By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Nintendo can brick your 3DS, Free Software Foundation doesn't like that

mysticwolf said:
Mr Khan said:

I think they're being somewhat overreactive. Here i'll agree that Nintendo should definitely take a certain degree of responsibility for bricked consoles (especially consoles bricked in the process of being repaired), but Nintendo's saying this in a more "cover your ass" sorta deal. They're saying *if* consoles brick due to some unforeseen incompatibility, it's not their problem (which i take a bit of issue with).

The 3DS was not meant to be bricked. Therefore, it isn't Nintendo's fault, or their problem, if one decides to take a risk by bricking it. If it is used the way it is supposed to be used, then it should not need to be bricked and/or repaired.

In what kind of situation might it need to be bricked?

p.s. i don't really know what Im talking about

Well they seem to be thinking Nintendo's saying "we reserve the right to brick your system whenever we damn well please," which in purely legal terms is true, but it's one of those matters of legal binding that cannot be applied (like the parts of the PSN's EULA regarding what you can and can't do to your PS3 which are not legally binding even if you agree to them), because it violates basic consumer protection concepts.

But Nintendo's not going to be maliciously bricking pirated consoles, or i damn well hope they don't as that would be quite evil of them, Nintendo's just saying if you modify the firmware in such a way that an unforeseen (and unprepared for) incompatibility arises with official software updates, you can't sue Nintendo, though i believe that if you got a good enough lawyer, you probably could, because they share at least partial responsibility for the bricking if it comes from their update (i.e. you did not brick it directly by putting homebrew on. They did not brick it directly by sending their update out, but the two interacted in such a way as it was bricked, and therefore Nintendo assumes partial responsibility for destroying your personal property)



Monster Hunter: pissing me off since 2010.

Around the Network

They said the same thing about the Wii, nop? 



Sig thanks to Saber! :D 

IamAwsome said:

 So it's official, Nintendo can brick your 3DS with a software update. The Free Software Foundation (whoever they are) is targeting Nintendo in an Anti-DRM campaign because of it.

Android's mobile operating system is based on the Linux kernel. Google and other members of the Open Handset Alliance collaborated on Android's development and release.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linux_kernel

The Linux kernel is released under the GNU General Public License version 2 (GPLv2)


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GPL

Author: Free Software Foundation

Knowledge is power, son.



This is great.



As always, I agree with the free software foundation in principle but not in practice ...



Around the Network

sony gets a crazy amount of bad press for making it difficult to hack on their console while nintendo bricks your console if you try and gets this?

i hope theres a huge amount of backlash for nintendo if this is indeed true



KylieDog said:

If they do not want me to use a flashcart then the answer is simple.

 

Stop making the only case for the games larger than the actual console.  What 'genius' at Nintendo sat and thought "Hey you know those tiny and easy to carry about protective cases we have with the GB and GBA games?   Yeah lets ditch those on the next portable system and use a game case larger than the actual console".  And what prat approved the idea.

This is a shit excuse for piracy, since no-one is forcing you to carry the cases around.



WHERE IS MY KORORINPA 3

That's old news that had been already discuss here.

This is just in their EULA to cover their ass if your console get brick when you update because of none compatible equipement (flash card) or custom firmware. The funny things is that this line also been on the Wii EULA, and when did Nintendo intentionaly brick modded Wii?



But we must first concentrate ourselves on the way to entertain people, for video games to live. Else, it's a world where sales representative will win, which has as effect to kill creativity. I want to say to the creators all around the world:"Courage, Dare!". Shigeru Miyamoto.

KylieDog said:
Gnac said:

This is a shit excuse for piracy, since no-one is forcing you to carry the cases around.


Oh please, carrying games around unprotected in a pocket where easily broke is not an option. 

Then grab one of these...if you're going to pirate, don't use an excuse like that.

This mode of action seems fine to me. Pirates then just shouldn't download the update at the time of release...just wait until a modified one is released.



HappySqurriel said:

As always, I agree with the free software foundation in principle but not in practice ...


but its impossible to hate them because they purchase patents and copyrights to many pieces of software and release all the source code making it freeware. Without them the world of software would be a very dismal failure.



PC gaming is better than console gaming. Always.     We are Anonymous, We are Legion    Kick-ass interview   Great Flash Series Here    Anime Ratings     Make and Play Please
Amazing discussion about being wrong
Official VGChartz Folding@Home Team #109453