By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
noname2200 on 23 February 2011
theprof00 said:

how did referencing the heart have anything to do with your understanding?

So let me get this straight; You noticed the scalpel, as in you read it, or as in you specifically noticed it as a potential clue but other information gave you second thoughts?

Logically, the easiest way to access a heart is a scalpel: the tool is meant for opening up the body, after all.  Haven't you played any Trauma Center games?  Or seen any alien autopsy movies, for that matter?  The latter's a common cliche...

In other words, I read it, but didn't jump to any conclusions based on it.



Around the Network
theprof00 on 23 February 2011
noname2200 said:
theprof00 said:

how did referencing the heart have anything to do with your understanding?

So let me get this straight; You noticed the scalpel, as in you read it, or as in you specifically noticed it as a potential clue but other information gave you second thoughts?

Logically, the easiest way to access a heart is a scalpel: the tool is meant for opening up the body, after all.  Haven't you played any Trauma Center games?  Or seen any alien autopsy movies, for that matter?  The latter's a common cliche...

In other words, I read it, but didn't jump to any conclusions based on it.

Ah ok, so you didn't notice it then.

I'm talking about IF you specifically noticed it, or if you just thought it was just flavor. I would say you did not notice it based on your, erm, "testimony"



noname2200 on 23 February 2011
theprof00 said:

Ah ok, so you didn't notice it then.

I'm talking about IF you specifically noticed it, or if you just thought it was just flavor. I would say you did not notice it based on your, erm, "testimony"


Ah.  Fair enough.



Linkzmax on 23 February 2011
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:

Well, we have your word that you did notice, and weren't sure. Well you knew, but didn't KNOW know.
Also, trash answered. Did notice, did know.

So you're waiting on Stefl and noname.

let's not give people something to use as a lie. I know I'm town, I noticed, but didn't KNOW know, but I'd rather not give people the option of "didn't know for sure", aside from people who say that on their own accord.

Fair enough. I don't know you're town, but I am more suspicious of those that say they knew for certain than those that say they weren't sure.(Those that didn't notice it at all stand out the most though)

I wonder if you should put me in the same category as noname; because, as I explained in my post, I thought it could also be a clue as to how the aliens get inside of the heart. I did read it as a clue, but not necessarily indicating that Wonk was the doctor. Well that does sound more like "noticed, unsure." Whatever, I'm more interested in what you make of the whole thing then how you feel about me individually.



VGC Mafia Archives

theprof00 on 23 February 2011
Linkzmax said:
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:

Well, we have your word that you did notice, and weren't sure. Well you knew, but didn't KNOW know.
Also, trash answered. Did notice, did know.

So you're waiting on Stefl and noname.

let's not give people something to use as a lie. I know I'm town, I noticed, but didn't KNOW know, but I'd rather not give people the option of "didn't know for sure", aside from people who say that on their own accord.

Fair enough. I don't know you're town, but I am more suspicious of those that say they knew for certain than those that say they weren't sure.(Those that didn't notice it at all stand out the most though)

I wonder if you should put me in the same category as noname; because, as I explained in my post, I thought it could also be a clue as to how the aliens get inside of the heart. I did read it as a clue, but not necessarily indicating that Wonk was the doctor. Well that does sound more like "noticed, unsure." Whatever, I'm more interested in what you make of the whole thing then how you feel about me individually.

now with extra info

 

ABC: Didn't notice; didn't know
Heph: Didn't notice; didn't know
noname: didn't notice; didn't know (tried to move to "did notice; wasn't sure")
Linkzmax: Didn't notice, didn't know (moved from "wasn't sure")
Radish: Didn't notice; didn't know

 

FF: noticed; knew?
Trash: noticed; Knew
Prof: noticed; knew

 



Around the Network
trashleg on 23 February 2011
theprof00 said:
Linkzmax said:

Fair enough. I don't know you're town, but I am more suspicious of those that say they knew for certain than those that say they weren't sure.(Those that didn't notice it at all stand out the most though)

I wonder if you should put me in the same category as noname; because, as I explained in my post, I thought it could also be a clue as to how the aliens get inside of the heart. I did read it as a clue, but not necessarily indicating that Wonk was the doctor. Well that does sound more like "noticed, unsure." Whatever, I'm more interested in what you make of the whole thing then how you feel about me individually.

now with extra info

Radish: Didn't notice; didn't know

ABC: Didn't notice; didn't know
Heph: Didn't notice; didn't know
noname: didn't notice; didn't know (tried to move to "wasn't sure")
Linkzmax: Did notice, didn't know (moved from "wasn't sure")

FF: noticed; knew?
Trash: noticed; Knew
Prof: noticed; knew


i like that even though linkz said he was suspicious of people who claimed to have known, you didnt try to downgrade your own knowledge and try to come off as ignorant. props to you.



Highwaystar101 said: trashleg said that if I didn't pay back the money she leant me, she would come round and break my legs... That's why people call her trashleg, because she trashes the legs of the people she loan sharks money to.
noname2200 on 23 February 2011
theprof00 said:


noname: didn't notice; didn't know (tried to move to "did notice; wasn't sure")

-_-

'kay.  I'm not going to spend any more time on this right now, but next time you ask a question, kindly spend a few seconds thinking about what you're really asking, and how to phrase your question to get your answer, before asking it.



radishhead on 23 February 2011
theprof00 said:

ok, I would just like a recap of people who noticed and did not notice the "scalpel" in the lynch flavor at the beginning of night one.

Everyone please answer this rephrased question: "Did you know wonk was the doc during night 1". 

Linkzmax: Did notice, was not sure

Radish: Didn't notice; didn't know
ABC: Didn't notice; didn't know
Heph: Didn't notice; didn't know

FF: Did notice; Did know

has anyone else answered?

What's the big deal? :(

I made sure that you realised that I did notice the mention of the scalpel in the flavour text, but I just didn't realise that it was actually going to actually mean anything. I suppose that makes me a "Did notice, didn't know" - but I did notice, 100%.



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~

radishhead on 23 February 2011
noname2200 said:
radishhead said:

 

Hey, where's my answer?

Huh? I'll try and find the question - just a sec



Click this button, you know you want to!  [Subscribe]

Watch me on YouTube!

http://www.youtube.com/user/TheRadishBros

~~~~ Mario Kart 8 drove far past my expectations! Never again will I doubt the wheels of a Monster Franchise! :0 ~~~~

theprof00 on 23 February 2011

FF, let me ask you something.

You make it seem like you believed the roleclaim, but you say that you didn't notice the flavor hint? Is that right?

 

same question for Heph; it appears I jumped the gun saying you didn't know based on your incredulity of his claim.

Did you notice the scalpel as a clue, or did you not?