Oh, I was off

wasn't the rule 30% of the number of players rounded down, so it should be 4...I think?

20%

Or one in five 

Hmmm, the general consensus among the other players seems to be 3 or 4 mafia members...it seems as if this could be an attempt to throw members off into thinking no way you would say such a high number if you were indeed mafia.

FoS: MetalGear_94

Not to sound like I'm defending the guy but he thought it was a 30% rule. So that would put the mark right at 5 mafia members. That's also in between the two lynch rule and the 20% rule

I realized that after I posted, but I'll be keeping my eye on him.

I'd like to bring into question the signature with the "Happle" who is sad and wearing a mask. Could this be a clue...lol?

Yeah, it seems I got the rule wrong.

1. In some situations it's a good idea for numbers altough I've yet to see scum hit in a day one lynch. With the even number I'm more likely to be agaist it.

2. Yes but there aren't many circumstances like that.

3. Lurkers are often scum and if not then it's just a very unhelpfully townie.

1. What is your opinion on a day 1 lynch?

2. Do you think it's ok under any circumstances for a townie to lie?

3. What's your opinion on lurkers?

1. I don't think it's too bad of an idea, but if the mafia approximations are accurate then there are high odds of hitting an innocent.

2. There are rare circumstances when it's OK I suppose, when the role allows.

3. They slow the game down. Alot.

I thought here it was more a 25% rule. 1 scum for every 3 townies. So 4 even this game.  However there is always the possibility of other tweaking that could change those numbers.