Wonktonodi said:
Working on my posts. I hope to not flood the wall with them and will do my best to keep things clear concise and free of stupid errors.
I believe I covered part of this in my "one post in over a 24 hour period" http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3919700 However I'll go at the points in order and with more detail.
1. I was satisfied with the answer over his prof statement because. It gave an explanation for that. Feeling satisfied with that I didn't look at much into the details of his answer because, they are so hard to follow some times. I have asked a few questions one was just to clarify a post he had made before going robot. I probably could have done more but won't deny I've not felt as motivated to. So currently I'm not looking at his older posts (any before the post in the link) with the possible exception of iterations with theprof. Although more on thepofs end than his since I did commit to doing this and haven't yet.
2. I'm not sure how those numbers would work. With a no lynch there would be more more possible person for the doc to protect (if there is one) so unless it was scum hit the first day in the random lynch the doc's odds of picking the same as the scum would improve. However I will avoid any more math discussions till after the game.
3. Correct that was a typo. I did find hephs vote for the time limit more suspicious than trash's. However that doesn't mean hers isn't just that I don't view them quite the same way.
4. I don't see the point of most of this. Yes I get that you find me suspicious and you have brought up reasons. However going to say you would HOS instead of a finger (you have latter changed this when you voted Heph although I wonder if you got a third hand in the unvote) My biggest problem with this though is you bring up that I did something very scummy but refuse to actually present the evidence. If you aren't going to bring up the evidence I don't think you should mention the suspicion either. It just seems like you want someone else to come up with something that I did.
Note I find this different from what I've done because I mention the evidence then ask for thoughts or opinions.
|
I was falling asleep thinking I'd be voting for you today, but when I woke up my mind was thinking I should revote Heph. Unfortunately, if I figured something out in a dream, then I didn't keep the logic. I won't be voting just due to a feeling, but I will look at Heph once again in addition to reexamining you.
1) Noted. I still feel like it was artificial though. I just don't think a townie investigating someone suspicious would get an answer which offers new information and not inquire about it or at least check to see that it's valid.
2) My math was slightly off and I haven't considered cases with additional no lynches. If the scumteam is comprised of 3 members, then overall the odds are still in favor of a no lynch. However, just considering the worst case scenario the random lynch is better for town and better still since I consider the odds to be 3/10 instead of 3/11. If it's only 2 members, then odds are much more in favor of a doc save then a random lynch. On the other hand, if there's only 2 of them then I doubt there would be a doctor anyway. I only bring this all up because I really enjoy math, but it's moot because I believe several players(yourself included) are suspicious enough to warrant a non-random lynch.
4) You refer to the post in which I unvoted Heph(No I don't have three hands, I suppose he get's a Smelly Foot of Suspicion, lol) and also HoSed you, but you missed "This will also explain why I was going to give Wonk an HoS"? I didn't want to bring up the evidence because I was worried you were drawing attention to something that scum might've missed. I wasn't looking for someone else to come up with something. And if they had thought I meant something else then it would've been exactly what I was hoping for, but only because they hadn't noticed it.
Your note is really giving me the impression that instead of forming your own opinions you want to point things out, see what people come up with, and then push them towards your goal. First with radish and now with Heph.