By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
radishhead said:
noname2200 said:
radishhead said:

 

Hey, where's my answer?

Huh? I'll try and find the question - just a sec


Here you are.

noname2200 said:
radishhead said:

ABC, me, you, trash, noname.. we've all been talking about the strange outcome of last night.

...we have?

radishhead said:
trashleg said:
A Bad Clown said:

Question: Did anyone else belive theRepublic was doctor?

I know it was a conversation between me and him, perhaps someone else was watching it also

wait.

so you believed therepublic was the doctor..and he was the first night kill? hmm. and you admit it may have just been you who thought so? what does that tell us?

I was going to mention this - it's a pretty large mistake to make.

When were you planning to mention it?  Were the over ten minutes you had enough to post something else, but not to point this out?





Around the Network
radishhead said:

What's the big deal? :(

I made sure that you realised that I did notice the mention of the scalpel in the flavour text, but I just didn't realise that it was actually going to actually mean anything. I suppose that makes me a "Did notice, didn't know" - but I did notice, 100%.

I'll check that and fix it



radishhead said:
trashleg said:
A Bad Clown said:

Question: Did anyone else belive theRepublic was doctor?

I know it was a conversation between me and him, perhaps someone else was watching it also

wait.

so you believed therepublic was the doctor..and he was the first night kill? hmm. and you admit it may have just been you who thought so? what does that tell us?

I was going to mention this - it's a pretty large mistake to make.

When were you planning to mention it?  Were the over ten minutes you had enough to post something else, but not to point this out?

Was this the question?

If so, I was going to mention it at the time that you posted the message, but I got ninja'd by you - so I just posted that message as a "seconded" opinion. I was already posting another post at the time (I think?) - don't forget that the game was moving really quickly at that point.



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~

Oh yeah - the other question:

I just picked out a few names of the people that were talking about Wonk's death - you weren't talking about how the outcome was strange, but it was being mentioned. This point is outdated now anyway, since at the time I felt that it was a waste of time to talk about Wonk's death, but now Prof seems to have made it his current mission to talk about nothing but this bit of flavour text.



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~

^ lolz(@change in the list)

I said I'd dig up old posts of people mentioning doctor if I had the time, so I've been noting such while I reread everything.

prof was first to mention thinking there's a doc. Then, I brought up the possibility of a doctor making a save. Heph was next. Wonk himself said a doc could exist.

So not to discredit the idea that Republic was chosen because the scumteam thought he was the doctor, but others stand out once again. I can't imagine ABC would come up with the idea that 2 or 3 others thought the same as he did and killed based on that thinking, so I very much believe it to be a confession of the actual rationale. I only wonder then who the others could be that would miss these other "hints"(though I read them all as speculation) and the night flavor, and furthermore didn't have the logic that the scumteam should've had, as I pointed out earlier.

I'm ready to vote, but even though prof was rash yesterday, I won't be a dick as some kind of revenge. There's still discussion to be had and I finally need to catch some shut eye. It's extremely unlikely that I'll be changing my mind this time around, so I will be voting when I wake up.



Around the Network
radishhead said:

Was this the question?

If so, I was going to mention it at the time that you posted the message, but I got ninja'd by you - so I just posted that message as a "seconded" opinion. I was already posting another post at the time (I think?) - don't forget that the game was moving really quickly at that point.

How did I ninja you exactly, when I don't think I was even online during that timespan?  Aditionally, the timeline doesn't work.  At all.

A Bad Clown on 02/22/11 12:56 PST

Question: Did anyone else belive theRepublic was doctor?

I know it was a conversation between me and him, perhaps someone else was watching it also.

_____________________________________________________________________________________

radishhead on 02/22/11 12:58 PST

Why are we talking about people that could have been the doctor, anyway? We know who the doctor is; he's dead. It's very annoying, but we seem to be spending quite some time talking about people who we thought could have been the doctor.

______________________________________________________________________________________

trashleg on 02/22/11 13:08 PST

A Bad Clown said:

Question: Did anyone else belive theRepublic was doctor?

I know it was a conversation between me and him, perhaps someone else was watching it also.

 
wait.

so you believed therepublic was the doctor..and he was the first night kill? hmm. and you admit it may have just been you who thought so? what does that tell us?

_____________________________________________________________________________________

radishhead on 02/22/11 13:08 PST

theprof00 said:
radishhead said:

Why are we talking about people that could have been the doctor, anyway? We know who the doctor is; he's dead. It's very annoying, but we seem to be spending quite some time talking about people who we thought could have been the doctor.

we are? You mean abc's single post about it?

ABC, me, you, trash, noname.. we've all been talking about the strange outcome of last night.
_____________________________________________________________________________________

radishhead on 02/22/11 13:08 PST

trashleg said:
A Bad Clown said:

Question: Did anyone else belive theRepublic was doctor?

I know it was a conversation between me and him, perhaps someone else was watching it also.

 


wait.

so you believed therepublic was the doctor..and he was the first night kill? hmm. and you admit it may have just been you who thought so? what does that tell us?

