To be honest, I didn't understand many peoples criticism of the game to begin with. For about two years after the game was revealed, we knew literally nothing about it other than its existence, yet that didn't stop people making assumptions about what it would be and deciding that it wasn't for them.

Now, we know a little more, and if people don't like what they hear, then that's fine, because they've actually got something that they can base that on.

On the Link should have a voice argument, I want to know who should be the voice actor, because I have my doubts that they could ever find someone to do it justice after all this time.

All I've seen so far, bloody hell awesome game!!! That's all I can say.

The first time I saw Beedle, I was like "I've seen that character somewhere before"! until Cheebee mentioned it. :D

So do I. 

I do think that HD Zelda should (and probably will) have voice acting for most of the characters, but hopefully NOT Link.

In Wink Waker, Link yells, "Come on!" when you're guiding that statue around, and that I don't mind.  But giving Link full dialogue is a bad idea, IMHO.  I think it's far more advantageous to have him just nod or shake his head when asked a question or use body language as a response.  That can really give a character, character... without actually speaking.  Remember, Zelda is not meant to be Uncharted.

And not all games that rely on a great story have to have the protagonist constantly talking to be relatable; look at the first Bioshock.  Except for a couple of short lines in the intro, I don't think your character says anything in the entire game...