There were some nice (and strange) surprises in that list (Duck Tales FTW!!!).

But, the lack of Age of Empires or Total War is not cool. At all.

And the worst part: no Metroid Prime! That's just ridiculous!

I obviously don't agree with everything but I think it's a pretty fair list.

Super Mario Galaxy better than Super Mario 64 is odd.

Wind Waker above Link to the Past? No!

Some key games are missing. Seems like they totally forgot the N64.

i dont think Galaxy being above mario 64 is odd at all. IMHO Mario 64 hasnt aged that well, its not unplayable like Sonic Adv. but if i had to put them side by side Galaxy is just the better game. 64 gets a little boring having to got to the same levels 5 or 6 times to get stars. i think Galaxy is what Mario 64 should have been.

but yeah Wind Waker above LttP is weird as hell

Portal? Really...? love the game but..no its not the best game ever.

List was ok until until GTA4 and portal.

LOL Tetris number 2 and Portal number 1? I'll just stop right derrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr

Portal no.1? really? I mean really? It's a good game but best of all times, no flipping way.

Well, I somewhat respect them for having the balls to not include OoT, but IMO that is the most shit list I've ever seen

@rolstoppable stop putting words in my mouth, i said Galaxy and thats what i meant. Galaxy>>>64 i couldnt make that clearer

Pretty much. And, no Metroid Prime either???

The hell is wrong with them?

Oh God no...

It's a good game, but NOT Top 5, heck, Top 10 quality. Too short really for my liking, hopefully the sequel will change this