Neither does L4D, ironically

want to vote for any of the new games that are here.

awww. Reach is probably the only 360 game that has a chance to get past round 2, and your putting it against UC2 in round 2... Thats just mean to us 360 fans. But on a side note, once 360 games do run out, will ps3 games be put against each other head to head.

As for actual vote. I pick uncharted 2. Halo ODST had a quirky campaign, but the fact it was sold as a full price game kind of irks me. My halo 3 disk had broken when I got ODST so due to the halo 3 multiplayer I enjoyed ODST a lot more than Uncharted 2, but I won't count thats halo 3's multiplayer. Anyway Uncharted 2 had a relatively fun campaign with some aww inspiring moments. Graphics are the best on consoles this generation at least so far. Gameplay was fun though I didn't really enjoy the combat too much. ODST's campaign was great, but too short. Also I didn't like the main area that connected all the levels together.

This is really hard. Comparing my favorite Sc-fi FPS franchise to a game that excelled all my expectations. Well to start off I like TPS better than FPS games so that counts as one factor. Graphically and presentation wise Uncharted 2 was one of the best I've ever seen. But gameplay wise... this is where Halo ODST has an advantage here. ODST is a Halo game and Bungie can really make good gameplay. And I found that ODST was basically Halo 3 with 3 additional maps and 2 new vehicles so MP wise if we go on the technical approach it is even better than Halo 3. But I'm gonna have to give it to Uncharted 2 because it blew my expectations through the roof and is till date one of the best single player games I have ever played. The MP is weaker than ODST but that doesn't stop it from being great. So Uncharted 2 gets this one.

okay fine I'll probably put Halo Reach against Killzone 3 or something a bit easier. But look on the bright side Halo 3 ODST is beating Uncharted 2

lol but is that for me or the other guy?

Had this been Halo 3 I would have voted for it but IMO ODST was a very weak entry and Uncharted 2 is a godly game therefore Uncharted 2 gets my vote

Massive fail, I clicked Halo ODST instead of Uncharted 2! I much prefer Uncharted 2, better story, more fun and in all honesty generally pleasing in every way bar multiplayer. I cannot in justice give the nod to Halo ODST though given I already owned Halo 3.

Why thank you, baby squirtle

Now that's just scary!