By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Do you think Sony regrets going after George Hotz now?

Kynes said:
fps_d0minat0r said:
Kynes said:
fps_d0minat0r said:
Kynes said:
fps_d0minat0r said:
...

removing features from a product (which are not core to its primary function) is not illegal.

attacking servers, pirating and hacking PSN is illegal.

thats why geo hot is in court and FBI are after anonymous and not sony.

anyways, PROTIP: dont study law because you dont even understand basic morals.

In Europe it is. If you advertise it, then you can't remove it, or you have to compensate your users.

 

Even they used it to import it as a computer, not a videogames system, so they pay less duties.

 

i remember they were taken to court but didnt hear anything after...

you know what happened?

http://games.slashdot.org/story/11/04/23/031220/Sony-Should-Pay-For-OtherOS-Removal-Says-Finnish-Board


exactly....so they paid the consequences.

and now, so must geo hot and anonymous.


You just said that it isn't illegal, but it doesn't seem to be that way. Sony hasn't paid anything, yet, but if this jurisprudence extends, it could cost them some money.


not really, people have to have proof of purchase otherwise anyone could just buy a pre-owned ps3 and claim 100 euros and that would be an easy way to get a cheap ps3 at the expense of sony.

im guessing hardly anyone who really cares about other OS will still have their reciepts. most people wont even go for a refund because they dont care and never even used other OS.



Around the Network

I had heard somewheres that old systems were being used as 'dev-kits' and they were able to track that which led them to shut the servers down.

Now obviously don't quote me entirely on this claim, it was simply something I had either seen on google or the forums across various sites. Obviously if these hacked consoles are being traced as 'dev-kits' it's pretty much what you guys mentioned above. Being able to download free content etc. But at the same time - if the console was being read as a dev kit..would they have been able to release custom patches for various games like Socom 4 and Mortal Kombat?

It's all really a big mystery at this point and time until there's official word from Sony. I'm not freaking out about whether any of my account information was breached or not, I just don't need stress like that right now. I'm sure being patient will pay off in the end, and we'll be getting some of the answers we're looking for very soon.



 Proud owner of the PSone original, PSone slim, PS2 slim, PS3 slim, PSP-3000.

37 PS3 games and counting.

Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:

Winning the case means they can easily win against any future hackers, and because of their markets in developing countries Sony has the most to gain by keeping pirates off their system, I don't think they regret it, they have to take a stand and have better secruity then everyone else in order to keep pirating down on their system, the ps3 is far less pirated and has far less cheaters online then the other 2 consoles and pc


They didn't win though... they settled out of court, and didn't even make him sign an acceptance  of blame.   While yes, they clearly have better security, what with there online being the only online currently up and running....

Wait.  It's the exact opposite.  This lawsuit theoretically has made their security LESS safe because they put a big target on their head that's caused 2 hacking incidents.

Oh please it will be over in a week and Sony will come out with a more secure system and everyone knows it, if anything they are flushing the people out 



imaprettyhotguy said:
Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:

Winning the case means they can easily win against any future hackers, and because of their markets in developing countries Sony has the most to gain by keeping pirates off their system, I don't think they regret it, they have to take a stand and have better secruity then everyone else in order to keep pirating down on their system, the ps3 is far less pirated and has far less cheaters online then the other 2 consoles and pc


They didn't win though... they settled out of court, and didn't even make him sign an acceptance  of blame.   While yes, they clearly have better security, what with there online being the only online currently up and running....

Wait.  It's the exact opposite.  This lawsuit theoretically has made their security LESS safe because they put a big target on their head that's caused 2 hacking incidents.

Oh please it will be over in a week and Sony will come out with a more secure system and everyone knows it, if anything they are flushing the people out 

If it was that easy... I'd think the PSP would be more secure.  Wouldn't you?

Or every other system would do the same.   What makes you think Sony is god's gift to security programming?



Kasz216 said:

Or every other system would do the same.   What makes you think Sony is god's gift to security programming?

At this point, I think it's pretty safe to say they are NOT god's gift to security programming.

/justwantstoplayportal




Or check out my new webcomic: http://selfcentent.com/

Around the Network

I don't even think Hotz is on their mind anymore. They are too busy cleaning their pants.



Anyone can guess. It takes no effort to throw out lots of predictions and have some of them be correct. You are not and wiser or better for having your guesses be right. Even a blind man can hit the bullseye.

Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:
Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:

Winning the case means they can easily win against any future hackers, and because of their markets in developing countries Sony has the most to gain by keeping pirates off their system, I don't think they regret it, they have to take a stand and have better secruity then everyone else in order to keep pirating down on their system, the ps3 is far less pirated and has far less cheaters online then the other 2 consoles and pc


They didn't win though... they settled out of court, and didn't even make him sign an acceptance  of blame.   While yes, they clearly have better security, what with there online being the only online currently up and running....

Wait.  It's the exact opposite.  This lawsuit theoretically has made their security LESS safe because they put a big target on their head that's caused 2 hacking incidents.

Oh please it will be over in a week and Sony will come out with a more secure system and everyone knows it, if anything they are flushing the people out 

If it was that easy... I'd think the PSP would be more secure.  Wouldn't you?

Or every other system would do the same.   What makes you think Sony is god's gift to security programming?

They kept hackers off the ps3 for a record amount of time, and if I am to understand the psp situation it was hardware not software that was hacked and Sony didn't do any fighting for it so what makes you think they can't?



imaprettyhotguy said:
Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:
Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:

Winning the case means they can easily win against any future hackers, and because of their markets in developing countries Sony has the most to gain by keeping pirates off their system, I don't think they regret it, they have to take a stand and have better secruity then everyone else in order to keep pirating down on their system, the ps3 is far less pirated and has far less cheaters online then the other 2 consoles and pc


They didn't win though... they settled out of court, and didn't even make him sign an acceptance  of blame.   While yes, they clearly have better security, what with there online being the only online currently up and running....

Wait.  It's the exact opposite.  This lawsuit theoretically has made their security LESS safe because they put a big target on their head that's caused 2 hacking incidents.

Oh please it will be over in a week and Sony will come out with a more secure system and everyone knows it, if anything they are flushing the people out 

If it was that easy... I'd think the PSP would be more secure.  Wouldn't you?

Or every other system would do the same.   What makes you think Sony is god's gift to security programming?

They kept hackers off the ps3 for a record amount of time, and if I am to understand the psp situation it was hardware not software that was hacked and Sony didn't do any fighting for it so what makes you think they can't?

They kept hacekrs off ps3 for a record amount of time for the same reason Apple did with the Mac.  It's the best DRM there is.  It's called low marketshare.

Once the PS3 got more successful, hackers started paying attention and it was hacked.

What makes me think Sony can't?  Well that would be because they lost their master signing key... which turns out to not be random... even though it's suppsoed to be.

That's what was hacked. 

A master signing key is basically, the key that comes with the console at launch that tells sony made products from non sony products.  The products that are official get there own "key".

Normal hacks, cause the system to not do it's "authentication check."  It's easy to upgrade your firmware and change how the system does it's authentication heck.

This hack, causes the system to not know what is a sony game and what isn't... and you can't change the master key because if you did... every product BEFORE you changed the key would stop working on the PS3. 


Master Keys are pretty much NEVER hacked, because it's near impossible to do because the number is random with each product, meaning you'd need a LARGE LARGE LARGE sample of keys from different products and probably a powerful computer to run the numbers.  It'd be a lot of effort for no game.

Sony, didn't use a random number with each product.

So it took 3 keys... and a pencil and paper.  This is why I think Sony can't do it.



Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:
Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:
Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:

Winning the case means they can easily win against any future hackers, and because of their markets in developing countries Sony has the most to gain by keeping pirates off their system, I don't think they regret it, they have to take a stand and have better secruity then everyone else in order to keep pirating down on their system, the ps3 is far less pirated and has far less cheaters online then the other 2 consoles and pc


They didn't win though... they settled out of court, and didn't even make him sign an acceptance  of blame.   While yes, they clearly have better security, what with there online being the only online currently up and running....

Wait.  It's the exact opposite.  This lawsuit theoretically has made their security LESS safe because they put a big target on their head that's caused 2 hacking incidents.

Oh please it will be over in a week and Sony will come out with a more secure system and everyone knows it, if anything they are flushing the people out 

If it was that easy... I'd think the PSP would be more secure.  Wouldn't you?

Or every other system would do the same.   What makes you think Sony is god's gift to security programming?

They kept hackers off the ps3 for a record amount of time, and if I am to understand the psp situation it was hardware not software that was hacked and Sony didn't do any fighting for it so what makes you think they can't?

They kept hacekrs off ps3 for a record amount of time for the same reason Apple did with the Mac.  It's the best DRM there is.  It's called low marketshare.

Once the PS3 got more successful, hackers started paying attention and it was hacked.

