Well I can't say I'm shocked. The whole thing felt a lot like prof's gambit last round. This would give me a pro-town read of you like I had of him then, except you have a lot of logical fallacies.
GodOfWar_3ever said:
To put it simply, wonk says the mafia wouldn't come forward claiming to be cop because I could be any ordinary townie lying to get the scum come forward...that was exactly what I was doing...
I don't know about you, but the tone of his post makes it sound like he is mafia, thinking I could be ordinary townie lying, and bluffing to get the scum to come foward.
|
I don't think you understood Wonk's post. He was calling you scum, not a lying townie. He read your bluff exactly and thinks it is something scum might try to look pro-town. I'll break that down into steps. 1) He recognized that your bluff would be suicide for any scum that tried to claim otherwise. I did as well for that matter, and I'm sure many others would agree. 2) It's a sure bet that someone on the scumteam would realize that also and so you have a bluff that only a team of idiots would fall for. 3) Knowing that it would be a bluff that would lead nowhere, you could've put it out there as scum to appear pro-town.
I don't really have an opinion on Wonk one way or the other at the moment. He might be scum, but the post you're referring to is not a slip up in the way you say it is.
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3769786 - Same numbers
1) There were 4 votes on Kantor at the time you switched to him(from FF). Hardly a consensus
2) It's already been said, but there was plenty to go on from day one and you bluffed extremely early on.
3) You should be sorry.
4) Everything else aside, I hope the flooding goes down.
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3769907 - Same numbers again
1) This I agree could be a slip up. I don't want to out Truck, but it's already in print so it could use an explanation.
2) If I had lied it was actually in hopes that you would have dismissed me as lying because you knew I didn't visit prof, In other words I was hoping I could personally confirm your story. If instead you called me on it and then admitted to lying, well that's exactly what I would have been doing in regards to you.
3) I said it before you came back from school, but you caused a major distraction for the 24 hours. Sure we could've done our own thing in that time, but a promise of good info gets a lot of attention. Almost everyone has been focused on if what you said was true, and if so what news would it bring. Yeah we have 48 hours left, the latter half of which is on a pretty big holiday for those of us in the United States.
4) nordlead says it perfectly.
Also, why did you come up with a watcher that can only watch every other day? What was your reasoning behind weakening the role?
I'd be voting for you now, but it seems there's been a few votes on you while I was typing this up. So I'm going to get votals first. I think you should be hung today, but I believe there's a few folks that haven't said anything since the start of day two and I'd really like to see some activity.