By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - What will be Sony's next 90+ rated Meta game (excluding Uncharted 3)?

 

Which game will be the first to reach 90 in metacritic?

Resistance 3 31 13.25%
 
Ratchet & Clank: All 4 One 3 1.28%
 
God of War: Origins 13 5.56%
 
ICO Collection 81 34.62%
 
Twisted Metal 4 1.71%
 
Starhawk 7 2.99%
 
The Last Guardian 70 29.91%
 
Other 25 10.68%
 
Total:234
worldlyfall on 07 August 2011

Last Guardian. But for the rest of the year other than uncharted there are no exclusive on ps3 that will score 90 and above.



Around the Network
Jay520 on 07 August 2011
CGI-Quality said:

Well for starters, Uncharted 3 will likely disprove your theory with ease. I can't see, unless something goes horribly wrong, how Uncharted 2 scores a 96 but Uncharted 3 will suddenly drop to below a 90. You'd have to have some good reasoning to compliment what you're saying. Also, even though The Last Guardian & Ico/SotC Collection aren't as safe of bets to stay above 90, they aren't out of the question either.

Therefore, the question remains; why is it that none of their announced games will see above 90 Metas?

I offered him a bet for Uncharted 3, but I don't think he's going to respond.



yo_john117 on 07 August 2011
CGI-Quality said:
yo_john117 said:

The only one I can see is the ICO collection...many of the other games will most likely just miss the 90 mark.

Don't rule out The Last Guardian.

I think it may just miss it because reviewers are much stricter now. I can see it getting reviewed like Heavy Rain.



yo_john117 on 07 August 2011
CGI-Quality said:
yo_john117 said:
CGI-Quality said:
yo_john117 said:

The only one I can see is the ICO collection...many of the other games will most likely just miss the 90 mark.

Don't rule out The Last Guardian.

I think it may just miss it because reviewers are much stricter now. I can see it getting reviewed like Heavy Rain.

Maybe, but then again, HR was virtually praised in the media. Nowadays, I rarely see such praise.

Exactly I can see it getting praised by the media/reviewers but with things the way they are it probably will just miss the 90+ mark.



TadpoleJackson on 07 August 2011
CGI-Quality said:

Well for starters, Uncharted 3 will likely disprove your theory with ease. I can't see, unless something goes horribly wrong, how Uncharted 2 scores a 96 but Uncharted 3 will suddenly drop to below a 90. You'd have to have some good reasoning to compliment what you're saying. Also, even though The Last Guardian & Ico/SotC Collection aren't as safe of bets to stay above 90, they aren't out of the question either.

Therefore, the question remains; why is it that none of their announced games will see above 90 Metas?


I see Uncharted 3 and think "More of the same". I expect reviews closer to that of the original(88)

None of Sony's studios made any really what I would call "great" games for their first title of the generation. I expect scores equal to Polyphony's first title for the PS3, Gran Turismo 5(84)

Ico(90) and SotC(91) need to have aged almost perfectly for them to make it 90+. since they barely made it the first time. 

Jay520 said:

I offered him a bet for Uncharted 3, but I don't think he's going to respond.

Sorry, I went out with friends... can't sit home all weekend and post on forums, now can I? 

Sure, I'll take it 

avatar control for a month?



Around the Network
Jay520 on 07 August 2011
Jay520 said:

I offered him a bet for Uncharted 3, but I don't think he's going to respond.

Sorry, I went out with friends... can't sit home all weekend and post on forums, now can I? 

Sure, I'll take it 

avatar control for a month?



Sure. If Uncharted 3 receives a 90 or higher metascore, then I can control your avatar for one month. If it doesn't, then you control mine. Deal?

TadpoleJackson on 07 August 2011

Jay520 said:

Sure. If Uncharted 3 receives a 90 or higher metascore, then I can control your avatar for one month. If it doesn't, then you control mine. Deal?


Ok, fine



Carl on 07 August 2011

ICO Collection and The Last Guardian will both do it.

If I could post video's on the new VGChartz, I would.



                            

IamAwsome on 07 August 2011

The Last Guardian will do it for sure.



Boutros on 07 August 2011
Carl2291 said:
ICO Collection and The Last Guardian will both do it.

If I could post video's on the new VGChartz, I would.