I was going to mention this - it's a pretty large mistake to make.
______________________________________________________________________________________
You had twelve minutes to bring it up, and made two additional posts in that time, but you didn't mention it until immediately  after trashleg did.


radishhead said:
theprof00 said:

ok, I would just like a recap of people who noticed and did not notice the "scalpel" in the lynch flavor at the beginning of night one.

Everyone please answer this rephrased question: "Did you know wonk was the doc during night 1". 

Linkzmax: Did notice, was not sure

Radish: Didn't notice; didn't know
ABC: Didn't notice; didn't know
Heph: Didn't notice; didn't know

FF: Did notice; Did know

has anyone else answered?

What's the big deal? :(

I made sure that you realised that I did notice the mention of the scalpel in the flavour text, but I just didn't realise that it was actually going to actually mean anything. I suppose that makes me a "Did notice, didn't know" - but I did notice, 100%.

"I did notice the flavour, and I read it a few times, because I liked the way that it was relevant to the events of day 1. I didn't realise that it was going to have a clue like that hidden within, you see."



noname2200 said:
radishhead said:

Was this the question?

If so, I was going to mention it at the time that you posted the message, but I got ninja'd by you - so I just posted that message as a "seconded" opinion. I was already posting another post at the time (I think?) - don't forget that the game was moving really quickly at that point.

How did I ninja you exactly, when I don't think I was even online during that timespan?  Aditionally, the timeline doesn't work.  At all.

A Bad Clown on 02/22/11 12:56 PST

Question: Did anyone else belive theRepublic was doctor?

I know it was a conversation between me and him, perhaps someone else was watching it also.

_____________________________________________________________________________________

radishhead on 02/22/11 12:58 PST

Why are we talking about people that could have been the doctor, anyway? We know who the doctor is; he's dead. It's very annoying, but we seem to be spending quite some time talking about people who we thought could have been the doctor.

______________________________________________________________________________________

trashleg on 02/22/11 13:08 PST

A Bad Clown said:

Question: Did anyone else belive theRepublic was doctor?

I know it was a conversation between me and him, perhaps someone else was watching it also.

 
wait.

so you believed therepublic was the doctor..and he was the first night kill? hmm. and you admit it may have just been you who thought so? what does that tell us?

_____________________________________________________________________________________

radishhead on 02/22/11 13:08 PST

theprof00 said:
radishhead said:

Why are we talking about people that could have been the doctor, anyway? We know who the doctor is; he's dead. It's very annoying, but we seem to be spending quite some time talking about people who we thought could have been the doctor.

we are? You mean abc's single post about it?

ABC, me, you, trash, noname.. we've all been talking about the strange outcome of last night.
_____________________________________________________________________________________

radishhead on 02/22/11 13:08 PST

trashleg said:
A Bad Clown said:

Question: Did anyone else belive theRepublic was doctor?

I know it was a conversation between me and him, perhaps someone else was watching it also.

 


wait.

so you believed therepublic was the doctor..and he was the first night kill? hmm. and you admit it may have just been you who thought so? what does that tell us?

I was going to mention this - it's a pretty large mistake to make.
______________________________________________________________________________________
You had twelve minutes to bring it up, and made two additional posts in that time, but you didn't mention it until immediately  after trashleg did.

I guess I did - the point is, I was going to make the point, so I just settled with confirming that it was a valid statement.



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~

theprof00 said:
radishhead said:
theprof00 said:

ok, I would just like a recap of people who noticed and did not notice the "scalpel" in the lynch flavor at the beginning of night one.

Everyone please answer this rephrased question: "Did you know wonk was the doc during night 1". 

Linkzmax: Did notice, was not sure

Radish: Didn't notice; didn't know
ABC: Didn't notice; didn't know
Heph: Didn't notice; didn't know

FF: Did notice; Did know

has anyone else answered?

What's the big deal? :(

I made sure that you realised that I did notice the mention of the scalpel in the flavour text, but I just didn't realise that it was actually going to actually mean anything. I suppose that makes me a "Did notice, didn't know" - but I did notice, 100%.

"I did notice the flavour, and I read it a few times, because I liked the way that it was relevant to the events of day 1. I didn't realise that it was going to have a clue like that hidden within, you see."

That's the one!

Having read the flavour multiple times, I obviously noticed the part about the scalpel, but I didn't think anything of it. I know that this makes no difference to your idea (because that would still give me the reason to attack rep if I thought that he could be doctor), but I don't want to be grouped with the people who didn't notice it at all.



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~

I contacted Stefl1504 because of his absence. He was online 23 hours ago, but he hasn't posted for a much longer time, so I started looking for replacements.

I do hope that he will be coming back, though. I've tried to contact Vetteman94, hatmoza, and makingmusic476, but Vetteman94 has no time, hatmoza wasn't online since 20th January and I got no response from makingmusic yet.

Any other ideas?



updated: 14.01.2012

playing right now: Xenoblade Chronicles

Hype-o-meter, from least to most hyped:  the Last Story, Twisted Metal, Mass Effect 3, Final Fantasy XIII-2, Final Fantasy Versus XIII, Playstation ViTA

bet with Mordred11 that Rage will look better on Xbox 360.