is it the vocabulary that bothers you? she's scottish.

is it the fact that she's pissed at the doc being dead? well you can read this as town blending... I don't know her style enough to say if it is though, I believe FF has more insight on her style though.

Are you suggesting that it's not annoying that the doctor is dead? :s

well, I read through all Heph's posts again and just don't see the suspicion there anymore. I see that a lot of what I was suspicious of was mis-speaks that I kept thinking were slips, and a lot of sarcasm that I thought was anger at being singled out unfairly.

anyway, I am going to try and move away from the "Heph is mafia" idea, despite that during my walk to work this morning I was all, "It's Heph, trash, and stefl, I know it is".

I'm suggesting that she's mafia "gloating" that the doc is dead.

In the last 6 games, around 90% of the people who have complained about a role being dead have turned out to be scum.

Actually, you might have a point - I find it more normal for town to just move on and try to secure a mafia on the next vote.

My short answer is that you're overlooking quite a few things.  Let's dig into them.

Recall that I've already done a pretty large summation post of all three of you (and more).  I'm assuming that people actually read and remember those things, just as I read theirs.  Since I assumed that, I didn't bother to reiterate everything in it again.  In said post, I think I've made it pretty clear there why I thought wonk was suspicious, and that I was more suspicious of him than you.  The post you're quoting is not intended to repeat those suspicions, but instead to point out what a lynch of that player may reveal about others.

The italicized can only be concluded when you ignore several things.  For starters, I believe Final-Fan was only swayed because I asked him to do something he was already contemplating; he'd earlier written that he was on the "ABC is just a confused townie" train, along with prof and linkz, a point which he implicitly reiterated after the post you've quoted.  I don't think FF would have voted for ABC at that point.  You wouldn't have either.  Nor would prof, Linkz, ABC, or wonk.

11-6=5, not 6.  You've essentially shown why ABC wasn't getting lynched that day.  Given that frustrating reality, I went with my second-favorite suspect.  I make no apologies for trying to lynch someone I thought was both scum and lynchable.

Leaving aside the lazy ex-post facto thinking this post uses, what makes you think trashleg would have gone along with it, let alone easily?  I certainly have no way of knowing; how do you?

The italicized is completely incorrect, and the only way you can conclude that is if you ignore the follow-up posts I made in which I challenged ABC's possible soft-claim.  Really heph, I'm surprised at you for concluding that the one person who's vocally up for clarifying what that statement meant has therefore cleared that person!

I'm also completely baffled as to how I've been "mostly distant from the action" when I've been one of the most active players.  Explain.

i would not bandwagon. my vote was, and still is, on ABC. that's unchanged. Just because its day 2 now doesn't mean i'm going to disregard the events of "yesterday".

For why I miscounted, I can only say that my inability to count votes has apparently continued into this game.  But no, I would not have pushed for heph's lynch if my addition was correct, because I found him less suspicious than wonk.  I even found him less suspicious than stefl, although stefl wasn't getting lynched anytime soon.

Now please explain what's so scummy about asking people to vote for someone I think is scum and might get lynched.