For all those people who missed it read this

http://www.wired.com/gamelife/2011/01/mario-all-stars-wii/

Correction: They're considering reprinting it, they haven't confirmed it yet.

they should make at least 1.5 mill for america

Well with openings that large in the US and Japan, they would have to at least consider more copies.

If they have sold Metroid Prime Trilogy at that price, and included some cool extras, I say that would have sold a hell of a lot better as well.

they should, I didnt get it...

I was stupid not to pre-order and get the game.  I wanted a compilation of all the marios anyway.  Hopefully I can get ahold of a reprint.

And to think the lazy compiliation has already outsold so many "better" games.

Just because Nintendo didn't add polish for the sake of it doesn't make these games any less sublime than they already are.

Why they would even need to consider this is beyond me.

Why you think selling more copies of a hit game is something beyond considering is just silly.

It's selling more copies of a hit game. Your comment is basically the same bad logic that made developers neglect the Wii ("we sold a million copies of RE4 on the Wii. We can't have more of that").

Er, perhaps Kenology means "it's silly to even consider this, just do it already" ...