Well, now that a lot of information has been shared, I do think we need to come to some sort of conclusion or vote here soon.

Vote for time limit

I don't feel convinced on trucks by prof. There are some interesting points there but some I disagree with or at least question.

Several seem to be on trucks suspicion on metal gear. Yet prof is very sure metal gear is scum.

the ones about the days ending don't seem that strong and actually. I depreciate him holding off hammering the second day. Considering one game I would have said something but the day ended and I was then nightkilled.

are you also ready to vote for someone?

I do, but I'm still deciding on who. Due to that, I'm certainly not going to start a campaign for either.

Votals
With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

[3,L-2] A Bad Clown: (Hephaestos), Hephaestos, (Wonktonodi), (Baalzamon), TruckOSaurus, Wonktonodi
[0] theprof00: (Wonktonodi)
[1,L-4] MetalGear_94: Vetteman94, (theprof00)
[1,L-4] TruckOSaurus: theprof00

Deadline rules are in the second post. Exact deadline will be decided after I get some sleep, but will be a minimum of 72 hours from outlaw's vote for a time limit.

I love quoting myself, like that I participate in 10 post discutions that say exactly what I posted before...

Damnit, spent 30 mins looking for a post that didn't exist  (and these longposts make my browser skip, it's enoying (old work comp)

so I thought I read in prof's longposts that MG said his character was evil, which didn't fit with Uther... of course he never said that but I derived a second theory for the siblings....

Malfurion Stormrage (trucks) is Illidan's brother... Illidan is of course a very evil character that very well could be the SK. He's also a WC3 player favorite as he is the demon hunter class, and much of the frozen throne story follows him.

But look at this for balance:

1 mafia/ 1 SK siblings, both think the other is town.... even more so, with truck's focus on MG as prof pointed out, He could have had the condition, "you brother can only die by the town, if you kill him yourself you will not forgive yourself and commit suicide"

Such a setting would allow for a 5 player mafia (i'm leaning trucks ABC) and 1 SK (MG) with the balance being the elite bodyguard and the insurance that the SK isn't killed by the mafia, while giving a strong motivation to the town for lynching him.

This said, it all comes from a missread post... so... but I quite like the idea and it would explain the animal blade (ilidan sending a message to his brother?), and would definitely explain the violence of the crimes.

On thing in the flavor that doesn't fit is that we all have costumes... we should be able to SEE who lies on theirs :p

(the Athras killing to become the SK is interesting too, but the animal is clearly defined as painted... that's where it blocks.

lastly as to radish's sibling quote, Mafia were probably allowed to say only "Hi, i'm malfurion stormrage, Sibling".... thus prompting Radish to recognize ABC for a sibling when he "had something" on a fellow mafia (who radish confused for the sibling).

I'm willing to try this out, as Malfurion is the only sibling I see (onyxia and nefarius are siblings... but not in this game)

Unvote

Vote : Trucks

(not if trucks is the mafia sibling... ABC is kinda cleared of mafia by radish...)

Oh and Tyrand would be malfurion's lover, not sibling. ^^

oh and to support the illidan theory... MG nameclaimed in the last 2... the other was trucks.... knowing the other's name, it's easy for one of them to just choose a random name (Uther) without fear of taking a claimed name and the other to keep his name.

that's easy... Hat loves me