By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Can Uncharted 3 beat Gears of War 3 on metacritic?

 

Can Uncharted 3 score higher than Gears of War 3 on metacritic?

Yes 289 79.61%
 
No 46 12.67%
 
Tie 28 7.71%
 
Total:363

@Brendude
Yep. :P
I probably should get an avatar too. Maybe someday...
@CGI
You heard it here first. :)



"Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth." -My good friend Mark Aurelius

Around the Network
CGI-Quality said:
homer said:
@CGI.
Even more than 6 points. I see it not breaking into the ninteies but rather resting in the upper eighties.

That would be one of the largest drops for any franchise in just one sequel (especially something with the acclaim of the Uncharted series). Ergo, I don't see that happening, but I'm curious as to why you do. Why would Gears drop just 3 or so points and Uncharted drop nearly 10?


Killzone 3 dropped 7 points.

It was partially because of one 5/10 review, but even then, it dropped 6 points. Uncharted 3 has to mess up big time from what I am seeing in the trailers for it to be rated less than 90.

It also has to be better than uncharted 2, otherwise it might fare like bioshock 2 did.



@CGI
Yeah. Unless I am right, at which point I will never let you stop hearing it. :)
Although that looks to be unlikely so I guess you will at least have fun rubbing it in my face.



"Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth." -My good friend Mark Aurelius

I think it can level with it's score, it's like with the Crash games, the 3rd one was the best because they gradually improve the game series each instalment.



I am judging UC3 on the horribly boring e3 presentation, the lackluster beta, and the tarnish Golden Abyss has brought to the series. We shall see come November if my "prophecy" will come true.... :P
Day 1 purchase for me anyways. Vgchartz needs a clan for UC3 or some cool league or something. That would be, how some people call it, "ballin."



"Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth." -My good friend Mark Aurelius

Around the Network

Golden abyss actually looks great and looks like an handheld goty material.




Jay520 said:
S.T.A.G.E. said:
It will probably have 93-94. Uncharted 2 is probably going to be hard to beat. Uncharted as a franchise may not be as popular as Gears, but suffers the Battlefield vs COD syndrome, where the better game sells the least but will most likely have the highest scores.


The difference in quality between Gears & Uncharted is not that great. In fact, one could make a valid argument in stating Gears is better.

I agree but I think his point is Uncharted is generally viewed as the better franchise...I know I think it's better than Gears.

But of course that may change when I get to play both UC3 and Gears 3. The new Horde mode/Beast mode may win me over.



homer said:
I am judging UC3 on the horribly boring e3 presentation, the lackluster beta, and the tarnish Golden Abyss has brought to the series. We shall see come November if my "prophecy" will come true.... :P
Day 1 purchase for me anyways. Vgchartz needs a clan for UC3 or some cool league or something. That would be, how some people call it, "ballin."


Maybe I should put the league in my signature, but I'm sure you've visited it before.



Have you seen the gamelays for it? Just bad. Good for a handheld does not mean good. Perhaps some genres are better fit for consoles after all. Then again, it is probably just Sony Bend's fault for making it so unattractive. Or perhaps I am just unused to the lack of Naughty Dog's magic touch in the series.



"Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth." -My good friend Mark Aurelius

@Rainbow Yoshi
You should. That would be jolly good fun.
Also, I apologize for not quoting people like I should. I know it is my pet peeve when people respond to me without quoting me. Vgchartz messes up when I try to quote on the computer I am on right now. I also apologize for looking so pessimistic and hateful towards the Uncharted series. I love the series, but I am just bitter with Sony Bend getting their grubby hands on it. Zipper would have done a so much better job imo. They have 3rd person shooter experience so it was only logical.



"Everything we hear is an opinion, not a fact. Everything we see is a perspective, not the truth." -My good friend Mark Aurelius