I'm pretty sure I recall this as well.  Round 26 if my memory serves me correct.

You mean ABC, not me right? I hadn't thought of your theory, but that's because a psych fakeclaim is almost gauranteed to be suicide and there's very little reward whether it is believed or not. Even a truthful claim is dangerous, because while an SK can reduce their numbers at night, two near-confirmed townies means trouble. Thus non-mafia claiming psych would likely be targeted for a kill or roleblock.(Unless of course mafia is limited to poisoning, :P)

I'd have to disagree with you about there being very little reward.  If you have a weak townie (a weak role and/or a vanilla if they exist in this game) who would fake roleclaim being a psych, you could divert the mafia from attacking a potentially more powerful target and divert it towards a weak town asset.  Even if there was an actual psych out there, it could potentially give him more time to find the SK while the fake claimed psych is being targeted.

Yes, he is right. That game was so short and all of the mafia were outted so quickly based on early joking day one that I didn't really get a look at how any of them would behave without heat already on them. I think radish was killed night one by the SK.

I think I also forgot the SW round where I believe he was part of the Jedi cult and was NKed by the Sith. My memory of others' previous roles is far less reliable than the records I keep on my computer. So my theory of setting up an early explanation for being alive later doesn't seem to fit, but there does seem to be reason for him to fear night kills as scum, though nothing when he was town. The inattentiveness this game weighs heavier than my own theory, but radish is still a distant third on my suspect list compared to the other two.

inconclusive this day is indeed.... I'm not fond of early small games, everyone plays pretty defensive from the start ^^

on Radish... what irks me the most is his "i did this to have the discussion going".... as I don't see how that fits as town or scum... it really smells like a made up reason and an other one of his usual slips... then again he slips as town too so....

on FF... still waiting for Hat's comments.

ST... well the original post didn't shock me so i don't really feel related to the discussion so far.

on others.... meh...

If Heph doesn't think my defense amounted to anything I don't know what he expected me to say.

I am really not liking radish's posts; IMO he seems to be reverting to his earlier "say anything to look good" behavior which I thought he'd outgrown, so I suspect he's scum.

OTOH I'm not sure whether hatmoza thinks I know something that indicates I'm pro town, or he's just scum backing off.

I was speaking about scum fakeclaiming psych. I think town fakeclaiming it would be faaar more of a distraction than the reward you suggest. I could go on and on about the harmful reprecussions but that's not really going to get us anywhere.

Yes a towny fake claiming Psych would be worse for us.  

And yeah I meant ABC originally,  I dont know how I mixed you two up

I gave a reason, my reason is I agree with what hatmoza has said. Would it be enough for me to vote on Day Two? I don't think so but on Day One this is enough for me.

My gut tells me it's none of these things. You felt compelled to post, you went a quick empty statement and when you started getting heat for it, you just started adding potenial meanings to what was essentially a worthless post.