WII

Super Mario Galaxy Nintendo, 2007

97.46%

WII

Super Mario Galaxy 2 Nintendo, 2010

97.12%

PS3

Grand Theft Auto IV Rockstar North/Rockstar Games, 2008

97.01%

PS3

Uncharted 2: Among Thieves Naughty Dog/SCEA, 2009

96.41%

X360

The Orange Box Valve Software/EA Games, 2007

96.19%

X360

Grand Theft Auto IV Rockstar North/Rockstar Games, 2008

96.17%

X360

Mass Effect 2 BioWare/Electronic Arts, 2010

95.66%

X360

Portal 2 Valve Software, 2011

95.00%

X360

BioShock Irrational Games/2K Games, 2007

94.95%

PS3

Red Dead Redemption Rockstar San Diego/Rockstar Games, 2010

94.76%

PS3

LittleBigPlanet Media Molecule/SCEA, 2008

94.67%

X360

Red Dead Redemption Rockstar San Diego/Rockstar Games, 2010

94.18%

X360

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Infinity Ward/Activision, 2007

94.08%

WII

World of Goo 2D Boy, 2008

94.00%

X360

Gears of War Epic Games/Microsoft Game Studios, 2006

93.89%

X360

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion Bethesda Softworks/2K Games, 2006

93.79%

PS3

BioShock Digital Extremes/2K Games, 2008

93.57%

PS3

Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots Kojima Productions/Konami, 2008

93.56%

PS3

Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare Infinity Ward/Activision, 2007

93.54%

X360

Halo 3 Bungie Software/Microsoft Game Studios, 2007

93.53%

X360

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Infinity Ward/Activision, 2009

93.39%

PS3

Street Fighter IV Capcom, 2009

93.36%

PS3

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Infinity Ward/Activision, 2009

93.35%

X360

Gears of War 2 Epic Games/Microsoft Game Studios, 2008

93.32%

X360

Street Fighter IV Capcom, 2009

93.17%

PS3

Mass Effect 2 BioWare/Electronic Arts, 2011

93.17%

WII

Super Smash Bros. Brawl Game Arts/Nintendo, 2008

92.75%

PS3

LittleBigPlanet 2 Media Molecule/SCEA, 2011

92.38%

WII

Metroid Prime Trilogy Retro Studios/Nintendo, 2009

92.27%

X360

Forza Motorsport 3 Turn 10/Microsoft Game Studios, 2009

92.13%

PS3

Batman: Arkham Asylum Rocksteady Studios/Square Enix, 2009

92.81%

X360

Batman: Arkham Asylum Rocksteady Studios/Eidos Interactive, 2009

92.07%

X360

Braid Number None Inc., 2008

92.06%

PS3

God of War III SCE Santa Monica/SCEA, 2010

92.04%

Note all game scores from game rankings

PS3 games = 14

360 games = 14

Wii games = 5

Games that sold over 3 million (sku) = 19/34

Games that sold over 5 milliom (sku) = 11/34

Games that sold over 10 million (sku) = 3/34

So do you think scores have an infulence on game sales?

In the top 10, I noticed wii controls the the very top followed by sony, but microsoft controls 5/10. 

And RDR, being a little worse game in PS3, has a higher meta and it's at the 10th pos.

Did Portal 2 (PS3) really not make the list?  Or does it just not have enough reviews yet?

Not enough reviews. 

If it weren't for VGC's review of GTAIV it would be first lol

I remember it going down when VGC joined Gamerankings.

damn I loved GTA 4. It got a 98 without VGC and some other sites.

Uncharted 2 and Mass Effect are separated nearly 1 point (.75).

but they have the same score on meta, i wonder if it would separated like that on meta, but since it doesnt do decimals, the rounding makes them tied?

uncharted does have a ton more perfects scores, and the lowest ME2 scores are lower than UC2's lowest (on meta)

On Metacritic, reviews from big and important publications are awarded a bigger weight in the aggregated score. I don't think Gamerankings work that way.

Exclusive titles on the list:

PS3 - 5

Wii - 4

X360 - 2

I don't think high scores sell games. Good games sell themselves, and also happen to get high scores.