just looked through the top 20 for now and the list seems fine. There are a good 30 games that could go on my top 10 list of all time depending on when you ask me and from the ones they listed all but grand theft auto 4 and shadow of colossus would never made it. While portal wasn't the fullest game, it defenitly was a gem among this generation. I'll give an example as to why its understandable that its above some more critically acclaimed games this gen. Uncharted 2 and mass effect 2 might be more complete experiences but with the huge number of quality tps games released this gen, I would rather uncharted and mass effect not exist than Portal.

Grand Theft Auto 4 gets a lot of undeserved hate, but it really shouldn't be considered a top 10 game. The transition from grand theft auto san andreas to grand theft auto 4 is exactly what you don't want to happen with improved hardware. Drastically improve graphics at the expence of content...

IMO shadow of colossus is a pretty overrated game from my limited experience with it. Story and atmosphere can't make a game. It needs to be fun to play as well.

I don't agree with half of the 20-11 but i could see why other people would vote them at their positions.

I don't see how Wind Waker deserves number 5 only because of it's art style... not to mention Majora's Mask and OoT weren't even on the list.

The lack of Ocarina of TIme is really confusing, I mean how can it not be in the top 100?
GTA IV should also be below San An and Red Dead

Overall it's pretty good though save for lack of Timesplitters

this is the most unique list ive seen in my life, there are some games id never thought id seen, TR Anniversary??? Duck Tales??? its all good, but whats not good is no Ocarina of Time, weird. Never really cared for MH, I thought it was a stripped down MMO so it doesnt bother me that its not on the list

Way to many new games towards the top of the list which shouldn't be near there...

TIL Tetris Attack is a better game than Ocarina of Time.

The list gets worse as it goes on, practically the whole top ten is way overrated.

^^^even Mario 3??? that was the best 2d Mario in the series IMHO

I said practically

^^oh ok, i was wondering. ill give you GTA4 and Portal