What makes me think Sony can't?  Well that would be because they lost their master signing key... which turns out to not be random... even though it's suppsoed to be.

That's what was hacked. 

A master signing key is basically, the key that comes with the console at launch that tells sony made products from non sony products.  The products that are official get there own "key".

Normal hacks, cause the system to not do it's "authentication check."  It's easy to upgrade your firmware and change how the system does it's authentication heck.

This hack, causes the system to not know what is a sony game and what isn't... and you can't change the master key because if you did... every product BEFORE you changed the key would stop working on the PS3. 


Master Keys are pretty much NEVER hacked, because it's near impossible to do because the number is random with each product, meaning you'd need a LARGE LARGE LARGE sample of keys from different products and probably a powerful computer to run the numbers.  It'd be a lot of effort for no game.

Sony, didn't use a random number with each product.

So it took 3 keys... and a pencil and paper.  This is why I think Sony can't do it.

and yet still no hackers on psn and no pirates, the updates stopped them and the low market share is just pure bs, ps3 sold more in its first year then 360 did and 360 was hacked in its first year 



imaprettyhotguy said:
Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:
Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:
Kasz216 said:
imaprettyhotguy said:

Winning the case means they can easily win against any future hackers, and because of their markets in developing countries Sony has the most to gain by keeping pirates off their system, I don't think they regret it, they have to take a stand and have better secruity then everyone else in order to keep pirating down on their system, the ps3 is far less pirated and has far less cheaters online then the other 2 consoles and pc


They didn't win though... they settled out of court, and didn't even make him sign an acceptance  of blame.   While yes, they clearly have better security, what with there online being the only online currently up and running....

Wait.  It's the exact opposite.  This lawsuit theoretically has made their security LESS safe because they put a big target on their head that's caused 2 hacking incidents.

Oh please it will be over in a week and Sony will come out with a more secure system and everyone knows it, if anything they are flushing the people out 

If it was that easy... I'd think the PSP would be more secure.  Wouldn't you?

Or every other system would do the same.   What makes you think Sony is god's gift to security programming?

They kept hackers off the ps3 for a record amount of time, and if I am to understand the psp situation it was hardware not software that was hacked and Sony didn't do any fighting for it so what makes you think they can't?

They kept hacekrs off ps3 for a record amount of time for the same reason Apple did with the Mac.  It's the best DRM there is.  It's called low marketshare.

Once the PS3 got more successful, hackers started paying attention and it was hacked.

What makes me think Sony can't?  Well that would be because they lost their master signing key... which turns out to not be random... even though it's suppsoed to be.

That's what was hacked. 

A master signing key is basically, the key that comes with the console at launch that tells sony made products from non sony products.  The products that are official get there own "key".

Normal hacks, cause the system to not do it's "authentication check."  It's easy to upgrade your firmware and change how the system does it's authentication heck.

This hack, causes the system to not know what is a sony game and what isn't... and you can't change the master key because if you did... every product BEFORE you changed the key would stop working on the PS3. 


Master Keys are pretty much NEVER hacked, because it's near impossible to do because the number is random with each product, meaning you'd need a LARGE LARGE LARGE sample of keys from different products and probably a powerful computer to run the numbers.  It'd be a lot of effort for no game.

Sony, didn't use a random number with each product.

So it took 3 keys... and a pencil and paper.  This is why I think Sony can't do it.

and yet still no hackers on psn and no pirates, the updates stopped them and the low market share is just pure bs, ps3 sold more in its first year then 360 did and 360 was hacked in its first year

Er.  360 had 100% Market share it's first year.

No hackers and pirates on PSN, well considering there are no legitamite people on PSN either, i'm not surprised.

As for that though i'll direct people to you  you everytime i get someone bitching about why they think Hotz was wrong because of all the hackers and pirates they claim plague online... and that online is worse then PC and 360.

So you can decide between you which of you is making stuff up to support your point.  I mean, if there are no hackers or pirates anymore, sony must REALLY regret going after GeoHotz.

Since they're entire PSN network got taken down by hackers twice, they lost customer information and they spent MILLIONS of dollars prosecuting him.

When what he did was already all cleaned up and made better.  Sounds like sueing your neighbor because he spilled some soda on your table and you needed to wipe it up with a rag.

I mean... Sony's lackluster security is responsible for what analyists think might be the BIGGEST breach in the history of such breaches.

http://ingame.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2011/04/26/6539290-why-the-playstation-network-breach-is-scary

You still really want to tout their security credentials as being far superior to Microsoft and Nintendos?