadlikeme on 25 September 2011
brendude13 said:
Deadlikeme said:
MasterVG71782 said:

I've been seeing a lot of topics where people have been comparing the two, so I thought maybe we could keep it all in one thread. I figured this part of the forum would be ideal, although there might be some sales discussions between the two. Maybe I'll start off by listing some PROs and CONs of the two systems (my knowledge of the 3DS is a bit rusty, so feel free to add more to that; feel free to add PROs and CONs to both).

Feel free to offer any more PROs and CONs for the two systems, if you feel I have any missing.

3DS PROs
- First party lineup
- Some big third party franchises (Monster Hunter, for example)
- Casual appeal
- Glasses-free 3D
- Virtual Console (access to old Game Boy titles and the like are a plus)
- Head start over competition
- Unanswered holiday period in 2011 in US and EMEAA regions
- Recent price cut puts it at an edge
- StreetPass allows for interactivity with other systems easily (even while in sleep mode)

3DS CONs
- Identity crisis (i.e. some people don't view it as much of an upgrade over DS)
- The less powerful of the two
- Region locked
- Started off with barely any games (will be remedied this holiday season)
- 3D effect has been said to make some people feel ill

Vita PROs
- Clearly the more powerful of the two
- Cross platform ability with PS3 (remote play, playing a title on both PS3/Vita with same save)
- Access to large library of games on PSN
- Not region locked
- Strong launch line-up
- Built-in second analog stick (some people consider it a plus over 3DS)
- Good amount of apps for the system (Social networking, for example)
- Near system allows interaction with other nearby players

Vita CONs
- No clear system selling games (like Nintendo's first party/Monster Hunter)
- 3G plan might be expensive (it seems so in Japan, but no announcements for outside of Japan yet)
- Memory cards are considered expensive
- No 2011 holiday release in US and EMEAA
- Debuting at a higher price ($250/300 for Vita vs. $170 for 3DS)
- No UMD option (people with a PSP and a lot of UMD games are left in the dust until Sony decides to announce a program to exchange UMD to digital)

Some things I didn't list include the battery life (about the same for both systems, so no advantage to either), the external battery for the Vita (don't think much is known about it, except that it will extend the battery life, but price and some other stuff is unknown, so can't place it).

 

EDIT (9/20/11) - Added StreetPass (3DS) and Near (Vita) to the PROs categories of both systems.

I disagree with alot of what you put in pros and cons for starters with 3DS

1."Some big third party franchises (Monster Hunter, for example)" PSV is going to have that franchise as well as most other 3DS franchises I don't think there are any exclusive 3rd party franchises for the 3DS. 

2. "Glasses-free 3D" is this really a pro? All the advantages of 3D get taken away with it being on such a small screen that is likely to move around a bit, also you can't use gyroscope and 3D at the same time. 

3. "- Head start over competition- Unanswered holiday period in 2011 in US and EMEAA regions" Redundant, Just leave it at headstart. 

4. Lack of 3rd party support needs to be in cons

5. Can't use gyroscope and 3D at same time needs to be in cons

Now for psv

1. Didn't mention enhanced BC with digital psp games (psp games will beable to use second analogue)

2. Didn't mention massive third party support (153 devs making games for it as well as Sony)

3. Didn't mention 3G option in pros

4.  "No clear system selling games (like Nintendo's first party/Monster Hunter)" Um Uncharted and does anyone believe there isn't going to be a Monster hunter on psv, really?... This should not be here. 

5. "Debuting at a higher price" It's going to be the same price 3ds was when it debued. 

6. " No UMD option" I would call that a pro, UMDs are bulky and the drives break easy, it's a really bad medium and would just clutter the system, I'd leave this out.

It seems like you have an agenda listing 3DS cons and Vita pros.

But you have a point, those things should be added / removed from the list, especially those Vita pros.

No agenda it's just biased in favor of 3DS, I even let the first party thing for 3DS slide, not that I'm saying Nintendo doesn't have a great first party, it just seems to me that Sony's first party has matched theirs atleast regarding the 3DS vs Vita. Also the fact that you can't list specifics proves to me that you are the one with the agenda.