Wonktonodi said:
Maybe you are right about MG lurking more than SAK all his hello commets didn't add much, although SAk hadn't added much himself. MG did go after a lurker that wasn't scum and that did put the attention on just that one lurker.
The scum didn't rush to SAKS aid they did it mostly spread out. It isn't only on HAT and FF either of them could be town with you being scum. You also had voted for both SAK and scottie, but since they have been so very sure that SAK is town. If SAK is scum and I do think he is then Stefls vote for him didn't put attention on him but made him pretty much safe. I don't think Stefl would have let the lynch go the whole way or then again maybe lynching SAK would make him really seem town.
I would be curious as to how much info we would get from most other people lynched. SAK had many votes on him and many votes switch from him most other people wouldn't really reveal as much.
|
I'm not saying SAK was a huge contributor, just that I believe MG was only trying to protect himself as far as the lurking issue goes.
I was only convinced that SAK is town once Stefl flipped scum. Otherwise, he'd been high on my list since the big blunder and on my radar since the sitting ducks/blind sheep. It's a moot point, but I doubt Stefl would've been able to hop off of SAK if the lynchtrain started going that way, or it would've looked very suspicious. Also there's little reason to trust someone as town simply because they started the votes for someone that turns out scum.
Looking at votes alone, nen offers almost exactly the same information as SAK. Neither voted for another player day one, though zexen voted for nen then. Day two, nen had a vote on ST early on, they voted each other and FF and zexen voted for both of them at some point. Oh and I had a vote on SAK, but seeing as I know what I am already, there's nothing gained for me. Day three they voted each other, nen voted for Stefl near the end, and SAK received votes from Stefl and radish. I don't think I have to recap today, right?
Anyway, this isn't day two anymore and I'm not going to vote based on who's flip would offer the most. There's plenty of evidence at this point that my vote will be to lynch the player I think is the scummiest.
Wonktonodi said:
We know for sure two scum voted Scottie. MG first and Stefl 4th. It might not be a scum save however it is more likely that scum would help finish off SAk and not just leave it for the town.
|
We have no idea how many scum voted for nen, though we do know the first two votes were townies. If you think it's so likely that scum would help finish off SAK then why wouldn't they have done the same for nen?
I believe Stefl voted for scottie to tie it up at 4 instead of pushing SAK into a 2-vote lead because he wanted two townies out in front of nen. He could've voted ST also, but look who already voted for him and why: Truck, who voted due to ST's vote on nen(not helpful to keep the attention off nen), nen(also not helpful), and scottie.