By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - Microsoft: “No Reviews of Kinect!”

Legend11 said:

Can I get in on that bet?


http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=117922&page=1&str=1658537271#

hows this?



Around the Network
gergroy said:

lol, I'm not the one betting with you, but it seems like you are trying to get somebody to bet more on holiday promotions rather than an actual price drop due to poor performance of kinect.  


What is a retailer to do when they get suckered into ordering millions of a bad product?



johnglen said:
Ping_ii said:
johnglen said:
Ping_ii said:
johnglen said:

Funny how some people are fishing anything negative on the net , concerning kinect , and starting threads on the MS forum , usually people with ps3 signatures. As if reviews for this kind of games matter , like the wii-sports game that became a phenomenon had glowing reviews.

The kinect train is coming and will crush the ps3 this holiday season, whether some people like it or not.

funny cause you on the other hand are on Psmove threads 24/7 trashing it along with PPL that has xbox on their signitures.

LMAO niggah please you aint a saint you do the same thing on sony thread.

Except i am not trashing move, I AM TALKING NEGATIVELY ABOUT ITS SALES.  I never said move is crap ,on the contrary i actually wrote that i like it , and i never went to sony forum and started crappy threads. As for the niggah stuff, what are you like 5 years old??


sure sure sure.......

yet your mad when ppl discusses something negative about kinect.

niggah quit pretending, your age asking comeback is pretty old and lame gramps.

Seek professional help cause the next few months are going to be very hard for you.

right.......

just like how its very hard for you when PSmove official numbers for EU was revealed right(1.5m)? thats why you couldn't stop hating and making up bullshit like how sony are just deperate for good numbers right?

yeh take your own advice and seek a PROFESSIONAL NOW.



theprof00 said:
Legend11 said:

Can I get in on that bet?


http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/thread.php?id=117922&page=1&str=1658537271#

hows this?


Sounds good. :)



theprof00 said:
daroamer said:
theprof00 said:
Adobo said:
theprof00 said:
Adobo said:
theprof00 said:

Anyone wanna make a bet with me?

sub 100$ kinect by christmas.


I will because their freaking N wireless accessory never get down from $99...  Freaking Apple.. err M$.

Ok, my one condition of the bet though, is that it will be a retailer price-drop. Walmart perhaps, or something like "get 2 games free with kinect purchase.

Or, buy 360, get kinect for free.

cool?

I'll add it to my bet thread if it's cool.

lol occasionally retailers offers some kind of price drop on anything special this comin' holiday, I'm talking about like PS3 did you know...

well, if stores can offer sub 99$ prices for kinect, it implies a wholesale price-cut.

Ok, here's my bet. 

At least one store will offer kinect for free with some kind of purchase.

Like how Sony gave out free PS3s with the purchase of a Bravia TV?

http://www.i4u.com/32180/sony-bravia-hdtv-bundles-free-sony-ps3-sale-amazon

Come on, these kinds of things happen all the time.

well, if it was going to be given away with a tv or a car, i wouldn't have accepted that as winning the bet. That's just over the top daroamer. I'm not "out to get" anyone. Don't be paranoid.

I mean like:

Buy a 360 elite, get kinect free. or say, buy kinect, get 360 arcade free. Buy kinect, get a 150$ giftcard. Something like that.


"At least one store will offer kinect for free with some kind of purchase."

You never specified anything, if you want to someone to bet you might want to clearly stipulate the conditions of what is considered bundling because of Kinect's failure and bundling because of special promotions. 



Around the Network
daroamer said:
theprof00 said:

well, if it was going to be given away with a tv or a car, i wouldn't have accepted that as winning the bet. That's just over the top daroamer. I'm not "out to get" anyone. Don't be paranoid.

I mean like:

Buy a 360 elite, get kinect free. or say, buy kinect, get 360 arcade free. Buy kinect, get a 150$ giftcard. Something like that.


"At least one store will offer kinect for free with some kind of purchase."

You never specified anything, if you want to someone to bet you might want to clearly stipulate the conditions of what is considered bundling because of Kinect's failure and bundling because of special promotions. 

If I were to go through with that, and say that I won a bet because it was offered with a 1000$ tv, I would be seen as a hater, which makes me think that is your impression of me.

Which is why I said, "stop being paranoid".



No reviews, huh . . . I'm not amused, Microsoft. I hope for your sake this isn't because you're releasing anything half-finished.



GOTY Contestants this year: Dead Space 2, Dark Souls, Tales of Graces f. Everything else can suck it.

Shadowblind said:

No reviews, huh . . . I'm not amused, Microsoft. I hope for your sake this isn't because you're releasing anything half-finished.

I totally agree snowblind



bobbert said:
Reasonable said:

Basically I don't agree with the whole policy of review embargos.  Be it films, games, or whatever.  It simply defeats the whole purpose of reviews and giving the consumer visibility to information on what they are considering purchasing.

 

OP said:

The gaming press complains about not being sent review copies...

 


They are NOT preventing anyone from reviewing it. They just have not sent out the finished product yet, just like Gran Turismo 5 has not been sent out yet. The product is still in testing and NOT finished yet. If someone really wanted to review a game, they can drive to Macy's and test it out for an hour. How are people complaining about how the kinect sucks in every other thread if there hasn't been a review yet? It's just the reviews have been on test demos. If they sent every game reviewer a kinect right now, they would still be getting a test version of the software. People are blowing this way out of proportion.

I agree, movies can be reviewed a couple weeks ahead of time because they should have finished editing the movie by then. The problem is, instead of finishing the product and then announcing a release date, they finished the hardware, and announced a release date and are producing them to be shipped right now. The software that drives it is continually being upgraded and I'm sure once it's in a near-final state it will be sent to reviewers. Even Oprah's audience was told that it would be shipped to them by November 4. The software demos everyone is using is showing off a single game that has been finalized. Not a full xbox dashboard and 17 games.

Sorry, that doesn't cut it for me.

A review of hardware like Kinect is a review where the reviewer has the hardware and can test it in various scenarios, not in some mall that's been set up by the supplier.  That's a review.  Not the reviewer queing to try it at Macy's.

Two, while I know MS are continuing to work on Kinect with one month to go the hardware for launch has to be set.  Otherwise they are not behaving sensibly and risk releasing something buggy.

I don't get any need to hide Kinect though as it's been tested lots anyway and clearly the basic tech seems to work.

As for the games, that's where they seem to be playing coy and the main focus for me.  Again, unless they are risking releasing buggy titles, most games should be locked in now this close to launch, or very, very close to it.  In short, unless they are rushing the games to market - which I wouldn't support for other reasons - then there is no way they shouldn't be able to get reviewers copies of the games.

I actually don't think MS is looking to do much except avoid some low scores for the games in the same manner that some Move titles got, at least in the sense they won't be available at launch, but I don't like that and it simply destroys the whole notion of a valuable review.

The bottom line is they do seem to be tawdry in gettings games into reviewers hands (and by extension slow to get them the hardware, too).



Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...

theprof00 said:
Shadowblind said:

No reviews, huh . . . I'm not amused, Microsoft. I hope for your sake this isn't because you're releasing anything half-finished.

I totally agree snowblind




GOTY Contestants this year: Dead Space 2, Dark Souls, Tales of Graces f. Everything else can suck it.