By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - What will be Sony's next 90+ rated Meta game (excluding Uncharted 3)?

 

Which game will be the first to reach 90 in metacritic?

Resistance 3 31 13.25%
 
Ratchet & Clank: All 4 One 3 1.28%
 
God of War: Origins 13 5.56%
 
ICO Collection 81 34.62%
 
Twisted Metal 4 1.71%
 
Starhawk 7 2.99%
 
The Last Guardian 70 29.91%
 
Other 25 10.68%
 
Total:234
adriane23 on 08 August 2011

Dark Souls, Ico Collection, and Journey will be the next ones.



I am the Playstation Avenger.

   

Around the Network
Jay520 on 08 August 2011
adriane23 said:
Dark Souls, Ico Collection, and Journey will be the next ones.


You do realize Dark Souls is multiplat?

dj2one on 08 August 2011

I voted for ICO comes out soon and it follows the GOW collection in terms of quality will be over a 90.



Max King of the Wild on 08 August 2011

the reason Resisance 2 was scored like it was was because it went away from what made resistance a good game yet improved greatly on graphics and multiplayer. resistance 3 is looking like its going back towards its roots... that being said I dont think it will reach a 90 though... I hope it does because that will just mean the game improved and corrected what they did wrong with 2 and will be a great end to a trilogy.



Max King of the Wild on 08 August 2011
TadpoleJackson said:
CGI-Quality said:

Well for starters, Uncharted 3 will likely disprove your theory with ease. I can't see, unless something goes horribly wrong, how Uncharted 2 scores a 96 but Uncharted 3 will suddenly drop to below a 90. You'd have to have some good reasoning to compliment what you're saying. Also, even though The Last Guardian & Ico/SotC Collection aren't as safe of bets to stay above 90, they aren't out of the question either.

Therefore, the question remains; why is it that none of their announced games will see above 90 Metas?


I see Uncharted 3 and think "More of the same". I expect reviews closer to that of the original(88)

None of Sony's studios made any really what I would call "great" games for their first title of the generation. I expect scores equal to Polyphony's first title for the PS3, Gran Turismo 5(84)

Ico(90) and SotC(91) need to have aged almost perfectly for them to make it 90+. since they barely made it the first time. 

Jay520 said:

I offered him a bet for Uncharted 3, but I don't think he's going to respond.

Sorry, I went out with friends... can't sit home all weekend and post on forums, now can I? 

Sure, I'll take it 

avatar control for a month?

More of the same great graphics, story, gameplay, and awesomness! how is that bad? More of the same is great because I wanted more after Uncharted 1 and 2 ended.

none of sonys studios made good games on first try? GoW3 and LBP say hello. and I don't care what anyone says Uncharted was AAA even if it didn't get 90+...



Around the Network
TadpoleJackson on 08 August 2011
Max King of the Wild said:

1. More of the same is great because I wanted more after Uncharted 1 and 2 ended.

2.none of sonys studios made good games on first try? GoW3 and LBP say hello.

3.and I don't care what anyone says Uncharted was AAA even if it didn't get 90+...

1.Good for you 

2. MM wasn't a Sony studio with LBP. I remembered Santa Monica after my last post. That's 2 out of what 10 studios? I'm too lazy. what did Wipeout make? 

3. Good for you 



Max King of the Wild on 08 August 2011
TadpoleJackson said:
Max King of the Wild said:

1. More of the same is great because I wanted more after Uncharted 1 and 2 ended.

2.none of sonys studios made good games on first try? GoW3 and LBP say hello.

3.and I don't care what anyone says Uncharted was AAA even if it didn't get 90+...

1.Good for you 

2. MM wasn't a Sony studio with LBP. I remembered Santa Monica after my last post. That's 2 out of what 10 studios? I'm too lazy. what did Wipeout make? 

3. Good for you 



So then scratch LBP and include LBP2 since they were firsrt party then and that was their first release being so. and thats more like 4. and I have no clue out of how many but who cares?



Lafiel on 08 August 2011
TadpoleJackson said:
Out of all the games they have announced I can't see any of their games making it 90+ on meta

good for you



Max King of the Wild on 08 August 2011
Lafiel said:
TadpoleJackson said:
Out of all the games they have announced I can't see any of their games making it 90+ on meta

good for you


WIN!



Jay520 on 08 August 2011
TadpoleJackson said:

2. MM wasn't a Sony studio with LBP. I remembered Santa Monica after my last post. That's 2 out of what 10 studios? I'm too lazy. what did Wipeout make? 

Studios that did reach 90 Meta their first time on PS3
- Media Molecule 
- Santa Monica
- Guerrilla Games

Studios that didn't reach 90 Meta their first time on PS3
- Polphony Digital
- Naughty Dog
- Zipper
- SCE San Diego
- SCE London
- Evolution Studios

So that's 3 vs 6. That's not that much of a recurring trend. 

TadpoleJackson said:

Besides Guerilla I can't think of one Sony 1st party dev that passed the 90+ on their first attempt on the PS3.

The Last Guardian won't be Team ICO's first game on the PS3, so it could still reach 90 meta following your rule.